Abraham Loeb and coauthors asked if interstellar object 3I/ATLAS is alien technology; telescopes measure a comet. The object was found on 1 July 2025 on a hyperbolic path from outside the Solar System. Loeb's papers keep a technological origin open as a hypothesis and rank the object on a scale of anomalies, while observing teams and the space agencies report a coma of gas and dust and call it a comet.
Discovery, July 2025
A discovery paper by Darryl Seligman and colleagues, posted on 3 July 2025, reports that the object, 3I/ATLAS or C/2025 N1 (ATLAS), was discovered on 2025 July 1 UT. It gives an orbital eccentricity of about 6.1, a perihelion of about 1.36 au, an inclination of about 175 degrees, and a hyperbolic velocity of about 58 km per second. Deep stacked images from the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope and the Very Large Telescope resolve a compact coma. The visible and near-infrared spectral slope is comparable to other interstellar objects and to primitive solar system bodies, comets and D-type asteroids. The paper notes that the object would be observable through early September 2025, then too close to the Sun to observe from Earth near perihelion, when its activity was likely to peak, and observable again from the ground in late November 2025; spacecraft at Mars, it says, could observe it in the gap.
Seligman et al., "Discovery and Preliminary Characterization of a Third Interstellar Object: 3I/ATLAS": https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.02757
NASA's record
NASA says the NASA-funded ATLAS survey telescope in Rio Hurtado, Chile, first reported observations of comet 3I/ATLAS to the Minor Planet Center on 1 July 2025, and that pre-discovery observations from three ATLAS telescopes and the Zwicky Transient Facility extend back to 14 June 2025. Astronomers class it as interstellar because of the hyperbolic shape of its orbit; traced into the past, it clearly originates outside the Solar System. NASA says it posed no threat to Earth, coming no closer than about 1.8 au. A Hubble image of 21 July 2025 showed a teardrop-shaped cocoon of dust coming off the icy nucleus, and observations as of 20 August put the nucleus at no more than 5.6 kilometers across and perhaps as small as 440 meters. NASA lists more than a dozen of its missions that observed the comet, among them Hubble, Webb, SPHEREx, Perseverance, and Parker Solar Probe.
NASA, Comet 3I/ATLAS: https://science.nasa.gov/solar-system/comets/3i-atlas/
The technology hypothesis
In a paper posted on 16 July 2025, Adam Hibberd, Adam Crowl, and Loeb wrote that 3I/ATLAS "has displayed various anomalous characteristics." Describing the work "as largely a pedagogical exercise," they "hypothesize that this object could be technological, and possibly hostile as would be expected from the 'Dark Forest' resolution to the 'Fermi Paradox'." They wrote that it passes surprisingly close to Venus, Mars, and Jupiter, with a probability of no more than about 0.005 percent, and that the low retrograde tilt of its orbital plane offers benefits to an extraterrestrial intelligence. They wrote that its eclipse by the Sun as seen from Earth at perihelion would allow a "clandestine reverse Solar Oberth Manoeuvre," and that an optimal intercept of Earth would mean arrival in late November or early December 2025. They added that a non-gravitational acceleration of about 5.9 x 10^-5 au per day squared, normalized at 1 au from the Sun, would indicate an intent to intercept Jupiter and to rendezvous with it after perihelion.
Hibberd, Crowl, and Loeb, "Is the Interstellar Object 3I/ATLAS Alien Technology?": https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.12213
The Loeb Scale
In a paper posted on 6 August 2025, Omer Eldadi, Gershon Tenenbaum, and Loeb proposed the Loeb Scale, formally the Interstellar Object Significance Scale, a 0 to 10 system that extends the Torino Scale. Levels 0 to 3 cover natural phenomena, levels 4 to 7 increasingly anomalous traits, and levels 8 to 10 are reserved for confirmed artificial origin. They rated 1I/'Oumuamua at level 4, 2I/Borisov at level 0, and 3I/ATLAS at level 4.
Eldadi, Tenenbaum, and Loeb, "The Loeb Scale: Astronomical Classification of Interstellar Objects": https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.09167
The coma measured
Martin Cordiner and colleagues reported the first results of a James Webb Space Telescope NIRSpec campaign, taken when the object was 3.32 au from the Sun and inbound. They found a coma dominated by carbon dioxide, with enhanced outgassing toward the Sun, and water, carbon monoxide, carbonyl sulfide, water ice, and dust. The coma's carbon dioxide to water ratio of 7.6 is "among the highest ever observed in a comet," and 4.5 sigma over the trend with distance from the Sun for long-period and Jupiter-family comets. The paper notes that 3I/ATLAS is only the second interstellar object to show a clear coma. They wrote that this fits an intrinsically CO2-rich nucleus, which may mean its ices saw more radiation than Solar System comets, or that it formed near the CO2 ice line in its parent disk.
Cordiner et al., "JWST detection of a carbon dioxide dominated gas coma surrounding interstellar object 3I/ATLAS": https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.18209
ESA's account
The European Space Agency calls 3I/ATLAS the third interstellar object observed, after 1I/'Oumuamua in 2017 and 2I/Borisov in 2019, and says "its shape and behaviour indicate that it is a comet: an icy object releasing dust and gas." It says Hubble captured a dust plume from the Sun-warmed side in early August 2025, that Webb observations in late August revealed carbon dioxide, water, carbon monoxide, carbonyl sulphide, and water ice in the coma, and that the comet reached about 250,000 km per hour at closest approach to the Sun on 29 October 2025. Its closest approach to Earth was about 270 million km on 19 December 2025, when it was on the other side of the Sun, and it posed no danger. ESA turned Mars Express, the ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter, and Juice toward the comet in autumn 2025, and data from the orbiter improved the predicted position by a factor of ten. ESA says the X-ray telescopes XRISM and XMM-Newton saw a diffuse glow around the nucleus, making it the first interstellar comet observed in X-ray light.
ESA, Comet 3I/ATLAS frequently asked questions: https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Space_Science/Comet_3I_ATLAS_frequently_asked_questions
Where the question stands
Loeb's side frames a technological origin as a hypothesis, tests it against the orbit, and places 3I/ATLAS at level 4 of its own scale, short of the levels kept for confirmed artificial objects. The observing papers and agency pages describe a coma of carbon dioxide, water, and dust and classify the object as a comet from outside the Solar System. Both sides point to traits that stand out: Loeb's group to its path past the planets, the observers to a carbon dioxide ratio among the highest seen in any comet.
