Posts say the Challenger crew lived on; NASA's record says the seven died. The Rogers Commission chapter on the accident says all seven crew members perished. A biomedical letter says the ocean impact was beyond crew survivability and that the cause of death cannot be positively determined. A House committee says the accident was not survivable and that it found no sabotage. The cockpit tape ends at about 73 seconds. A 2015 article quotes posts that treat living people with similar names as the crew. The posts and the records do not say the same thing.
The commission's chapter, and the letter on cause of death
Chapter III of the Report of the Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident says flight of mission 51-L began at 11:38 a.m. Eastern Standard Time on 28 January 1986 and ended 73 seconds later in a burn of hydrogen and oxygen that destroyed the external tank and broke the orbiter up. The chapter's next sentence is: "All seven crew members perished." It says the ground temperature was 36 degrees Fahrenheit, 15 degrees colder than any previous launch, and that the last telemetry from Challenger was received 73.618 seconds after launch. At the structural breakup it says the vehicle was at Mach 1.92 and at an altitude of 46,000 feet. The boosters, it says, flew out of the fireball and were destroyed by the range safety officer 110 seconds after launch. The chapter records the deaths. It does not describe a rescue.
Rogers Commission, Volume 1, Chapter III: https://www.nasa.gov/history/rogersrep/v1ch3.htm
On 28 July 1986 NASA released a letter from Joseph P. Kerwin to Rear Admiral Richard H. Truly. Kerwin writes that the findings are inconclusive because the crew compartment's impact with the ocean was so violent that it masked damage from the seconds after the explosion. The letter's conclusions are that the cause of death cannot be positively determined; that the forces at orbiter breakup were probably not enough to cause death or serious injury; and that the crew possibly, but not certainly, lost consciousness in the seconds after breakup from loss of cabin pressure. It estimates the largest acceleration at breakup in a range of 12 to 20 G, briefly, and says medical analysis indicates those accelerations are survivable. It then says the compartment peaked near 65,000 feet and struck the ocean about two minutes and forty-five seconds after breakup at about 207 miles per hour, imposing about 200 G, "far in excess of the structural limits of the crew compartment or crew survivability levels." Four personal egress air packs were recovered, three of them activated; the commander's was not. The seats were in place and occupied at water impact, with harnesses locked. The Armed Forces Institute of Pathology, the letter says, could not determine the cause of death. The letter prints an unsurvivable impact. It does not print a surviving crew.
Kerwin to Truly, released 28 July 1986: https://www.nasa.gov/missions/space-shuttle/sts-51l/challenger-crew-report/
The NASA release that accompanied the letter says the agency is unable to determine positively the cause of death, and that loss of consciousness in the seconds after breakup is possible but not certain. It says the voice tape holds comments by Francis R. Scobee, Michael J. Smith, Ellison S. Onizuka, and Judith A. Resnik from 2 minutes and 5 seconds before launch through loss of data. It says a 17 July 1986 announcement had described the crew as unaware of events before breakup, and that further analysis found the tape's final comment to be the first potential sign of awareness, at the moment data were lost at 73 seconds. Truly's statement in the release says the work has closed that chapter of the loss, and: "We have now turned our full efforts to the future, but will never forget our seven friends who gave their lives to America's space frontier."
NASA release, 28 July 1986: https://www.nasa.gov/missions/space-shuttle/sts-51l/nasa-releases-challenger-transcript-and-report-on-cause-of-death/
A House finding, and the tape
House Report 99-1016, the Committee on Science and Technology's investigation, was approved by the committee on 7 October 1986. The letter of submittal is dated 29 October 1986. Under "Crew survival," the finding is: "In the case of the tragic loss of the Space Shuttle Challenger and her crew on January 28, 1986, the Committee is convinced that the accident was not survivable." A separate finding says the committee is convinced there is no evidence of sabotage, terrorism, or foreign covert action in the loss. The report's altitude is not restated in that finding. Kerwin's letter says the accident happened at 48,000 feet and that the cabin was at that altitude or higher for almost a minute. The commission chapter says 46,000 feet at breakup. Both figures are printed. Neither finding says anyone lived.
House Report 99-1016: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-CRPT-99hrpt1016/pdf/GPO-CRPT-99hrpt1016.pdf
NASA's transcript of the operational recorder names Commander Francis R. Scobee, Pilot Michael J. Smith, Mission Specialist Ellison S. Onizuka, and Mission Specialist Judith A. Resnik as the speakers, from T-2:05 through about T+73 seconds, "when loss of all data occurred." It says Ronald E. McNair, S. Christa McAuliffe, and Gregory B. Jarvis were seated on the middeck, could monitor voice activity, and did not make voice reports. The last lines are, at T+1:10, the commander: "Roger, go at throttle up." At T+1:13 the pilot: "Uhoh." The transcript then prints "LOSS OF ALL DATA." The tape stops. It does not continue with a call from a surviving crew.
Challenger operational recorder transcript: https://www.nasa.gov/missions/space-shuttle/sts-51l/challenger-crew-transcript/
The posts the 2015 article quotes
A Snopes article by Dan Evon and David Mikkelson, published 2 May 2015 and updated 13 February 2023, states the claim it is checking: that the seven astronauts supposedly killed are quietly living in the United States. It quotes a post asking what if most or all of the seven "are still alive and thriving in their new professions," and a further post saying six have doppelgangers, in some cases with the same names, and listing Richard Scobee, Michael J. Smith, Judith Resnick, and Sharon McAuliffe. The article then identifies other people. It describes a Richard Scobee as chief executive of a Chicago firm called Cows in Trees, and says that man was chief executive of The Marketing Edge in Chicago while Francis Richard Scobee was in NASA training. It identifies Carl McNair as Ronald McNair's brother, and Claude Onizuka as Ellison Onizuka's brother. It identifies a Judith Resnik as a Yale law professor who was teaching while the astronaut Judith Resnik was working as an engineer and at NASA. It identifies a Sharon A. McAuliffe as an adjunct professor at Syracuse University College of Law. It says the Social Security Death Index is not a complete list, and that entries for at least four of the crew can be found in it. The article quotes the claim and names the people the posts use. It does not record a living member of the 51-L crew.
Snopes, 2 May 2015, updated 13 February 2023: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/challenger-crew-alive/