In March 2025 Filippo Biondi, Corrado Malanga, and Armando Mei announced that satellite radar had shown what no excavation had: shafts and chambers far beneath the Pyramid of Khafre at Giza. Their press abstract (https://fightingmonarch.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/04/official-khafre-project-press-release.pdf) presents an engineered complex underground. In popular coverage and online the claim has grown into Djed resonance chambers, a lake from local oral tradition, and the Giza Power Plant. Zahi Hawass answered that nothing of the kind exists beneath the pyramid and that no radar was used inside it. Whether satellite radar can see that deep at all is the other half of the dispute. The fight is about a method more than a place: whether vibrations read from radar images can picture rock hundreds of metres down, and who gets to say so without a journal.
The abstract was written for journalists ahead of a conference on 16 March 2025. It says the team used publicly available SAR data from Capella Space and Umbra, processed with software by Biondi that turns the radar signal into phononic information able to detect millimetric displacements of vibrating structures. It reports five structures above Belzoni's chamber with the shape of the so-called Zed above the King's Chamber in Khufu's pyramid, each resolved into five horizontal levels under a sloping roof. These Djed-like Zeds are the claimants' own reading; the abstract does not call them resonance chambers. Below ground it reports eight hollow cylindrical structures in two parallel north-south rows, wrapped in descending spiral pathways, reaching 648 metres and merging into two cubic structures about 80 metres a side. It then describes structures across the plateau about two kilometres down, and names excavation as a later step to verify their artificial nature. It is a press abstract, not a journal paper. The lake, the oral tradition, and the Giza Power Plant of popular retellings are not in it.
The method has a published past. In 2022 Biondi and Malanga posted a paper (https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.00811) that went on to appear in the journal Remote Sensing. It concerns the Great Pyramid, which they call Khnum-Khufu, not Khafre. Its abstract opens by granting the obstacle: radar waves penetrate solid bodies poorly, so imaging normally covers only surfaces. Their answer is to analyse micro-movements of the pyramid driven by background seismic waves, read from a series of COSMO-SkyMed images, and to claim full 3D tomography of the interior and subsurface, with structures never discovered before. In the arXiv wording the pyramid becomes "transparent like a crystal" in the micro-movement domain. That is their paper and their method claim, not an independent confirmation of anything under Khafre.
The satellites matter. The Italian Space Agency (https://www.asi.it/en/earth-science/cosmo-skymed/) describes COSMO-SkyMed, run with the Ministry of Defence, as a constellation of radar satellites operating in the X-band, able to see through clouds and without sunlight. It is built for high-resolution imaging of the surface.
NASA's Earthdata explainer (https://www.earthdata.nasa.gov/learn/earth-observation-data-basics/sar) sets out the standard physics. Wavelength determines how far a radar signal penetrates a medium. The X-band, about 3 centimetres, is listed for high-resolution work with little penetration into vegetation; longer L-band and P-band waves go deeper. The explainer notes that archaeologists use SAR to find features hidden by vegetation or desert sand. Nothing there describes imaging hundreds of metres of limestone. Biondi and Malanga do not say the waves travel that far; they say surface vibration carries the information. That claim, not the radar band, is what would need independent testing.
Hawass set out his response on his own site in a statement dated 26 March (https://www.hawasszahi.com/news/a-statement-from-dr-zahi-hawass-re-the-khafre-project). He calls the columns fabrications by people with no expertise in Egyptian civilization or the pyramids. He says the Supreme Council of Antiquities granted them no permit to work inside the pyramid, that no radar devices have been used inside it, and that no archaeological missions are working there. He adds that Khafre's base was carved from bedrock to about 8 metres and that recent studies show no columns beneath it. He also treats the claims as attempts to diminish Egyptian civilization, a framing recorded here as his.
The 2022 paper did not stand. Retraction Watch (https://retractionwatch.com/2026/08/31/retraction-corridors-inside-great-pyramid-giza/) reported that Remote Sensing, which had published it in October 2022, retracted it on 10 August 2026 after a reader raised concerns about its methods. Quoting the notice, it says the editors confirmed serious methodological flaws and statistical errors judged to undermine the paper's conclusions, and that the authors disagreed with the retraction. It also quotes Lawrence Conyers, an archaeological radar specialist, who says such micro-vibrations are far below what a satellite can detect, and notes that the 2025 Khafre claims have not been published or peer-reviewed. The retracted paper is the Khufu study; the Khafre material is a press abstract, with no journal paper of its own to judge.
Biondi, Malanga, and Mei say radar vibration analysis shows eight hollow shafts plunging 648 metres beneath Khafre into two cubic chambers, with more structures two kilometres down. Their 2025 abstract was written for a press conference, not a journal. The 2022 Khufu paper behind the method concedes that radar barely penetrates solid bodies, used X-band COSMO-SkyMed images, and has since been retracted for methodological flaws and statistical errors, over the authors' disagreement. NASA ties penetration to wavelength. Hawass says no radar worked inside the pyramid and no columns lie under its bedrock base. The shafts remain an unverified claim.
What Stays Contested
On these pages: a March 2025 press abstract claiming shafts, spiral paths, and cubic chambers under Khafre; a 2022 paper on Khufu that admits radar's poor penetration and proposes vibration tomography; X-band satellites built for surface imaging; Hawass's denial of permits, radar work, and columns; a retraction the authors dispute. Left open: whether the vibration method can measure anything deep, which only independent tests with published data could settle. No hidden city is baptized, and no researcher is mocked.
