Adherents say John Hutchison's fields lift metal; the Army found no records of 1983 work its officer says it paid for. Between 1999 and 2000, Army intelligence answered a Freedom of Information requester with "no record" letters and called a 1991 letter about a classified report a forgery; John Alexander, the officer named in that work, then told the Energy Department that the Army had paid contractors to work with Hutchison around 1983, that a report was written, and that the Army's copy no longer exists. Critics add a second dispute: Hutchison first said a line visible in one levitation video was part of his apparatus, then said he had been "creative" with the footage because he could not reproduce the effect after 1991. Government letters spell his name both Hutchison and Hutchinson.
The claim on the inventor's site
The semi-official Hutchison site, built by Andrew Johnson with Hutchison's agreement, says that in 1979 high-voltage gear Hutchison was using to study Nikola Tesla's work made heavy metal levitate and shoot toward the ceiling, and some pieces shred. It lists lift effects on objects from a few grams to about 750 kg, fusing of wood and metal, steel bars turning to dust, and effects up to about 300 feet away. It says a Los Alamos group contacted him in 1983 on behalf of the US government, naming George Hathaway, Alex Pezzaro, Col. John Alexander, Bob Friedberge and John Rink, and that he was told the videotapes of that work are no longer available. It says government officials took his lab equipment in 1989 while he was in Germany, and that FOIA requests in 2004 and 2005 released nothing of value.
Semi-official Hutchison site, "About": https://www.thehutchisoneffect.com/wp/2009/09/02/about/
A 2004 profile
The Guardian reported in 2004 that Hutchison worked from a Vancouver flat filled with homemade Tesla coils, Van de Graaff generators and radio-frequency gear. It said that in 1979 a steel bar rose from the floor and dropped, and that the next night nothing happened. It reported that the US military visited in 1983 and diverted money to keep his experiments going, and that in 1984 a team set up at the lab to study the effects under controlled conditions; nothing happened, and the team, the paper wrote, allegedly lost interest. It said his films are usually shot in close-up, making fraud hard to rule out, though he "has never been caught."
The Guardian, "Breaking the laws," 2004: https://www.theguardian.com/education/2004/oct/28/research.highereducation
The letters Hutchison kept
A file of letters on the semi-official site opens with a typed letter dated March 1991 on Army Intelligence and Security Command letterhead, saying it understood Hutchison had received slides of his work taken by Los Alamos in June 1983, and that "the report is classified." In October 1991 the Army Materiel Command's public affairs chief, Col. Douglas H. Rogers, wrote that outside of Dr. Alexander he knew of no other place to try. A Los Alamos letter of September 1991 answered his request for a report prepared by John B. Alexander, a lab employee, by pointing to a letter Alexander had sent him on September 10, 1991. In 1995 NASA aerospace engineer Marc G. Millis wrote that he understood the effects were hard to reproduce at will and asked whether any had been made completely repeatable. In 1998 Hal Fox wrote that Ken Shoulders had reproduced "one small piece" of the phenomena.
Hutchison correspondence file: https://www.thehutchisoneffect.com/docs/Hutch%20Letters2.pdf
The FOIA answers, 1999-2000
Requester Brian Allan's file holds the agencies' replies. On October 21, 1999, INSCOM's FOIA chief, Russell A. Nichols, wrote that no records responsive to the Hutchinson Effect were located. On November 30, 1999, after Allan sent the March 1991 letter, Nichols wrote again that no records were found and that the letter "is a forgery. It was not created by this office nor was it authorized by this office." The Army Space and Missile Defense Command also found nothing. On May 8, 2000, the Energy Department's Albuquerque office wrote that Los Alamos had never employed Hutchison and that Alexander worked there from 1988 to 1995. It relayed Alexander's account: in 1983 or so he, through the Army, paid a contractor, Alex Pizzara and George Hathaway, to work with Hutchison; a report was written by John Rink and Robert Freeman; it is no longer available at Los Alamos; and he knows for certain the Army's copy no longer exists.
FOIA correspondence of Brian Allan, 1999-2000: https://www.teflonrabbit.com/pdf-downloads/219
The critics' case
Damn Interesting wrote that criticism of Hutchison's work stems from a shortage of impartial third-party observations and from the fact that the effect has not been reproduced elsewhere, even by Hutchison. It described a skeptics' suggestion that a ceiling electromagnet and an upside-down camera could make falling objects appear to rise. It reported a video made for a television special in which a string is visible over a levitating toy UFO, moving in step with it. Hutchison, it said, first called it a wire that was part of the apparatus, and later said he had been "creative" with the footage because he had not been able to reproduce the effect since 1991.
Damn Interesting, "The Hutchison Effect": https://www.damninteresting.com/retired/the-hutchison-effect/
Hutchison's later account
In an interview with Tim Ventura published by the Alternative Propulsion Engineering Conference, Hutchison described levitation, metals turning to a jelly-like state, and objects vanishing and returning, and said a 1983 Los Alamos experiment affected objects up to 300 feet away. The summary says Ken Shoulders and Richard Hull replicated some aspects but that full replication remains elusive, and that Hutchison said many failed attempts did not use the original equipment. It says he described a six-hour unclassified report on video whose whereabouts are uncertain, and that the research largely ended around 2003-2004.
Alternative Propulsion Engineering Conference, Hutchison interview: https://www.altpropulsion.com/the-hutchison-effect-the-john-hutchison-interview/
Where the record stands
What adherents cite is Hutchison's films, his metal samples, letters from officials, and witnesses who saw demonstrations. What the government file shows is a denial of records, a charge of forgery against the one letter that called a report classified, and an officer's account that the Army paid for the work and that the report is gone.
