Adherents of the Atlantis reading look at the Richat Structure in Mauritania and see Plato's city. Plato described a capital of concentric rings of land and water, a plain sheltered by mountains to the north, a channel to the sea, and stone of three colours. The Richat is a set of near-circular rings in the western Sahara, with highlands around it and dry channels nearby. If the climate and coastline have changed since Plato's source described the place, the argument runs, a ringed city could now sit high and dry in a desert. The geology describes how the rings formed and how old they are. The dispute is over whether a resemblance in shape can carry a match in history.
Plato's text is the place to start, and the Perseus Digital Library carries W. R. M. Lamb's translation of the Critias (https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus:text:1999.01.0180:text=Criti.:section=113c). At 113c Poseidon's island has a plain and, about 50 stades from its centre, a low hill. At 113d he cuts "circular belts of sea and land enclosing one another alternately," two of land and three of sea. The later sections give sizes: the central island is five stades across, and the rings run three, three, two, two and one stade wide. A wall stands "at a uniform distance of fifty stades from the largest circle." Lamb's note puts a stade at about 600 feet. The figure of 127 stades that adherents cite comes from adding that wall, on both sides, to the rings. At Lamb's 600 feet, 127 stades is about 23 kilometres, close to the figure adherents give, so the arithmetic holds once the wall is counted. The rings alone, as Plato gives them, come to 27 stades across, roughly five kilometres.
NASA's Earth Observatory describes the formation in plain terms (https://science.nasa.gov/earth/earth-observatory/eyeing-the-richat-structure/). French geographers first described it in the 1930s and called it the Richat "buttonhole." Astronauts Ed White and James McDivitt photographed it on Gemini IV, which helped make "The Eye of the Sahara" a familiar name. The structure is about 40 kilometres wide. It "was initially thought to be an impact crater," but researchers later showed it is "a deeply eroded geologic dome formed by the uplift of rock above an underground intrusion of igneous material." Different rocks eroded at different rates, leaving circular ridges called cuestas.
The European Space Agency's account of its Envisat view gives other measurements (https://www.esa.int/Applications/Observing_the_Earth/The_Richat_structure_Mauritania). ESA calls it a "50-km-diameter circular" feature, "more clearly observed from space than from down on the ground." It describes concentric bands of resistant quartzite forming ridges with valleys of softer rock between them, a sedimentary plateau standing about 200 metres above the surrounding sand, and the outer rim's peak at some 485 metres above sea level. The image was taken on 21 June 2003 at 300 metres resolution. The width depends on where one draws the edge, which is why NASA and ESA give different figures. Both say the rings are rock, not walls or canals, and both note that the structure was once taken for an impact site.
The age comes from the rocks themselves. Guillaume Matton, Michel Jébrak and James Lee published "Resolving the Richat enigma: Doming and hydrothermal karstification above an alkaline complex" in Geology in 2005 (https://archipel.uqam.ca/272/1/Matton_etal05.pdf). They describe a dome at least 40 kilometres across in Late Proterozoic to Ordovician rocks, eroded into "three nested rings dipping outward," with a central breccia intruded by ring dikes, kimberlites and alkaline volcanic rocks. Early workers had cited the crater-like shape as evidence of an impact. The authors report an average 40Ar/39Ar age of 98.2 ± 2.6 million years for the alkaline activity. The black, white and red stones that adherents match to Plato's quarries are, in this paper, the sedimentary and igneous rocks of that complex.
Adherents are right that the Sahara has not always been dry, and that point is documented. Nick Drake and colleagues, writing in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in 2011 (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3021035/), show that "during the Holocene humid period the region contained a series of linked lakes, rivers, and inland deltas comprising a large interlinked waterway." The system was last active in the early Holocene, and dated lake sediments show a "green Sahara" during the last interglacial, about 125,000 years ago. Water and wildlife did once reach places that are desert now, and people followed them. A wetter Sahara is a long way from a sea-going harbour city, and the paper does not place one at the Richat.
The human record near the Richat is also documented, and it is younger. UNESCO's World Heritage listing for the Ancient Ksour of Ouadane, Chinguetti, Tichitt and Oualata (https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/750/) says these towns were "founded in the 11th and 12th centuries to serve the caravans crossing the Sahara," with houses crowded along narrow streets around mosques. ESA's account notes that Ksour in the vicinity of the structure were inscribed in 1996. These towns are the archaeology the region is known for. None of the sources reports a buried ringed city at the Richat itself.
Taken together, the Richat comparison rests on a real likeness of outline and on a real history of a greener Sahara. The rings are cuestas of folded and eroded rock around an igneous complex about a hundred million years old, and they are several times larger than the rings Plato describes. The nearby settlements that do exist are medieval caravan towns, founded some fourteen centuries after Plato wrote his dialogues.
What Stays Contested
Plato's Atlantis may be allegory, memory or invention, and that question is open to readers. The narrower claim that the Richat is the ringed city depends on stretching Plato's 27 stades of rings to include his outer wall, and on treating geological ridges as built ones. Field geology and dating describe a natural dome, and no excavation report in these sources describes a city in its rings. Adherents who want to test the idea would need dated human remains or worked stone from inside the structure itself.
