Genome papers read human chromosome 2 as a fusion of two ape chromosomes; creationist researchers dispute that reading. Humans carry 46 chromosomes and apes 48; the papers say two ancestral chromosomes that stayed separate in other primates fused head-to-head in the human line. A 1991 paper found inverted telomere repeats in band 2q13, a 2002 paper sequenced the region around them, and a 2005 paper that finished the chromosome's sequence calls it the product of a head-to-head fusion. Creationist pages at Answers Research Journal, the Institute for Creation Research, and Answers in Genesis say the site is a working part of a gene, not the scar of a fusion.
The 1991 PNAS paper
J. W. IJdo and colleagues, in "Origin of human chromosome 2: an ancestral telomere-telomere fusion," Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 15 October 1991, report two allelic cosmids from human chromosome 2, c8.1 and c29B, each containing two inverted arrays of the vertebrate telomeric repeat in a head-to-head arrangement, 5'(TTAGGG)n-(CCCTAA)m3'. They say the flanking sequences are characteristic of present-day human pretelomeres and hybridize both to band 2q13 and to subsets of human chromosome ends. They conclude: "the locus cloned in cosmids c8.1 and c29B is the relic of an ancient telomere-telomere fusion and marks the point at which two ancestral ape chromosomes fused to give rise to human chromosome 2."
IJdo et al., PNAS, 1991: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC52649/
The 2002 Genome Research paper
Yuxin Fan and colleagues, in "Genomic structure and evolution of the ancestral chromosome fusion site in 2q13–2q14.1 and paralogous regions on other human chromosomes," Genome Research (2002), open: "Human chromosome 2 was formed by the head-to-head fusion of two ancestral chromosomes that remained separate in other primates." They analyze more than 600 kb around the site and report 789 bp of degenerate telomere repeats in two head-to-head arrays. They write that the 1991 observation indicated the two ancestral chromosomes had joined end-to-end within the terminal telomeric repeats, "with subsequent inactivation of one of the two centromeres." They also ask the question the dispute turns on: "why are the arrays at the fusion site so degenerate?" They report the arrays 14% diverged from canonical telomere repeats, against under 1.5% divergence in noncoding sequence since chimpanzees and humans split. They offer three explanations, a join near but not at the ends, rapid decay after the fusion, or sequencing error, and say the evidence supports the second.
Fan et al., Genome Research, 2002: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC187548/
The 2005 Nature paper
The Europe PMC record for "Generation and annotation of the DNA sequences of human chromosomes 2 and 4," by L. W. Hillier and colleagues in Nature (vol. 434, pages 724–731, 2005), prints the paper's abstract. It opens: "Human chromosome 2 is unique to the human lineage in being the product of a head-to-head fusion of two intermediate-sized ancestral chromosomes." It says the paper presents approximately 237 million base pairs of sequence for chromosome 2, part of more than 99.6% of the euchromatic sequence of the two chromosomes, and identifies 1,346 protein-coding genes and 1,239 pseudogenes on chromosome 2. It says the analyses "expand our understanding of the structure and evolution of mammalian chromosomes, including gene deserts, segmental duplications and highly variant regions."
Hillier et al., Nature, 2005 (Europe PMC record with abstract): https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/article/MED/15815621?resultType=core&format=json
The Answers Research Journal paper
Jeffrey P. Tomkins's "Alleged Human Chromosome 2 'Fusion Site' Encodes an Active DNA Binding Domain Inside a Complex and Highly Expressed Gene—Negating Fusion," published in Answers Research Journal on October 16, 2013, says all known fusions in extant mammals involve satellite DNA and breaks at or near centromeres. It calls the telomeric signature very small, about 800 bases, and highly degenerate given the supposed 3 to 6 million years of divergence. It says the site, read on the minus strand, is a functional DNA binding domain inside the first intron of the DDX11L2 gene, expressed in at least 255 cell or tissue types. It says a previously documented 614 Kb region around the site lacks gene correspondence with chimpanzee chromosomes 2A and 2B, and that the evidence "thoroughly refutes" the fusion claim.
Tomkins, Answers Research Journal, 2013: https://answersresearchjournal.org/alleged-human-chromosome-2-fusion-site/
The Institute for Creation Research summary
Tomkins's ICR article of November 27, 2013, says the fusion idea was first proposed from similar staining patterns in human and chimpanzee chromosomes. It says the 1991 sequence was "unexpectedly small in size and extremely degenerate," and that a telomere-telomere fusion, if real, would be the first documented case in nature. It says the site sits in the middle of a gene first classified as a pseudogene and is read in the reverse direction as a regulatory switch. It concludes that the site "is not a degenerate fusion sequence" but has been "a functional feature in an important gene" since creation.
Jeffrey P. Tomkins, Institute for Creation Research, 2013: https://www.icr.org/content/new-research-debunks-human-chromosome-fusion
Answers in Genesis, 2021
Avery Foley's article "Unraveling the Chromosome 2 Connection," dated March 21, 2021, says chimpanzee chromosomes 12 and 13 were renamed 2a and 2b because of their banding likeness to human chromosome 2. It quotes the Genome Research question, "Why are the [telomere sequences] at the fusion site so degenerate?" It says thousands of telomere repeats should be present where only a few hundred are found, and that a gene sits at the site. It says the proposed second centromere is 90% smaller than a working one, holds sequences not unique to centromeres, and contains a gene, and it quotes Tomkins that this "completely refutes the idea that it's a defunct centromere."
Avery Foley, "Unraveling the Chromosome 2 Connection," Answers in Genesis: https://answersingenesis.org/genetics/unraveling-chromosome-2-connection/
The papers and the dispute
The three papers read the same features as a fusion: head-to-head telomere arrays at 2q13 and, in the 2002 paper's words, the inactivation of one of the two centromeres. The 2002 paper itself calls the arrays degenerate and gives its reasons. The creationist pages take up that same degeneracy, the small size of the site, a gene at the site, and the state of the second centromere, and read them as design rather than fusion. The dispute is between those two readings of one stretch of chromosome 2.
