A 1969 rumor said Paul McCartney had died and been replaced; press doors print the claim and print denials. Album details are called clues in some of those doors. A station history, a campus paper, a Beatles feature, a LIFE interview page, a later magazine article, and a BBC culture piece do not record a death. They do not even date the LIFE cover the same way. Each denial stays inside the door that prints it.
A Detroit call, as a station history tells it
A Keener 13 history dated 12 October 2008 describes 12 October 1969, when Russ Gibb, on WKNR-FM, took a Sunday call in Detroit from Eastern Michigan University student Tom Zarski. The page says Zarski wanted to talk about McCartney being dead and about clues, including playing Revolution Number Nine backwards, and that the audience then heard "Turn me on, dead man." It says Fred LaBour heard the broadcast and that his Michigan Daily piece of 14 October, a record-review parody, helped carry the story past the local market, and that LaBour admitted to Gibb that much of the article was pure fabrication. A recollection the page prints, from Ken R. Deutsch, says a call to Apple Records' press office brought the answer that McCartney was quite alive and had been in the office that afternoon. The page says the American peak was the 7 November LIFE edition, after a crew found a farm in Scotland. The caller's claim and that press-office denial sit in the same history.
Keener 13, 12 October 2008: https://keener13.org/?p=183
Clues a campus paper prints, and an admission it also prints
The Harvard Crimson of 23 October 1969, "Clues Do Not a Dead Man Make," says the craze started on 12 October when Russ Gibbs of WKNR-FM in Dearborn aired death clues. It says Fred LaBour's Michigan Daily article of 14 October began by stating that Paul McCartney was killed in an automobile accident in early November 1966, and it attributes to LaBour a tale that the others created a false Paul McCartney. The Crimson then says LaBour has admitted the entire story was a product of his imagination and only a working hypothesis. It still prints clues: a voice at the end of "Strawberry Fields Forever" which it says says "I buried Paul"; a black carnation against red ones; an "O.P.D." patch which it says could as easily be "O.P.P.," Ontario Provincial Police; and Abbey Road, barefoot and out of step, with a Volkswagen plate 28IF. On that plate the Crimson says the reading would matter more if it were true, which it is not, because the age would be 27 rather than 28. Both the clues and the admission are the article's. Neither is scored as a closed end.
Harvard Crimson, 23 October 1969: https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1969/10/23/clues-do-not-a-dead-man/
A 1967 "false rumour," and LIFE dated 7 November
The Beatles Bible feature prints a February 1967 Beatles Book Monthly paragraph headed "FALSE RUMOUR": on 7 January a rumor swept London of a fatal crash on the M1, and there was absolutely no truth in it, as the press officer found by telephone. The feature dates later momentum to 12 October 1969 and a call to Russ Gibb. The caller, identified only as Tom, claimed a death and told Gibb to play "Revolution 9" backwards, where "number nine" was heard as "turn me on, dead man." It says that on 22 October, from a Scottish farm, a statement was given to Peter Brown for the press, borrowing Mark Twain: rumors of my death have been greatly exaggerated. An edition of LIFE dated 7 November 1969, the feature says, repeats that paraphrase and adds that if he was dead he would be the last to know. The cover words it prints are "The case of the 'missing' Beatle – Paul is still with us." It also notes a 1993 album title, Paul Is Live, with a plate it describes as 51 IS.
Beatles Bible feature: https://www.beatlesbible.com/features/paul-is-dead/
Lines a LIFE page prints
The Paul McCartney Project page for the LIFE interview says it was recorded on 2 November 1969 and published on 7 November 1969, Dorothy Bacon interviewing, under a title it gives as the case of the missing Beatles, Paul is still with us. It says interviews were agreed as the rumors intensified, including the BBC and the Sunday People on 24 October, and LIFE. It prints a comment it attributes to the magazine: perhaps the rumor started because there had not been much press lately; there is not enough time; the people making up the rumors should worry about themselves instead of worrying whether the subject is dead or not. Another passage says the speaker would rather make music, and that the Beatle thing is over, exploded partly by what the group had done and partly by other people. Its LIFE date is 7 November, which is not every other door's date.
Paul McCartney Project, LIFE page: https://www.the-paulmccartney-project.com/interview/the-case-of-the-mising-beatles-paul-is-still-with-us/
A later article, and a LIFE date of 9 November
Rolling Stone's article by Rob Sheffield describes Gibb on WKNR on 12 October 1969, a caller, "Revolution 9" backwards, and "Turn me on, dead man." It states the rumor as fans carried it: a 1966 crash, a hidden death, a look-alike, a barefoot figure on Abbey Road, and a plate 28IF, which the article says would fit an age of 28, noting that he was 27. It prints a 1974 interview line: someone from the office rang up and said "you're dead," and the reply printed is "I don't agree with that." It prints Apple press officer Derek Taylor, via Richard DiLello, that the McCartney who wrote "And I Love Her" is still alive and has a lot to write. It prints John Lennon, calling the Detroit station on 26 October, calling it the most stupid rumor he had ever heard. On LIFE, this article says the November 9 cover story was titled "Paul McCartney Is Still With Us," and that a line in it said the Beatles thing is over. November 9 is this article's date. The project page and the Bible feature print 7 November. The date clash stays. The article's statement that the replacement claim was not true is that article's, not a slur on a reader still looking at a printed clue.
Rolling Stone, Sheffield: https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/paul-mccartney-is-dead-conspiracy-897189/
The BBC's shorter telling
A BBC Culture article of 3 October 2014 says that in 1969 rumors spread among American college students that McCartney had died in 1966 and had been replaced by a lookalike, and that clues had been left. It says a caller to a Detroit station in October 1969 argued that "turn me on, dead man" could be heard when Revolution 9 was played backwards. That is the article's summary of the claim. It does not print the LIFE denial the other doors print, and it does not print a medical finding.
BBC Culture, 3 October 2014: https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20141003-the-hidden-messages-in-songs
Beside the rumor
The six doors print a 1969 claim that a death had been hidden. They also print, depending on the door, LaBour's admission that his accident story was imagination, a press-office denial, a 1967 "false rumour" note, a Twain line, LIFE lines dated either 7 November or 9 November, a 1974 "I don't agree," and Taylor's sentence that the writer is still alive. No door here is a death certificate. No door here is scored as an order to stop reading a clue that same door has printed.