Mohamed Al Fayed called Diana's death murder; French judges, Operation Paget and the 2008 inquest found otherwise.
The crash in the Pont de l'Alma underpass in Paris on 31 August 1997 killed Diana, Princess of Wales, Dodi Al Fayed and their driver Henri Paul. The record runs through a French judicial investigation and its appeals, a Scottish court ruling, the Metropolitan Police's Operation Paget report of December 2006, and the London inquest that ended on 7 April 2008. Beside it stand the claims of Mohamed Al Fayed, Dodi's father, as courts, police and reporters printed them.
The French investigation, 1999
La Dépêche du Midi reported on 4 September 1999 that the Paris examining magistrates Hervé Stéphan and Marie-Christine Devidal granted a general dismissal to the nine photographers and the press motorcyclist placed under investigation for involuntary homicide and failure to assist persons in danger, in line with the prosecutor's submissions of 17 August. The judges found that the accident was due to Paul's "state of intoxication" and the high speed at which he drove. The paper reported that Mohamed al-Fayed, convinced that his son was the victim of a plot by the British secret services, would appeal, and that the white Fiat Uno linked to the crash was never found.
La Dépêche du Midi, 4 September 1999: https://www.ladepeche.fr/article/1999/09/04/230903-non-lieu-pour-les-photographes.html
The last French appeal, 2002
An Associated Press report carried by CBS News on 4 April 2002 says France's highest court, the Court of Cassation, upheld the dismissal of manslaughter charges against the nine photographers and the motorcyclist, rejecting Al Fayed's appeal against Judge Stéphan's ruling of September 1999 that drugs and alcohol taken by Paul, as well as excessive speed, caused the deaths. It says Al Fayed claimed the photographers contributed by chasing the car and forcing Paul to accelerate, and that he had long claimed the deaths were a murder conspiracy plotted by people who disapproved of Diana's relationship with his son. Bodyguard Trevor Rees-Jones survived with severe facial injuries.
CBS News (AP), 4 April 2002: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/photographers-cleared-in-dianas-death/
A Scottish court, 2004
The Guardian reported on 13 March 2004 that Lord Drummond-Young, in the Court of Session in Edinburgh, dismissed Al Fayed's petition, brought after the Scottish executive refused his call for a public inquiry. As the paper prints his case, Al Fayed claimed the secret services had developed a technique for blinding a driver in a tunnel with a stroboscopic flash, and that agents posing as paparazzi used it on Paul. The judge said the petition and its documents "do not disclose an arguable case for the inference that the UK security services were implicated in any way in the death or the surrounding events." The report adds that a French inquiry concluded Paul was under the influence of drink and anti-depressants.
The Guardian, 13 March 2004: https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2004/mar/13/monarchy.gerardseenan
Operation Paget, 2006
The Operation Paget report describes itself as the findings of the criminal investigation into Al Fayed's allegation of conspiracy to murder, an inquiry also requested by the coroner Michael Burgess. It says solicitors for Al Fayed wrote in July 2003 alleging that the crash was murder by a conspiracy of the "Establishment," particularly Prince Philip, who used the "Security Services," and that the French authorities declined to reopen their investigation. It sets out his claims that the couple meant to announce an engagement on 1 September 1997 and that Diana was pregnant, and answers that the evidence, "pathological, scientific, medical and anecdotal showed that the Princess of Wales was not pregnant." It quotes the toxicologist Professor Robert Forrest that Paul's blood alcohol at death was "around 175 mg/100ml." On the intelligence claims it says there was no evidence that either the Secret Intelligence Service or the Security Service watched the Princess, and that MI6 did not know she was in Paris that night.
Operation Paget report, December 2006: https://downloads.bbc.co.uk/news/nol/shared/bsp/hi/pdfs/14_12_06_diana_report.pdf
Al Fayed at the inquest, February 2008
The Guardian reported Al Fayed's evidence to the inquest jury on 18 February 2008. It says he told the court that Diana and Dodi were murdered in a conspiracy begun by the royal family and carried out with the involvement of the security services and others, that Diana told him by telephone she was pregnant, and that the couple called him about their intention to marry an hour before the crash. It says he named the photographer James Andanson as the likely killer, using his Fiat and a strobe light to blind Paul, disputed that Paul was drunk, and said the blood samples showing intoxication were not Paul's. The paper notes that the inquest had heard Andanson was at home, 177 miles south of Paris, at the time of the crash.
The Guardian, 18 February 2008: https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2008/feb/18/diana.monarchy
The verdict, April 2008
The Guardian reported on 7 April 2008 that the jury found, by nine to two, that Diana and Dodi were unlawfully killed by the reckless driving of Henri Paul and of the paparazzi who chased them. The coroner, Lord Justice Scott Baker, had told the jurors they must be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the deaths were caused by gross negligence, a finding equivalent to manslaughter. The jurors agreed unanimously that the couple's not wearing seatbelts and the car's striking a pillar in the Alma tunnel contributed. The paper says the coroner told the jury in his summing-up that there was no evidence of involvement by Prince Philip or MI6. Al Fayed said: "The most important thing is it is murder," and that the jury had found unidentified vehicles following the Mercedes.
The Guardian, 7 April 2008: https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2008/apr/07/diana.monarchy
Where the claim stands
Al Fayed's claim, as these doors print it, is murder by MI6 at the behest of the royal family, with a flash fired in the tunnel and Paul's blood samples switched. The French judges found intoxication and speed; the Scottish court found no arguable case against the security services; Operation Paget found no evidence of a pregnancy or of intelligence surveillance; the inquest jury returned unlawful killing by gross negligence in the driving, and the coroner said there was no evidence against Prince Philip or MI6. Al Fayed rejected those findings and kept to his claim.
