Taken in order, the Apollo record confirms the ringing and explains it. The Apollo 12 impact registered for close to an hour, Apollo 13's rocket stage for close to four hours by the UTIG account, and the scientists who measured it attributed the long codas to a dry, fractured crust that scatters energy rather than absorbing it. The comparison to a bell was Ewing's own; the UTIG account says he made it at the announcement of the discovery.