Adherents of the artificial-moon reading look at Saturn's moon Iapetus and see a seam. A ridge runs along its equator for hundreds of kilometres, rising many kilometres above the plains, so that the moon looks like a walnut, or like two halves joined at the middle. Popular retellings compare it to the Death Star. A natural process, the argument runs, should give a gentle equatorial bulge, not a sharp wall that tracks the equator so closely, so a built structure deserves consideration. Planetary scientists agree that the ridge is unusual and still argue about how it formed. The dispute is between a construction reading and a set of natural models that each explain part of the ridge.
The construction reading was set out in 2005 by Richard C. Hoagland in "A Moon with a View," preserved by the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine (https://web.archive.org/web/20110103012826/http://www.enterprisemission.com/moon1.htm). He describes a "baffling, arrow-straight, 12-mile-high (~60,000 foot!) wall" that "precisely bisects the leading hemisphere" and crosses Cassini Regio "over 800 miles in length." He writes that the find "forces serious reconsideration" of the possibility that "it could really be a wall a vast, planet spanning, artificial construct!!" and asks whether "a literal wall -- 12 miles high and 12 miles wide" could be built. He links the moon to Arthur C. Clarke's novel, in which Iapetus hosts an alien Star Gate. That is the claim in its author's words.
The numbers come from the first Cassini look, and NASA's caption for that mosaic is precise about them. The Photojournal entry "Encountering Iapetus," PIA06166, added on 7 January 2005 (https://science.nasa.gov/photojournal/encountering-iapetus/), describes the ridge as "an approximately 20-kilometer wide (12 miles) band." On the left horizon "the peak of the ridge reaches at least 13 kilometers (8 miles) above the surrounding terrain." Along "the roughly 1,300 kilometer (800 mile) length over which it can be traced in this picture, it remains almost exactly parallel to the equator within a couple of degrees." So the twelve miles in the caption is a width, and the length is what could be traced in one image. Later papers, below, put the highest peaks near 20 kilometres, which is about twelve miles of height as well. The caption adds that "the physical origin of the ridge has yet to be explained."
Some scientists look inside the moon for the cause. Leszek Czechowski and Jacek Leliwa-Kopystyński, in Advances in Space Research, volume 42 (https://igf.fuw.edu.pl/en/publications/661/), note that the ridge "extends at least 1400 km along the great circle defined by the equator." They "discuss the possibility that the ridge is a result of extensional forces acting above an ascending current of solid-state convection," and they find "a two-cell pattern of convection is a reasonable explanation." They propose three scenarios: spin-orbit resonance, convection in a low-viscosity interior, and an impact that generates flow. In this view the equatorial position follows from how the interior moved, and the ridge forms where the surface is pulled apart above rising material, rather than as a pile laid on top.
Others look for a cause in orbit. Kevin Walsh, Harold Levison, Amy Barr and Luke Dones presented at the 2011 Lunar and Planetary Science Conference "a scenario that both builds the equatorial ridge and despins Iapetus through an impact-generated disk and satellite" (https://www.lpi.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2011/pdf/2562.pdf). A giant impact puts debris into orbit, forming a ring inside the Roche limit and a satellite outside it. The satellite "rapidly pushes the ring material down to the surface," then tidally evolves outward and slows the moon's spin. They estimate a stripped sub-satellite would hit Iapetus about 88 percent of the time. A ring that falls along the equator would leave material along the equator, and that is what the ridge does.
High-resolution topography has tested the shape. Erika Lopez Garcia, Edgard Rivera-Valentin, Paul Schenk, Noah Hammond and Amy Barr published "Topographic Constraints on the Origin of the Equatorial Ridge on Iapetus" in Icarus in 2014 (https://arxiv.org/abs/1404.2337). They write that the ridge "may be as high as 20 km" and may have formed "by endogenic forces, such as tectonic and convective forces, or exogenic processes such as debris infall." Their analysis "suggests a predominantly triangular morphology, with some ridge face slopes reaching 40 degrees, allowing for an exogenic formation mechanism." Steep, triangular faces are what a pile of fallen debris could produce, and they leave the endogenic models with something to explain.
Whether falling debris can build such a ridge has been simulated. Angela Stickle and James Roberts of the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory reported at the 2017 Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (https://www.hou.usra.edu/meetings/lpsc2017/pdf/1262.pdf) that the ridge extends more than 110 degrees in longitude, roughly 1400 kilometres, with parts rising "as much as 20 km." Using a hydrocode, they modelled ice debris striking ice at 400 metres per second at angles of 1, 3 and 10 degrees. Impacts usually dig craters, but at extremely shallow angles of 3 degrees or less, material is added rather than removed. Their conclusion is that a collapsing debris disk "should have been able to build topography to create a ridge around Iapetus."
The Iapetus ridge is real, long and steep, and its origin is still debated in the published work. Hoagland's twelve miles matches both the band width in the first Cassini caption and the upper height later papers give, so the size is not in dispute; the reading of it is. The natural models place it either above a convection current or under a collapsing ring of debris, and topography and impact simulations now favour the debris idea without settling it.
What Stays Contested
No model yet explains every feature of the ridge, and the endogenic and exogenic camps both publish. The artificial reading asks why a natural feature would track the equator so closely. The ring models give one answer, since debris orbiting in the equatorial plane falls along the equator. Construction would need evidence the images do not show, such as regular structure at the metre scale; the studies report slopes, widths and heights, not masonry.