Adherents of the impossible-geometry reading point to Saturn's north pole, where a six-sided pattern wider than Earth has sat for decades. Fluids, they argue, swirl and break up; they do not hold straight sides and sharp corners. In their telling, scientists first dismissed the Voyager view as a glitch, Cassini then proved it real, and a laboratory needed carefully tuned, unnatural conditions to copy it, so the shape may point to something beyond ordinary weather. The mission and laboratory records describe the same hexagon in detail. The disagreement is over whether a stable geometric jet stream is a mystery of physics or a known kind of wave that is still being worked out.
NASA's Cassini mission overview, "Hexagon in Motion," gives the scale (https://science.nasa.gov/mission/cassini/science/saturn/hexagon-in-motion/). Scientists "first observed the six-sided jet stream when the two Voyager spacecraft passed by Saturn in 1980 and 1981," though the flybys allowed only glimpses of its edge. Cassini's cameras later showed "a stunningly symmetric jet stream about 20,000 miles (30,000 kilometers) across, with winds about 300 mph (500 kph)," spinning around a tight polar vortex. The page explains that Earth's jet streams meander because of uneven heating, land, oceans and mountains, while Saturn "has no solid surface" and a far more uniform composition. It also reports that the hexagon was duplicated in a laboratory tank, and quotes Kevin Baines of JPL: "We can also get squares, octagons and other polygons – it depends on the speed and the different properties of the fluid."
The Photojournal entry "Spring Reveals Saturn's Hexagon Jet Stream," PIA11682, added on 9 December 2009 (https://science.nasa.gov/photojournal/spring-reveals-saturns-hexagon-jet-stream/), records the first full visible-light map as northern spring arrived. It says the hexagon "was originally discovered in images taken by Voyager spacecraft in the early 1980s." Scientists "think the hexagon is a meandering jet stream at 77 degrees north latitude," with "waves that can now be seen radiating from the corners of the hexagon where the jet takes its hardest turns." Infrared images from 2006 showed it "nearly stationary" and likely "an unusually strong pole-encircling planetary wave that extends deep into the atmosphere." A large vortex once proposed as its driver was absent in the new images while the hexagon persisted, which weakened one early explanation and kept the question open.
The laboratory work came from the University of Oxford. Ana Barbosa Aguiar, Peter Read, Robin Wordsworth, Tara Salter and Hiro Yamazaki published "A laboratory model of Saturn's North Polar Hexagon" in Icarus in 2010 (https://people.seas.harvard.edu/~rwordsworth/papers/barbosa2010laboratory.pdf). They note the hexagon "has been observed at 76°N on Saturn since the 1980s (Godfrey, D.A. [1988])" and that "its origin remains unclear." In a 60-centimetre cylinder of water and glycerol on a rotating table, a differentially rotating ring drove a jet that broke into polygons. They propose that the hexagon is a wave mode "caused by the nonlinear equilibration of barotropically unstable zonal jets," and their analysis fits a hexagon in the north and none in the south. The authors describe their set-up as producing polygons "under conditions plausibly similar to those on Saturn, at least in terms of Rossby number," which is the opposite of an unnatural recipe.
Physicists have also asked why the number is six. Gerald Marsh, in "The Enigma of Saturn's North-Polar Hexagon" (https://arxiv.org/abs/1711.00338), starts from the suggestion that the hexagon "is an unusual Rossby wave." To accept that, "one must not only explain how a Rossby wave can be hexagonal in shape, albeit with curved corners, but also why it is hexagonal rather than in the form of some other polygon." He concludes that "a spectrum of Rossby waves with different amplitudes and wavelengths resulting from the velocity profile of the hexagonal jet is likely responsible for its shape." The corners are curved, then, and the polygon is the sum of waves on a jet.
The hexagon reaches higher than once thought. Leigh Fletcher and colleagues, in Nature Communications in 2018 (https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-018-06017-3), traced a warm North Polar Stratospheric Vortex forming as northern summer arrived. Its boundary near 78°N emerged as hexagonal, "suggesting that the Rossby wave responsible for Saturn's long-lived polar hexagon—which was previously expected to be trapped in the troposphere—can influence the stratospheric temperatures some 300 km above Saturn's clouds." The figure adherents quote for depth points downward; this measurement points upward. Both show a structure with real vertical extent.
Deep-atmosphere models now generate polygons without tuning. Rakesh Yadav and Jeremy Bloxham, in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in 2020 (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7322008/), ran a three-dimensional simulation of deep thermal convection that "spontaneously generates giant polar cyclones, fierce alternating zonal flows, and a high-latitude eastward jet with a polygonal pattern." They write that Godfrey analysed the 1981 Voyager 2 data in 1988, and that the hexagon has been "present and relatively unchanged" for at least about 40 years. Their mechanism is "self-organized turbulence in the form of giant vortices" pinching the jet.
Seen across the mission and laboratory records, Saturn's hexagon is a long-lived jet stream near 77°N, about 30,000 kilometres across, with curved corners and winds near 500 kilometres per hour. It was found in Voyager images, mapped by Cassini, reproduced in a rotating tank and generated in a convection model. What remains open is why it lasts and why the north has one and the south does not.
What Stays Contested
The hexagon is still called a mystery by the scientists who study it, and NASA quotes Andrew Ingersoll saying it has lasted "for decades and, who knows, maybe centuries." The models differ on whether a shallow jet or deep convection drives it. That open question is a disagreement among wave explanations. None of the records treats the six sides as a sign of design, and none describes the Voyager images as a glitch.

