The case
In the summer of 1995 livestock found dead in rural Puerto Rico, with throat wounds and seemingly drained of blood, were blamed on a "goat sucker" (Texas Observer). Live Science says the first stories surfaced in March 1995. That August a Canóvanas woman described a long-limbed, earless, spiny-backed creature with huge eyes outside her mother's house, and over 200 reports followed in Puerto Rico (Texas Observer). The page does not use her name. The Texas Observer notes that the film Species was released in the United States and Puerto Rico on 7 July 1995. Early 1995 reports also described an escaped genetics experiment or an alien; these are descriptions recorded in the reports, not findings of the Archive.
In 2000 a hairless canid carcass in Nicaragua was the first body tied to the legend. University anatomists there called it a common dog, likely with mange (Texas Observer, citing Radford). Carcasses turned up in Texas in 2004, 2007 and 2009. In July 2007 a Texas rancher and some neighbours found three carcasses over four days outside her ranch in Cuero (BBC).
The rancher's own words carry one side of the case. The Texas Observer quotes her: "I have now done DNA at five different universities. All of them came back identical. They do not match any animal in the archive." She keeps the carcass, the skull and a taxidermy mount. She says she does not know what it is and is adamant that it is not a normal mangy coyote, and she suggests it may be a rare, naturally hairless kind of coyote.
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the drained animals and the strange carcasses as the work of a blood-drinking predator that science has not catalogued.
The mainstream view
Biologist Mike Forstner of Texas State University told the BBC (3 November 2007): "the DNA sequence is a virtually identical match to DNA from the coyote."
Benjamin Radford (Skeptical Inquirer, 2020; Live Science, 2011; his 2011 book Tracking the Chupacabra) traces the first description to Species, which he says the first witness had seen. He told Live Science: "When you did a necropsy of the chickens and goats that they attacked, they all had normal blood levels." A 2014 case at Ratcliffe, Texas, was read as a raccoon (Live Science, Radford).
The adherents' answer
The rancher's words above are one answer. The other comes from the then mayor of Canóvanas, José Soto, in Primera Hora (22 March 2011). He said Radford "está equivocado" (is wrong), that the first witness told a television show she did see it, and that "hay testigos como un pastor de iglesia que lo vio y un policía que hasta le disparó" (there are witnesses like a church pastor who saw it and a police officer who even shot at it). These are his statements as reported by the paper.