The case
About 10:30 p.m. on 21 April 1977 a 17-year-old driving north on Farm Street in Dover, Massachusetts, with two friends saw a creature by a stone wall. From Joseph Nyman's investigation report, as given by Cellar Walls: "It looked like a baby's body with long arms and legs. It had a big head about the same size as the body, it was sort of melon shaped," with glowing orange eyes "like glass marbles." His friends saw nothing.
About two hours later, around 12:30 a.m. on 22 April, a 15-year-old walking home on Miller Hill Road saw a "very small" figure with a large head that scurried into a gully and gripped a tree (Cellar Walls; Joe Nickell, citing Walter Webb's report). About midnight on 22 to 23 April a 15-year-old girl, driven home by her boyfriend, saw a tan creature crouched by a bridge on Springdale Avenue, with "bright green eyes." The page does not name the witnesses. The MetroWest Daily News (2021) swaps the eye colours, giving green for the first two sightings and orange for the third; this page follows the investigators' report, as given by Cellar Walls and Nickell.
Loren Coleman saw the first witness's sketch at a Dover store and named the creature the Dover Demon (MetroWest; Boston Globe, 2019). He investigated with Joseph Nyman, Ed Fogg and Walter Webb (Cellar Walls). Boston television stations and newspapers, the Associated Press and UPI covered it (MetroWest). In 2025 the Dover Historical Society held an exhibit, "The Dover Demon: Uncovering a Local Legend" (Town of Dover newsletter, October 2025; CBS Boston, 30 October 2025).
The adherents' reading
Coleman told MetroWest: "The eyewitnesses were credible, the incidents flowed naturally." Plotted on a map, he says, the three sightings "follow a meandering stream." He calls it a case where he is comfortable saying, "I don't know."
The mainstream view
A retired Dover police sergeant told MetroWest that the department "didn't put any credence in it" and still thinks it was a high school prank. He said that if the teens saw something, it could have been "a raccoon with mange." MetroWest calls a young moose "the most popular theory." The president of the historical society told MetroWest that his own feelings are mixed: "Is it a space alien or was it a sick animal?"
Joe Nickell (Skeptical Inquirer, 2023) identifies it as a male snowy owl: a large, round, apparently earless head, a beak hidden in bristles, and partly opened wings mistaken for spindly arms. He concedes that the reported height "is excessive for it to have been a snowy owl," which would be no more than about 27 inches, and argues that heights are often exaggerated. He also notes that the driver in the third sighting had heard of the first sighting beforehand.
The adherents' answer
Coleman says yearling moose are not usually forced from their mothers by April and would weigh 500 to 600 pounds, much larger than described, and he says the creature walked on two feet (MetroWest). The first teenage witness, interviewed as an adult in 2021, told MetroWest: "What I saw, it did happen," and says he has passed up chances to profit from it. Both are their own statements.