The case
In summer 1988 a 17-year-old driver said that, as he changed a flat tire at about 2 a.m. near Scape Ore Swamp, four miles south of Bishopville, South Carolina, a creature chased and damaged his car. UPI (19 July 1988) quotes him: "It was green, wet-like, about 7 feet tall and had three fingers, red eyes, skin like a lizard and snakelike scales." The city of Bishopville says three toes on each foot. The date of the first sighting varies between accounts: "July 1988" on the city page, and "several weeks ago" in one UPI version of 19 July, while another version and the 27 July report say he reported it the week before. The first wire report ran on 19 July. The page does not name the driver, who was a minor in 1988.
The city page says he passed a polygraph and that the sheriff and deputies took the report seriously. A deputy had heard talk of the creature for about three weeks. Two men said it chased them from a spring, and a couple found their car's chrome battered and wires pulled out (UPI, 19 July). Deputies found three-toed prints on a dirt road by the swamp, and the sheriff had plaster casts made (UPI, 27 July). By mid-August the story had been on the CBS Evening News (Charleston City Paper, 2008). The city page records hundreds of calls about the creature from as far away as Japan and New Zealand.
The Post and Courier (2022) says the first report was just over 200 words, written by a reporter after the sheriff took her to see the couple's damaged car. Bishopville now holds a Lizard Man festival.
The adherents' reading
Erik Beckjord, founder of the National Cryptozoological Society, told UPI on 27 July 1988: "You're dealing with a skunk ape, which is a colloquial name... You can call it anything you want to, but it's a Bigfoot." That is his 1988 statement. Adherents read the reports as an unknown animal.
The mainstream view
Sheriff Liston Truesdale told UPI on 27 July that he believed the tracks were "a prankster's work" and that the teenager saw something, probably a bear. On 12 August UPI quoted Truesdale saying there is "no such thing" as a Lizard Man, but also: "We've had too many reliable people telling us they've seen something... I think possibly it might have been a bear."
A separate claim in August, by another man who said he had wounded the creature, was withdrawn. He admitted making it up, and the blood and scales he presented came from a fish (UPI, 12 August).
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer with the polygraph result (city page), the three-toed prints, the damaged cars, and other residents who told the sheriff they had seen the creature (UPI, 27 July).