Adherents of the mechanical-sound reading start from a recording made over the deepest ocean on Earth. A call named the Western Pacific Biotwang opens with a deep moan and ends in a metallic, twanging sweep that, to many listeners, sounds less like an animal than like a machine. They argue that its structure is too regular for biology, that it was heard all year, and that the trench is just the kind of hidden, crushing place where unknown intelligent life or automated machinery could operate unseen. The acoustic record names the call, the instruments that heard it, and, since 2024, the animal. The argument is over whether a strange sound in a deep place is a mystery of the deep or a whale.
The name comes from Oregon State University researchers who recorded and analysed the call. Their 2016 announcement (https://news.oregonstate.edu/news/new-complex-call-recorded-mariana-trench-believed-be-baleen-whale) describes a five-part call lasting "between 2.5 and 3.5 seconds," with "deep moans at frequencies as low as 38 hertz and a metallic finale that pushes as high as 8,000 hertz." It was picked up by autonomous ocean gliders that "dive up to 1,000 meters." Sharon Nieukirk, lead author of the study in the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, said "the low-frequency moaning part is typical of baleen whales." The team leaned toward the minke whale because of the call's likeness to the dwarf minke "Star Wars" sound, but said scientists "can't yet be sure." Nieukirk also flagged the year-round recordings as "a mystery."
The source was identified in a NOAA-led study. Ann Allen and colleagues from NOAA's Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, Google and Oregon State published in Frontiers in Marine Science on 18 September 2024 (https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/marine-science/articles/10.3389/fmars.2024.1394695/full). Recapping the glider survey of 2014 and 2015 off Guam, they describe "a complex call lasting 3.5 sec with 5 different parts, starting at 30 Hz and ending with a metallic sound that reaches up to 8000 Hz." Using visual and acoustic surveys in the Mariana Archipelago, "we determined that Biotwangs are produced by Bryde's whales." Machine-learning searches of long-term recordings found a "consistent seasonal presence" in the Marianas and at Wake Island, with occasional detections as far away as the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands and Howland Island near the equator. Calling peaked from February to April and, more strongly, from August to November.
NOAA Fisheries' species profile now lists the call as part of the animal's repertoire (https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/species/brydes-whale). Bryde's whales weigh about 90,000 pounds and reach 40 to 55 feet in length. They live in tropical, subtropical and warm temperate waters "from 40° south to 40° north." The profile notes that they sometimes produce "short, powerful sounds that have low frequencies and sound like 'moans,'" and that "in the central and western North Pacific, Bryde's whales make a unique, complex sound called a 'biotwang.'" The metallic finish adherents hear as machinery is, on this record, the signature of one regional population.
The trench floor has been listened to directly. Robert Dziak and colleagues published "Ambient Sound at Challenger Deep, Mariana Trench" in Oceanography in 2017 (https://tos.org/oceanography/article/ambient-sound-at-challenger-deep-mariana-trench). A hydrophone on a 45-metre mooring, deployed in 2015, recorded continuously for 24 days, with an anchor depth of 10,854.7 metres. "Observed sound sources included earthquake acoustic signals (T phases), baleen and odontocete cetacean vocalizations, ship propeller sounds, airguns, active sonar, and the passing of a Category 4 typhoon." The authors call the deepest point "relatively quiet but... not as acoustically isolated as previously thought." Whales were heard from the bottom, along with ships and storms, nearly eleven kilometres below the surface.
NOAA Ocean Exploration's archived expedition page gives the practical detail (https://archive.oceanexplorer.noaa.gov/explorations/16challenger/welcome.html). The hydrophone was built by NOAA's Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory to withstand "more than 16,000 pounds per square inch." Because the ceramic hydrophone could crack, the mooring was lowered "at no more than five meters per second." It was deployed from the Coast Guard Cutter Sequoia in July 2015, recorded sound from 10 to 32,000 hertz for 23 days, and was recovered in November. This is the instrument behind claims about hydrophones at Challenger Deep, and it is a different instrument from the gliders that heard the Biotwang.
The setting is protected and mapped. NOAA Fisheries' page on the Mariana Trench Marine National Monument (https://www.fisheries.noaa.gov/pacific-islands/habitat-conservation/mariana-trench-marine-national-monument) says the monument covers about 95,216 square miles of submerged lands and waters in the Mariana Archipelago, in three units. It was established by Presidential Proclamation in January 2009 and is managed by NOAA, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and the Commonwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands. The page also notes that the waters above the seafloor in the Volcanic and Trench Units are not included in the monument. In the Trench Unit, what is protected is the deep seafloor, the same terrain on which the Challenger Deep hydrophone was anchored.
Put together, the record shows a call first logged by gliders in 2014 and 2015, described as metallic by the scientists who named it, and traced in 2024 to Bryde's whales seen and heard at the same time. The trench floor itself is noisy with whales, ships, earthquakes and storms. The Biotwang is strange to human ears and ordinary for a whale population in the western North Pacific, which returns to it season after season.
What Stays Contested
Some questions about the call remain open: what Bryde's whales use it for, and why the 2024 study found "seasonal and inter-annual variation in occurrence" that it links to changing ocean conditions. The mechanical reading treats the metallic tone as a sign of machinery. The 2024 study matched the call to whales in view of the survey ship. The trench may still hold sounds nobody has named, but this one has a source observed at sea.