Theories about the deep sea, lost ships, and what lies beneath the waves
On the morning of 31 January 1921 the Coast Guard at Cape Hatteras spotted a five-masted schooner aground on Diamond Shoals with all sails set. When boarders finally reached her days later, the Carroll A. Deering was empty: no crew, no log, no navigation instruments, no boats, food laid out as if for a meal, and three half-starved cats. Five federal departments looked into the case. Washington openly suspected foul play, from pirates to Bolshevik agents, and the case was never closed.
On 5 December 1872 the British brig Dei Gratia found the American brigantine Mary Celeste between the Azores and Portugal, sound, provisioned and under sail, with no one aboard. Captain Benjamin Briggs, his wife Sarah, their two-year-old daughter Sophia and seven crewmen were gone, along with the ship's boat and papers. The 1873 press reported a bloodstained sword and cuts on the bows, and the U.S. Treasury wrote of "grave suspicions" of murder. No body, boat or survivor was ever found.
Adherents call the waters south of Tokyo, around Miyake-jima and the Izu chain toward the Bonin Islands, the Devil's Sea or the Dragon's Triangle: the Pacific twin of the Bermuda Triangle. According to CNN, author Charles Berlitz wrote that Japan lost five military vessels and about 100 scientists there between 1952 and 1954. The emblem case is the government survey ship Kaiyo Maru No. 5, sent in September 1952 to study a new volcano. She went silent, and neither her crew nor her hull was ever found.
Adherents say a stretch of the western North Atlantic between Florida, Bermuda and Puerto Rico swallows ships and aircraft and leaves no wreckage, no bodies and often no distress call. In December 1945 five Navy Avengers radioed that their compasses were out and vanished with 14 men, and a flying boat sent to find them was lost with 13 more. In 1918 the collier USS Cyclops disappeared without sending a word. The Navy's own ship history still calls her loss one of the sea's unsolved mysteries.
Kursk's loss in 2000 generated allegations of a collision with a NATO submarine, renewed by former Northern Fleet commander Vyacheslav Popov in 2021. Seismic measurements recorded two explosions; rescue accounts also exposed contradictory public statements and delayed foreign assistance. Those failings are distinct from proof of an attacking or colliding vessel. Contemporary technical records and the reported Russian commission findings support an internal torpedo-accident sequence.
The ferry's newly filmed hull damage revived a claim that a concealed submarine collision, rather than bow failure, caused the 1994 disaster. A grave-peace treaty and military-equipment shipments supplied further grounds for suspicion. Official records distinguish those genuine restrictions and transports from evidence about the fatal voyage. Later seabed surveys reject a collision or explosion while documenting serious structural, certification and industry-wide safety failures.
Animal Planet's Mermaids specials presented fictional scientists, underwater images and government suppression in documentary form. Some viewers treated that presentation as evidence, prompting real questions to NOAA. The creator described his work as science fiction built around environmental concerns, while contemporary criticism examined the disclaimers and marketing. The documented case is a manufactured cover-up narrative entering public discussion, not evidence that NOAA discovered and concealed aquatic humans.
Operation Holystone denotes Cold War U.S. Navy submarine special intelligence collection against Soviet naval targets—ELINT/SIGINT and acoustic signatures—as described in FAS and Congressional Record open summaries. Seymour Hersh’s May 1975 reporting forced public debate; Ford White House memos hosted by PBS FRONTLINE show Cheney option papers and Attorney General Levi’s advice against prosecuting the leak lest the government confirm the program in court. The Archive documents existence and disclosure politics and refuses invented complete take/hull lists.
For a long time the southern North Sea could be described as empty water with a shipping problem. Fishermen pulled antler, bone, and flint up in their nets, and those pieces sat as curiosities: stray finds, no valley, no camp, nothing that forced a map. What had been land lay under one of the busiest seas in the world, and a flint without a deposit is easy to treat as an accident of the trawl. Seismic mapping and sediment cores broke that description.
USS Scorpion (SSN-589) was lost 22 May 1968 with ninety-nine dead; a Navy Court of Inquiry could not ascertain certain cause. Later FOIA releases of inquiry and advisory materials, plus ONI-associated acoustic analyses (e.g., Rule), contest explosion and mechanism readings. Soviet-attack folklore is labeled contested. Contested/L2 keeps Navy doors primary without sealing a single cause.
SOSUS was the U.S. Navy’s Cold War passive undersea sound-surveillance grid—Caesar/NAVFAC cover, LOFAR analysis, later IUSS with SURTASS. Navy/IUSS community histories and 1991 mission declassification document the program without inventing classified take lists.
Put together, the record shows a call first logged by gliders in 2014 and 2015, described as metallic by the scientists who named it, and traced in 2024 to Bryde's whales seen and heard at the same time. The trench floor itself is noisy with whales, ships, earthquakes and storms. The Biotwang is strange to human ears and ordinary for a whale population in the western North Pacific, which returns to it season after season.