The case
Richard Freeman, an expedition leader writing in the Guardian (8 September 2011), says the orang pendek is said to be 4 to 5 feet tall, powerfully built and upright, with black or honey-coloured hair, living on the forest floor. Detik (2023) describes a ground-dwelling, two-legged ape between 80 and 150 cm tall. Freeman lists local names: sedapa or sedapak in the south-eastern lowlands, gugu in southern Sumatra, atu rimbu in Rawas and sebaba in Bengkulu. In 1918 the Dutch colonial official L.C. Westenenk recorded an event from 1910, which Freeman quotes. The page does not name local villagers or guides.
The sources give different lengths for the searches. Debbie Martyr began her research in the late 1980s (Freeman). Freeman says Martyr and Holden "began a 15-year search funded by Fauna and Flora International." Detik says Holden searched from 1995 in a 3-year project funded by the same organisation. The page states both and does not choose between them. Detik adds that a National Geographic-funded camera-trap project from 2005 to 2009 found nothing. The English renderings of detik on this page are translations from Indonesian, not quotations.
The adherents' reading
Freeman says: "I believe the orang pendek is a great ape closely related to the orang-utan," which he calls "an undiscovered species of ponginae." His team cast a print in 2011 that he judged "clearly a handprint rather than a footprint," and preserved hairs for DNA testing (Guardian, 7 October 2011). The abstract of Gregory Forth's 2008 chapter finds that the orang pendek has a "probable grounding in an empirical creature, either a variety of orang-utan or another primate."
The mainstream view
Bryan Sykes and colleagues (Proceedings of the Royal Society B, 2014) tested hair samples attributed to anomalous primates. Their table lists a Sumatran sample submitted as orang pendek as Tapirus indicus, the Malayan tapir.
Raymond Corbey's review of Forth's 2008 book (International Institute for Asian Studies) says Forth "argues that in the case of Sumatra the claims may partly or entirely relate to sightings of orangutans, gibbons, sun bears, or Kubu hunter-gatherers living in the forests." The same review says Forth "keeps an open mind as to the possibility of an as yet unknown primate, as, by the way, do several well-established primatologists on the basis of their fieldwork in Sumatra." Corbey adds that the orang pendek was "reported frequently by both Europeans and locals in colonial times." Detik reports that Holden photographed so many animals other than orang pendek that he says his own efforts could be seen as evidence it does not exist.
The adherents' answer
Freeman (8 September 2011) reports that Dr David Chivers of Cambridge judged an earlier cast "definitely an ape," and that Dr Hans Brunner, an expert on mammal hair, concluded that hairs "originated from a previously undocumented species of primate."
Holden, under his own name in detik, says he saw an upright animal about 7 metres away in October 1994, about 1.5 metres tall, and did not photograph it. He still believes it exists, and he points to a ground cuckoo unseen for over 90 years until it was trapped in 1997. Detik reports that the Fauna and Flora project's report found only footprints that did not appear to match any known primate species (translated from Indonesian).