The denial was anatomical. When the Liang Bua skeleton was published, the answering claim was that it was not a new species: LB1 was a modern human with a developmental disorder, microcephaly among the signs. The Smithsonian Institution's Human Origins page states that argument. There has been considerable debate over whether LB-1, the holotype, may represent a modern human with a disease or growth disorder, and the same page says most scientists now recognize Homo floresiensis as a taxon distinct from Homo sapiens. That "most" is the museum's sentence. It does not turn the 2006 papers into a fraud, and it does not make the bones a mythic race. The page uses the nickname hobbit. No plot is built on it.
The museum's description is a small-bodied human from one cave. Remains have so far been found only on Flores. Fossils are dated there to about 100,000 to 60,000 years ago, stone tools made by this species to about 190,000 to 50,000 years old. Stature is about 3 feet 6 inches, with a tiny brain, no chin, and large feet. It offers island dwarfism, also the pattern of Flores's extinct pygmy elephants, and notes that some scientists think the ancestors were already small. A joint Indonesian-Australian team found LB-1, a nearly complete female, in Liang Bua; that section says about 80,000 years ago. As many as twelve individuals are reported, and Liang Bua is called the only site for the species. The overview range and the "about 80,000" for LB-1 are both printed. They are not one number.
The 2004 species paper is the claim the critics refused. Peter Brown and colleagues, in Nature, reported an adult from Late Pleistocene Flores with stature and endocranial volume approximating 1 metre and 380 cubic centimetres. Primitive and derived features, they wrote, assign it to Homo floresiensis. The most likely explanation they gave was long-term isolation and endemic dwarfing of ancestral Homo erectus. "Most likely" is their phrase. The museum's note, that the ancestors may already have been small, is a different origin beside it.
The pathology paper says the species name was the error. Teuku Jacob and colleagues, in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, write that LB1 shows marked craniofacial and postcranial asymmetries and other signs of abnormal growth. Aside from the anomalies, they say 140 cranial features place LB1 in modern human ranges, like Australomelanesian populations, and that LB1 and LB6/1 either fit Homo sapiens or share receding chins and rotated premolars with Rampasasa pygmies near the cave. They propose that LB1 comes from an earlier pygmy Homo sapiens population and, individually, shows a developmental abnormality including microcephaly. Other remains from the site share the small body, they write, but not the microcephaly. They were answering estimates near 1.06 metres and 380 millilitres used to define a species from one person. The paper is an argument, not a hoax to be sneered at.
The dates moved without settling the name. Thomas Sutikna and colleagues, Nature, 2016, say the old dates, about 95 to 12 thousand years, had implied survival long after modern humans reached Australia by about 50 thousand years ago. Their stratigraphy rejects a holotype near 18 thousand calibrated years and a last appearance near 17 or 13 to 11 thousand. Skeletal remains date to about 100 to 60 thousand years ago. Stone artefacts they attribute to the species run from about 190 to 50 thousand. Whether anyone survived after 50 thousand years, to meet modern humans or other hominins such as Denisovans, they leave open. Open is not a late survival.
Mata Menge is a second locality, described as floresiensis-like rather than as a second stack of Liang Bua skeletons. Gerrit van den Bergh and colleagues report a mandible fragment and six teeth from at least three small individuals, excavated in 2014 in the So'a Basin and dated to about 0.7 million years, on their account the oldest hominin remains on Flores. The jaw and teeth resemble Homo floresiensis from Liang Bua, aside from a more primitive first molar, and the Mata Menge jaw and molar are even smaller. Derived relative to Australopithecus and Homo habilis, they tend, the authors say, to support a dwarfed descendant of early Asian Homo erectus rather than habilis or a late australopithecine. Adam Brumm and colleagues date that sandstone to a valley stream around 700 thousand years ago, by argon, fission-track, and uranium-series with electron spin resonance on teeth, in dry savannah-like grassland with wetland. The stone technology is markedly similar to the later Liang Bua industry, and they attribute the fossils to a population ancestral to Homo floresiensis. The Smithsonian page still limits the species name to Liang Bua. Both sentences can be printed. They are not the same claim.
One side named a species from a very small adult in Liang Bua. The other said that adult was a small modern human with a pathology, microcephaly included, and that the other bones were small without the small brain. Later dating pulled the skeletons off a near-modern overlap and left any meeting with Homo sapiens unresolved. Mata Menge added older, smaller, floresiensis-like teeth and a jaw, read there as early dwarfing from Asian Homo erectus, not as an end to the 2006 argument. No mythic race is baptized here, and the pathology papers are not treated as fraud.
Smithsonian Human Origins, Homo floresiensis: https://humanorigins.si.edu/evidence/human-fossils/species/homo-floresiensis.
Brown and colleagues, Nature, 2004: https://www.nature.com/articles/nature02999.
Jacob and colleagues, PNAS, 2006, via PubMed Central: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1552106/.
Sutikna and colleagues, Nature, 2016: https://www.nature.com/articles/nature17179.
van den Bergh and colleagues, Nature, 2016: https://www.nature.com/articles/nature17999.
Brumm and colleagues, Nature, 2016: https://www.nature.com/articles/nature17663.
What Stays Contested
On these pages: the 2004 species name for a Liang Bua adult about a metre tall, cranial volume near 380 cubic centimetres; a 2006 reading of LB1 as a pygmy modern human with microcephaly; museum dates of about 100,000 to 60,000 years for the fossils and 190,000 to 50,000 for the tools, and a statement that the species is known only from Liang Bua; a 2016 shift of the bones to about 100 to 60 thousand years, with any later meeting left open; Mata Menge at about 700 thousand years, floresiensis-like. Left contested: whether LB1's brain is a species trait or one disorder.