Browse all theories tagged with this keyword
The Holy Lance in Vienna's imperial treasury is, per the Kunsthistorisches Museum (KHM), a Carolingian winged lance of the 8th century. The KHM says "pious wishful thinking" turned an iron pin set in the blade into one of the nails of the cross, and that in the 13th century the lance came to be seen as that of Longinus. Trevor Ravenscroft's *The Spear of Destiny* says that Hitler was obsessed with the lance. Time quotes the line "Whomsoever claims this spear and solves its secrets holds the destiny of the world in his hands". The book's date differs by source: 1972 (Bad Archaeology, naming Neville Spearman) or 1973 (All About History). Sky HISTORY says American forces located the lance "just two hours" before Hitler's death on 30 April 1945. Robert Feather, a British metallurgist, examined the lance in 2003 (Time Europe, 8 June 2003) and "found the main body of the spear to be medieval, dating to the 7th century at the earliest", which is compatible with the KHM's 8th century. Bad Archaeology, a blog by museum curator Keith Fitzpatrick-Matthews, says Ravenscroft "admitted in 1982" that his contact with his source, Walter Johannes Stein, was "conducted entirely through a medium", and that the book's style is "decidedly novelistic". All About History says Stein said nothing of such a claim in his lifetime. The sources also differ on the recovery: Bad Archaeology says Walter Horn of the US Army found the regalia's hiding place in 1946, while a US Army account says that on 7 August 1945 Horn located several missing pieces of the Imperial Regalia, including the crown, orb, scepter and two swords, and that the regalia returned to Austria on 4 January 1946. Feather also told Time that the iron pin is "consistent" in length and shape with a first-century Roman nail, that science cannot date the iron fragments around it, and that "We're in the realm of speculation, but you cannot rule it out." Adherents answer that the pin cannot be ruled out as a first-century nail.
The National Science and Media Museum (2012) says that in 1917 Frances Griffiths and her cousin Elsie Wright began a series of five photographs, showing the girls with fairies, at Cottingley Beck. In 1920 the photographs reached Edward Gardner of the Theosophical Society and then Arthur Conan Doyle, who published the first two in the Christmas 1920 Strand Magazine under the names "Alice" and "Iris" (Leeds Library; Bradford Museums). Cooper gives the first Strand publication as the end of 1919. Gardner supplied a camera and marked plates, and three more photographs followed in August 1920. Doyle's *The Coming of the Fairies* (1922) set out the case. Doyle's book opens by saying the incidents were "either the most elaborate and ingenious hoax ever played upon the public" or "an event in human history which may in the future appear to have been epoch-making in its character". In a letter to the photographic journalist Geoffrey Crawley dated 17 February 1983, Elsie (by then Elsie Hill) said all five photographs were staged (Science and Media Museum; the Leeds Library says she "finally wrote a letter of confession in 1983"). Joe Cooper's interview in The Unexplained (cited as issue 117, 1982; the Guardian says 1983) reports that "in late 1981 and mid 1982 respectively" Frances (Way) and Elsie (Hill) admitted the first four were fakes, made from gift-book illustrations fixed in place with hatpins. Frances said until her death that the fifth photograph, "Fairy Sunbath, Elves, etc.", was genuine and that she had seen fairies at the beck (Science and Media Museum; Bradford Museums; Cooper). She told Cooper: "I saw these fairies building up in the grasses and just aimed the camera and took a photograph." Both photographers are deceased (Frances Griffiths 1907 to 1986, Elsie Wright 1901 to 1988, per the Museum). Adherents point to Frances's statement that the fifth photograph is genuine, and to Cooper's remark that whether fairies exist "remains an open question".
The Feejee Mermaid is a mummified figure with a monkey-like head and a fish tail. Live Science says that Samuel Barrett Eades bought it from the Dutch in January 1822, showed it in London from September 1822, and that two naturalists he invited called it fake. After his death his son sold it to Moses Kimball of the Boston Museum, in the early 1840s. In 1842 Kimball and P. T. Barnum arranged its New York showing: Adrienne Saint-Pierre told Live Science that "Barnum leased the mermaid from Kimball". Live Science says that during the 1842 tour one Charleston newspaper vouched for it while another called it a fraud. Harvard's Peabody Museum says that "Japanese craftsmen fabricated mermaids by joining the bodies of monkeys and fish, although the head and torso of this example are made from papier-mâché". The Boston Globe (2016) records curator Diana Loren calling its Peabody figure "an amalgam of papier-mâché, fish and possibly monkey parts, and wood", and says Kimball told the Globe in an interview that he knew it was a "fraud". In October 2023, radiology students at Northern Kentucky University scanned the Clark County Historical Society's figure from Springfield, Ohio. The Springfield News-Sun reports that the scans showed what appeared to be fish scales and a fish jaw, wooden rods, metal, cotton stuffing and likely papier-mâché; The Northerner adds that further tests are needed. Loren told the Crimson it is "unclear" whether the Peabody figure is the exact specimen Barnum showed, and Saint-Pierre told Live Science the Peabody has "no solid documentation" that it is, while the Globe reports Loren saying the museum has documentation suggesting it is. Provenance also differs: Live Science says Eades bought it from the Dutch; the Globe says a sailor visiting Japan bought it in 1822; the Peabody says Kimball bought it from the son of a Boston sea captain. Adherents answer that it is not established that the Peabody figure is the one Barnum showed.
This page covers two lakes and keeps a living Syilx teaching separate from a settler name. The Syilx (Okanagan) name for the being of Okanagan Lake is n̓x̌aʔx̌ʔítkʷ. The Westbank Museum page (text provided by Sncewips Heritage Museum) says: "Often, the Ogopogo is mistakenly seen as synonymous with the syilx people's n'x̌ax̌aitkʷ", which it calls "a benevolent lake spirit; it does not eat people nor does it need offerings of flesh". It says the name "Ogopogo" "originated from the imaginations of Clark Cumberland and Mark Strong", who performed a 1924 song. Syilx 101 (Okanagan Nation Alliance) quotes the late Elder Joey Pierre: "You don't call him Ogopogo, you call him by his name, n̓x̌aʔx̌ʔítkʷ", glossed as "sacred being in the water". UBC Okanagan News (9 July 2015) reports a student display, drawing on Kelowna Museums and Sncəwips Heritage Museum resources, that "highlights how the spirit of the lake was transformed into a 'monster' by early settlers". At Lake Champlain, the Green Mountaineer, a Vermont Historical Society magazine for children, says sightings of Champ "have been made for centuries", lists an 1819 report at Bulwagga Bay, and calls the July 1977 snapshot by Sandra Mansi the remarkable one. Adherents read the long record of sightings as evidence that something lives in Lake Champlain. Mansi says, in Yankee, "I knew I had to have the conviction to say, 'Okay, this is what I saw. You tell me what it was.'" Yankee adds that she "doesn't really know what she saw" and that scientists who scrutinized her print found it had not been doctored. Live Science (Benjamin Radford, 2013) reports his field investigations for a Discovery Channel documentary, which found that Mansi "overestimated the object's size" and concluded the object was a submerged tree trunk raised by gases from decay. Adherents answer that the tree-trunk finding rests on one later investigation and that the sightings do not depend on one photograph.
Norwegian sources describe a huge sea creature that fishers met over deep water. The Biodiversity Heritage Library says the thirteenth-century Norwegian Konungs skuggsjá (the King's Mirror) describes a beast that appears "more like an island than a fish", which a 1917 translation identifies as the Kraken. Erik Pontoppidan's Natural History of Norway (Danish 1752 to 1753; English 1755) gave the account most often quoted. He calls it "incontestibly the largest Sea-monster in the world", names it "Kraken, Kraxen, or, as some name it, Krabben", and says he writes from what his correspondents related. He reports that fishers "unanimously affirm" that where they expect 80 or 100 fathoms they sometimes find only 20 or 30, with plenty of fish, and that they row away if the water keeps shoaling. Its back, he says, "looks at first like a number of small islands", and he gives "about an English mile and an half in circumference", the smallest estimate he knew. Adherents read the shifting seabed and the agreement of many crews as one great animal. The Biodiversity Heritage Library says the giant squid, Architeuthis dux, was for centuries known as the Kraken. Kubodera and Mori (2005) report the first images of a live giant squid in the wild, at 900 m off the Ogasawara Islands, and a severed tentacle confirmed an animal greater than 8 m. Winkelmann et al. (2013) sampled 43 giant squid and found results consistent with one global species, Architeuthis dux. Adherents answer that an animal of about 8 m is not a mile of back, so the older reports may describe something far larger or different.
Mokele-mbembe is described as a large, long-necked animal of the swamps and rivers of the Likouala region of the Republic of the Congo, where the Lac Télé Community Reserve now lies (WCS Congo). Roy Mackal and colleagues, who searched the Likouala in 1980 and 1981 and whose own summary says "Non-probative evidence of Mokele-Mbembe was found," quote a German officer's pre-war report of an elephant-sized animal with "a long and very flexible neck." In April 1983 the Congolese biologist Marcellin Agnagna, of the Zoological Park of Brazzaville, led the first Congolese government expedition. He writes that the villagers of Boha, who "own" Lake Télé, agreed to help after a week of discussion, and that elders prayed to their ancestors to protect the team. On 1 May 1983, he reports, he and two villagers watched an animal "with a wide back, a long neck, and a small head" for about 20 minutes; the animal was about 300 metres from the lake's edge, and after the party waded about 60 metres into the shallows it was about 240 metres away; his film failed because he "began filming with the lens cap on." Adherents take these accounts as evidence of a large unknown animal. Live Science, drawing on Daniel Loxton and Donald Prothero, traces the modern dinosaur idea to Carl Hagenbeck's 1909 book and calls the reports "a distillation of many creatively varied stories." Riley Black, in Smithsonian, notes "no trace of sauropods in the fossil record" since the end-Cretaceous, and writes that the name "can also refer to something that is not real or has no physical manifestation". Adherents answer, with Mackal, that no dinosaur fossil sites exist in central Africa to test the idea, and Agnagna wrote that the animal is "known to many inhabitants of the Likouala region."
In the Gobi, the olgoi-khorkhoi (loosely "large intestine worm," per Live Science) is said to live under the sand and to kill by poison or, in some accounts, an electric current. Roy Chapman Andrews, in *On the Trail of Ancient Man* (1926), records that at a cabinet meeting in Urga "the Premier asked that, if it were possible, I should capture for the Mongolian government a specimen of the alter gorhai-horhai." "None of those present ever had seen the creature," he wrote, "but they all firmly believed in its existence and described it minutely": a sausage about two feet long, so poisonous that touching it meant instant death. Atlas Obscura and Skeptoid date the meeting to 1919; the surrounding chapter describes the 1922 expedition. Czech writer Ivan Mackerle searched the Gobi in 1990 and 1992, and again in 2004 by small aircraft, and recorded herders describing a worm that inflates and squirts poison. Adherents, Mackerle among them, held to a worm that kills at a distance. Atlas Obscura reports that in 1983 conservationist Yuri Gorelov caught a Tartar sand boa, a non-venomous snake, which local Mongols identified as an olgoi-khorkhoi, and that scholar Ágnes Birtalan calls khorkhoi a "taboo name" for dangerous animals, especially snakes. Prague Zoo director Miroslav Bobek writes that Mackerle's own witness testimonies "largely support" the sand boa reading. Live Science calls a real animal "doubtful." Adherents answer that Mackerle's herders described the creature in detail, and that the belief persists among those who grew up with it.
The Ngarrindjeri tell of the Mulyawonk, a water being of the river. In the story given by the Rural City of Murray Bridge and the Murray-Darling Basin Authority, a greedy man took far more fish than he needed, and the Elders turned him into a half-fish, half-man creature and banished him to the river; children are told never to swim alone or take more fish than they can eat. Mark Koolmatrie, of the Ramindjeri and Warki clans of the Ngarrindjeri nation, told ABC Science: "The Mulyawonk story has been told to us forever." The council page notes that the story varies between Lakalinyeri (clans), and traces the word bunyip to the Wemba-Wemba or Wergaia language. Historian David Waldron told the Canberra Times that many different water creatures "get shoehorned into the word bunyip." Separately, a skull found by the Murrumbidgee River in 1846 was shown at the Colonial Museum of Sydney in 1847 as a possible bunyip. Historian Penny Edmonds, in the Australian Humanities Review, writes that scientists at the time declared the specimen to be from a strange and unknown species, but that the naturalist William Sharp Macleay judged it "the misshapen foetus of a mare," and that the skull has since been lost. Patrick Nunn and Luiza Ponciano suggest some stories may preserve memories of extinct megafauna, but write that "we shall never be able to prove conclusively" this. The people who keep the Mulyawonk teaching, Koolmatrie among them, say it is a living story about caring for the river, and the Murray Bridge page says it "teaches children water safety and respect for the fish of the river and lakes."
The Thunderbird is a powerful sky being in the traditions of many Indigenous nations, with different roles in different cultures. Charlotte Coté, a member of the Tseshaht First Nation, records the Nuu-chah-nulth and Makah account of T'iick'in, the Thunderbird, whose wings caused thunder and whose flicking tongue caused lightning, and who hunted whales. Audubon reports that Thunderbirds are known as wakinyan in Sioux languages, are generally depicted as birds of prey or avian-human hybrids, and appear in roughly 500 references in anthropological records. The Ojibwe People's Dictionary gives animikii as "a thunderbird, a thunderer." Separately, on 26 April 1890 the Tombstone Epitaph printed a report, reproduced by True West, that two ranchers found a winged "monster, resembling a huge alligator," about ninety-two feet long with wings about 160 feet from tip to tip, between the Whetstone and Huachuca mountains. The report never uses the word Thunderbird and mentions no Indigenous tradition. Adherents of a later reading take the report as evidence of a giant winged animal. True West's Jana Bommersbach writes that the Epitaph printed no photograph and no follow-up; the photograph claim began with a 1963 Saga article that misdated the story to 1886, and the most circulated image adds a bird to an existing photograph of the wounded train robber John Sontag with members of the posse that caught him. Troy Taylor called the report one with "all of the appearances of the tall tales" of Western newspapers. Adherents answer that a Los Angeles paper took the report seriously in May 1890, citing earlier sightings near Elizabeth Lake, California, as Horace Bell recorded in 1930.
In Mongolia, almas is a name for a hairy, upright being reported mainly in the west, including the Altai. In the Caucasus the form is almasty; the reprint of Koffmann's article notes that the local names are always translated as "man of the woods," "wildman" or "hairy man," the standard rendering this page follows. Zhugdariyn Damdin, in a letter to Boris Porshnev dated 20 June 1967, wrote as "a simple hunter" aged 68 who had searched for four years from 1962 in the Kobdo and Bayan-Olgii aimaqs, and said accounts of the almas are passed on "in all Mongol families living in gers." Marie-Jeanne Koffmann wrote that more than 500 witness statements described bipedal, hair-covered creatures with no language, and that a Soviet commission on the question was created in 1958. Adherents read these accounts as a surviving hominid: Koffmann concluded that the reports "are real and are well founded in fact," and described the almasty as a hominid with traits of Neanderthal man. In 2014 Sykes and colleagues identified eight Russian "almasty" hair samples as brown bear, American black bear, horse, cow and raccoon; the published sample sheets place three of them in valleys of Kabardino-Balkaria. Michael Heaney of the Bodleian Library, checking archive diaries, found that a much-repeated 1906 almas sighting, said to have started Mongolian research, is "in grave doubt." Adherents answer that the genetic results apply only to the hairs tested, and that doubt about one early sighting leaves hundreds of later field statements standing.
In eastern Australia, "yowie" is a name applied to a tall, hairy, upright creature; Australian Geographic gives heights of up to 3.6 metres. The historian David Waldron told ABC News that the first mentions come from Indigenous people around the Hunter River, where it was more complex: "a water spirit that kills children," and a person's yowie "travelling when they sleep." Anthropologist Yasmine Musharbash, writing in the Conversation, reports that hairy beings are known across the continent under many names, and that in the Tanami Desert the Warlpiri know them as Pangkarlangu, who change as communities change. Joe Nickell quotes an Aboriginal elder on the Dulagarl: "He only appears to Aboriginal people." Australian Geographic records an 1886 Blue Mountains sighting and a hotelier's reward of fifty pounds. Adherents read later reports as a real animal: Rex Gilroy, of the Australian Yowie Research Centre (established 1976), gives his own reading that Dreamtime traditions describe hominids 3 to 4 metres tall. Waldron says the name was merged with the bunyip, called "Australia's gorilla" by the 1890s and "Australia's so-called Bigfoot" after the 1950s yeti story, "a colonial process"; Nickell traces "Yahoo" to Jonathan Swift and names wombats and kangaroos as likely sources of some reports. Adherents answer, with Gilroy as quoted by Nickell, that many early Europeans reported seeing the creature years before they learned of the Aboriginal traditions.
On Sunday 4 August 1577 a violent storm struck the Suffolk churches at Bungay and Blythburgh. Abraham Fleming's pamphlet A straunge and terrible Wunder (1577) reports that "a dog as they might discerne it, of a black colour" appeared in the Bungay church, passed between two kneeling people and "wrung the necks of them bothe," leaving "the marks as it were of his clawes or talans" in the stones and the church door. Fleming says the same shape entered the church at "Blibery" (Blythburgh) that day and "slew two men and a lad." The Blythburgh church's history says lightning "cleft the door," leaving scorch marks on the north door called the fingerprints of the Devil. A Suffolk County Council parish record lists the storm killing 2 and burning about 18. Adherents read the two church visits as the work of one black dog, a hell hound of a kind reported across England. Holinshed's chronicle, quoted in Hone's Every-Day Book (1827), records the same storm as lightning and thunder, with a man over forty and a boy of fifteen found dead at Blythburgh and two men slain in the Bungay belfry, and names no dog. The name Shuck appears in none of Fleming's pamphlet, Hone's entry or the Blythburgh church history; BBC News records Black Shuck as the name later tradition gives the dog. Adherents answer that Fleming says his report came "by the mouthes of them that were eye witnesses," and that the Blythburgh door is still marked.
By tradition, the creature was born at Leeds Point on a stormy night in 1735 to a woman known as Mother Leeds who, pregnant for the 13th time, cried out, "Let this one be a devil" (National Geographic; other versions exist). From 16 January 1909, for about a week, newspapers across South Jersey and Philadelphia carried reports of hoof-like tracks in snow and of a winged creature with a horse-like head. The Sun (New York) reported on 21 January that "all south Jersey had posses out" hunting the "Leed's devil," and The Inquirer's front page that day showed "actual proof-prints of the strange creature." The Atlantic County Library counts thirty sightings in one week, and says the Philadelphia Zoo's superintendent offered a $10,000 reward. Adherents read the week as sightings of a creature long known in the Pine Barrens as the Leeds Devil. The Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia could not find any record of a living or dead species resembling it (Atlantic County). Historians Brian Regal and Frank Esposito, in National Geographic, trace the Leeds name to the 17th-century colonist Daniel Leeds and find no 17th-century source calling any of his wives Mother Leeds. The Inquirer (2019) calls the publicist Norman Jeffries "the prime suspect in a case of fake news," and the Atlantic County Library says animal trainers at a Philadelphia museum made a Devil from a kangaroo with false wings. Adherents answer that businessmen, postal officials and policemen were among those who reported tracks and sightings, on both banks of the Delaware.
On 21 August 1955 a family on a farm near Kelly said that small, silvery figures with large heads, yellow glowing eyes and clawed hands had approached the house after a bright object came down behind it. Two men fired a shotgun and a .22 rifle. About 11 p.m., eight adults and three children arrived at the Hopkinsville police station (History.com). State police, military police from Fort Campbell and local officers went to the farm. The Kentucky New Era ran the first story on 22 August: "Story of Space-Ship, 12 Little Men Probed Today ... Bullets Failed To Affect Visitors." Officers stayed until after 2 a.m. "without seeing anything either to prove or disprove the story." According to the case site that hosts the New Era text, its reporter later noted that national media added the colour green two or three days afterwards. Adherents read it as a visit by small beings over several hours, one of the most detailed close encounters on record. Joe Nickell (2006, as reported by History.com) matched the light to a small meteor and the figures to great horned owls. Blue Book logged the case as number 10073 but did not officially investigate it. Adherents answer that the police chief said the family "reach for their guns" rather than run to the police, that the figures returned after the officers left, and that, as PBS records, none of the witnesses changed their story.
On 12 September 1952 (History.com), children playing after supper at the elementary school in Flatwoods saw something streak overhead and crash into a nearby hill (West Virginia Public Broadcasting). Nickell describes them as boys playing football on the school playground, a group of seven. A local mother went up the hill with them (West Virginia Public Broadcasting). West Virginia Public Broadcasting, quoting the visitors bureau director, describes a green and red figure about 10 feet tall, with a red face and a spade-shaped form around the head. The 15 September 1952 United Press story in the Washington Daily News gives the height as 11 or 12 feet, a "very sickening, hot, stuffy smelling odor," an area "all trampled down," and two tracks like skid marks about a foot wide the next morning. Nickell records a metallic, "sickening, irritating" odour, drape-like folds, two parallel "skid marks," trampled grass, and a pair of shining eyes. The group ran. Gray Barker wrote it up for FATE, and the Air Force opened a Project Blue Book inquiry. Adherents read the light, the odour, the marks and the figure as one visit by a landed craft and its pilot. The Blue Book record card at the National Archives concludes the object was "astronomical," the "well known Washington area meteor of 12 Sep." Joe Nickell (Skeptical Inquirer, November/December 2000) argues that the fireball was a meteor visible in at least three states, that the pulsing light matched a nearby aircraft beacon, and that the figure was a barn owl on a branch. Adherents answer that a meteor does not account for the marks and the odour found at the site, or for the figure the group described.
On 15 November 1966 two young couples reported a large winged figure with red eyes near the abandoned wartime munitions site known as the TNT area, outside Point Pleasant. The Point Pleasant Register ran "Couples See Man-Sized Bird...Creature...Something" on 16 November: the two men described it as about six or seven feet tall, with a 10-foot wingspan and red eyes about two inches across, and one said, "It was like a man with wings." Mary Hyre wrote 10 columns on it by year's end for the Athens Messenger, where History.com says an editor coined "Mothman" after Batman's foe Killer Moth. Keel's own timeline, as summarised by Hasken, lists 21 sightings before 1967 and 5 after the new year; the sources disagree on the total, so no single count is given as fact. WVPB says UFO reports began on 22 January 1967. On 15 December 1967 the Silver Bridge at Point Pleasant collapsed, killing 46; the National Transportation Safety Board determined that the collapse began with a cleavage fracture in the lower limb of the eye of eyebar 330, and that 31 of the 37 vehicles on the bridge fell with it. Adherents, following John Keel's The Mothman Prophecies (1975), read the figure as a harbinger linked to the collapse; Audubon lists other partisan readings: an alien or an extra-dimensional spirit. Joe Nickell of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry, in Audubon, says the original Mothman was likely a barred owl, whose eyeshine can glow red. Adherents answer that four people saw the figure together, and that the reports ended after the bridge fell.
From June 1764, attacks in the Gévaudan (modern Lozère) killed mostly women and children. Smithsonian Magazine says the beast killed around 100 people and injured nearly 300, and names the first victim as a 14-year-old girl watching her sheep; France Culture says about 80 recorded deaths. The Courrier d'Avignon, under editor François Morénas, turned it into national news. Captain Duhamel led hunts with up to 30,000 volunteers, the d'Ennevals announced in February 1765 that they would come, and François Antoine shot a large wolf in September 1765 that was sent to Versailles. Killings resumed, and Jean Chastel shot an animal on 19 June 1767, after which the attacks ended. The regional delegate Lafont wrote that "it is much bigger than a wolf," and Duhamel thought it a hybrid whose father was a lion. Adherents read these descriptions as an animal that no ordinary wolf could explain. Jay M. Smith, author of Monsters of the Gévaudan (Harvard University Press, 2011), told Smithsonian that "the best and most likely explanation is Gévaudan had a serious wolf infestation." An anatomical analysis reported by France Culture (5 December 2024) finds that the animal called Ténazeyre was a large-toothed wolf, with the other two suspects also canids and possibly wolves. Adherents answer that the killings went on after Antoine's wolf was presented as the beast; Smithsonian reports 30 to 35 deaths over the following 18 months.
On 15 May 1989, KLAS-TV in Las Vegas aired a live interview with a man called "Dennis," who described a place called S-4, built into the side of a mountain; seven months later the public learned his name, Bob Lazar. In that interview he said: "The propulsion system is a gravity propulsion system and the power source is an antimatter reactor." By his account, the craft used a stable form of element 115, which no laboratory had then made. The National Security Archive notes that the CIA's U-2 history, declassified in 2013, named Area 51 as the U-2 test site. Adherents read the account as a firsthand description of recovered craft. Physics Today reports that a Dubna and Livermore team led by Yuri Oganessian made element 115 in the summer of 2003; Scientific American reports four atoms that decayed after about 90 milliseconds. IUPAC approved the name moscovium (Mc) on 28 November 2016. VICE reports that only four isotopes have been produced, each lasting fractions of a second, and that scientists have not made a stable isotope like the one he described. Adherents answer that the account named element 115 in 1989, fourteen years before any laboratory made it.
Tesla came to Colorado Springs in 1899 and kept notes at his laboratory there, almost daily, for about eight months; the last journal entry is dated 7 January 1900. In "The Problem of Increasing Human Energy" (Century Magazine, June 1900) he wrote that an electrical movement could be made "perceptible on some of our nearer planets, as Venus and Mars," that "interplanetary communication has entered the stage of probability," and that "man is not the only being in the Infinite gifted with a mind." In "Talking with the Planets" (Collier's Weekly, February 1901) he described changes "with such a clear suggestion of number and order" and wrote: "The feeling is constantly growing on me that I had been the first to hear the greeting of one planet to another." Adherents read this as the first reception of an alien signal. In ARRL's QST ("Ghost," October 2018), Allison McLellan writes that biographer Marc Seifer suggests Tesla may have picked up Marconi's transmissions, citing the three-dot Morse "S." Adherents answer with Tesla's own words: he knew the disturbances caused by the sun, the aurora and earth currents, and these were "not traceable to any cause then known to me."
On 9 December 1965, witnesses about 30 miles southeast of Pittsburgh described a fireball and a metallic, acorn-shaped object about 12 to 15 feet high that landed in the woods; some said military personnel cordoned off the site and that the object left on a truck under a tarp (AP, 2009). Leslie Kean, who directs the Coalition for Freedom of Information, sued NASA in 2003; in March 2007 a federal judge found NASA had not yet shown an adequate search, and the case settled in October 2007 with $50,000 in fees and a new search, which ended in August 2009 with no record of the object. The Black Vault reports that NASA's transmittal slip listed fragment-study records sent to the National Archives in 1967 or 1968, that the Archives told NASA in 1996 they were lost, and that a later letter appears to say they were never received. Adherents read the cordon and the missing records as signs that something was recovered and kept quiet. A 1965 NASA press release, quoted by VICE, said the fireball was "more likely a meteor"; in 2005 NASA spokesman David Steitz told the AP the object appeared to be a Russian satellite, with fragment records lost in the 1990s. Adherents answer, as Space.com reports Kean's view, that data from U.S. Space Command and the Russian Space Agency show it was not a Russian satellite.
In Intelligent Life in the Universe (1966), Shklovskii and Sagan wrote that if the 1945 orbital data for Phobos were right, its decay implied a density so low that "a natural satellite cannot be a hollow object," leading them to "the possibility" that it was an artificial satellite of Mars; they added that the data "may contain substantial errors." In Mars Global Surveyor images from 12 September 1998, NASA describes a very large boulder about 85 m across on Phobos; it came to be called the Phobos monolith, a name Buzz Aldrin used in a 2009 C-SPAN appearance, as IFLScience reports. Adherents read the hollow-moon calculation and the monolith as signs that Phobos is a made object. Parts and Wright (Research Notes of the AAS, 2026) note that later observations found a slower decay, explained by tidal friction, and that a Phobos hollow enough to match the 1966 rate would have about 2.1 x 10^-5 of its actual mass, a difference detectable within a year. Science News (2010), reporting on Mars Express data, gives a density of about 1.87 g per cubic cm and as much as 30 percent empty space, a possible rubble pile. JAXA's Martian Moons eXploration spacecraft launched on 20 October 2026 and is scheduled to return more than 10 g of material from Phobos in 2031. Adherents answer that no sample of Phobos has yet been examined.
Kardashev, in Soviet Astronomy (1964), ranked civilizations by energy: Type I at about 4 x 10^12 W, close to the level then reached on Earth; Type II at about 4 x 10^26 W, harnessing its own star; Type III at about 4 x 10^37 W, on the scale of a galaxy. Dyson, in Science (1960), had already proposed searching for infrared from artificial stellar sources. Gray (AJ, 2020) shows that Sagan, in The Cosmic Connection (1973), suggested decimal steps and classed Earth as Type 0.7, though Sagan presented no equation. Wright and colleagues argue that detectably large alien energy supplies can plausibly be expected to exist. Adherents read the scale as a map of where advanced civilizations should be, and of how far humanity has to go. Griffith and colleagues, using WISE on about 100,000 galaxies, found none reprocessing more than 85 percent of their starlight into mid-infrared. Zackrisson and colleagues, studying 1,359 disk galaxies, found none standing out as strong Type III candidates. Adherents answer that these surveys set upper limits, not zero.
Technosignatures are observable signs of technology. Cocconi and Morrison (Nature, 1959) proposed searching for interstellar radio communications. NASA's Technosignatures Workshop (Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston, 26 to 28 September 2018) produced a report edited by Jason Wright and Dawn Gelino, and Wright and coauthors (ApJL 927, L30, 2022) argue technosignatures may be abundant, long-lived, highly detectable and unambiguous. Adherents read this work as a sign that alien technology is now a serious scientific question, and that it may already be in the data. Price and colleagues (AJ 159, 86, 2020) searched 1,138 stars at Green Bank and 189 at Parkes and, after excluding interference, were "left with zero candidates," finding no transmitters above about 2.1 x 10^12 W (Green Bank) and 9.1 x 10^12 W (Parkes). A ten-year Breakthrough Listen review (MacMahon and Czech, arXiv, October 2026) notes that its best-known candidate, BLC1, was ultimately attributed to terrestrial interference, the conclusion Sheikh and colleagues reached with a technosignature verification framework. Adherents answer that these searches covered a small sample of stars and a narrow band of radio frequencies.
In Sumerian texts the Anunna are a group of high gods who decide the fates, and Inana's Descent makes them the seven judges of the underworld. After the Old Babylonian period the name came to mean the gods of the netherworld, set against the Igigi. Atrahasis opens with the great Anunnaki making the Igigi carry the workload, and Enuma Elish has Marduk station three hundred in heaven and three hundred below. In The 12th Planet (1976) Zecharia Sitchin recast them as astronauts from the planet Nibiru. Michael Heiser answered that no cuneiform text says so.