The case
Mokele-mbembe is described as a large, long-necked animal of the swamps and rivers of the Likouala region of the Republic of the Congo, where WCS Congo places the Lac Télé Community Reserve.
Roy Mackal, J. Richard Greenwell and M. Justin Wilkinson, writing in Cryptozoology in 1982, trace early reports. A 1776 book by the Abbé Proyart reported missionaries seeing the track of an animal "which they did not see but which must have been monstrous." They say Carl Hagenbeck reported two accounts of similar animals in Rhodesia in 1912, while Live Science dates his book to 1909. They quote the expedition of von Stein zu Lausnitz, which recorded reports of an animal named Mokele-Mbembe: "brownish-gray color, with a smooth skin, the size approximately that of an elephant," with "a long and very flexible neck." Mackal and a colleague went out in early 1980, and Mackal led a second expedition from late October to early December 1981. Their own summary says: "Non-probative evidence of Mokele-Mbembe was found." A separate 1981 expedition is recorded in a report by Herman Regusters in the Munger Africana Library Notes of July 1982.
In April 1983 the Congolese biologist Marcellin Agnagna, of the Zoological Park of Brazzaville, led the first Congolese government expedition, which left Brazzaville on 3 April with seven members from several ministries. In Cryptozoology he records that the villagers of Boha, who "own" Lake Télé, were reluctant, partly owing to "negative experiences with one of the previous American expeditions in 1981." They agreed after a week because it was an official government project. On 26 April, he writes, "the drums were beaten at Boha, while village elders made their ritual prayers invoking the spirits of their ancestors to protect the expedition members." The prayers and the reluctance are the villagers' own. On 1 May 1983, at about 2:30 p.m., Agnagna and two Boha villagers saw "a strange animal, with a wide back, a long neck, and a small head." It was about 300 metres from the lake's edge, and about 240 metres away after the party waded about 60 metres into the shallows. It was visible for 20 minutes, with about 5 metres showing above the waterline. His film failed: he "began filming with the lens cap on." The expedition ended on 17 May after 45 days.
The adherents' reading
Agnagna wrote: "It can be said with certainty that the animal we saw was Mokele-Mbembe." Adherents take his account, and the 1980 and 1981 expedition reports, as evidence of a large unknown animal.
The mainstream view
Live Science, drawing on Daniel Loxton and Donald Prothero, traces the modern dinosaur idea to Hagenbeck's 1909 book Beasts and Men. The book speculated that sauropods might survive in Africa and offered no evidence. The reports, it says, are "a distillation of many creatively varied stories from widely separated regions." Riley Black writes in Smithsonian Magazine that there is "no trace of sauropods in the fossil record" in the 65 million years since the end-Cretaceous extinction. Prothero notes that the reports are inconsistent, Black writes that the name "can also refer to something that is not real or has no physical manifestation," and people may tell visiting searchers "what they want to hear."
The adherents' answer
Mackal and colleagues answer that no dinosaur fossil sites exist in central Africa, so the fossil record from other regions "is not applicable to central Africa." They describe the Likouala as a vast, almost untouched swamp-forest of about 60,000 square miles. Agnagna wrote that the animal "is known to many inhabitants of the Likouala region."