The case
On 15 May 1989, KLAS-TV in Las Vegas aired a live interview with a man who used the name "Dennis." As KLAS later reported, he described "a place called S-4, a facility built into the side of a mountain, disguised to look like natural terrain." Seven months later the public learned his name was Bob Lazar.
VICE quotes the 1989 interview. Lazar said: "The propulsion system is a gravity propulsion system and the power source is an antimatter reactor." And: "This technology doesn't exist at all." By his account, the craft used a stable version of element 115. VICE notes that element 115 had not been created in a laboratory when he first spoke. Everything in this section is his account, in his words.
The base itself is documented. On 29 October 2013 the National Security Archive noted that the CIA's U-2 history, declassified that summer, drew attention to "the U-2's secret test site at Area 51 in Nevada," and posted more than 60 declassified documents on stealth aircraft and Soviet MiGs tested there. A documented base is not, by itself, evidence for the S-4 account, and the two are kept apart here. The Area 51 page covers the base.
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the account as a firsthand description of recovered craft, and the element 115 detail as something no outsider could have known in 1989.
The mainstream view
Physics Today reports that in the summer of 2003 researchers at Dubna and Livermore, led by Yuri Oganessian, set out to create element 115, and reported element 115 and its daughter, element 113. Scientific American adds that out of billions of candidates, four atoms of element 115 were detected, each decaying into element 113 after about 90 milliseconds. IUPAC approved the name moscovium (Mc) on 28 November 2016, honoring the Moscow region.
On stability, VICE reports that only four moscovium isotopes have been produced, each lasting fractions of a second, and that scientists have not produced a stable isotope like the one Lazar described.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that the account named element 115 in 1989, fourteen years before any laboratory made it. The laboratory work was done in the summer of 2003 and reported in 2004.