The case
On 9 December 1965, witnesses about 30 miles southeast of Pittsburgh described a fireball, and then an object in the woods near Kecksburg, Pennsylvania. The Associated Press (14 November 2009) reports accounts from media at the time of a metallic, acorn-shaped object about 12 to 15 feet high and 8 to 12 feet across that landed gently. Some witnesses said military personnel cordoned off the site, and that the object left on a truck under a tarp. These are witness descriptions.
Two people kept asking. Space.com quotes the investigator Stan Gordon: "I remain convinced that an object of still undetermined origin fell from the sky into a wooded area near Kecksburg." Leslie Kean told the AP: "I still believe, from all the work and the research and everything, that something came down... But what it was, I have no idea."
Kean submitted a Freedom of Information Act request to NASA dated 31 January 2003 and later sued. In its memorandum opinion of 27 March 2007, the court notes that NASA conceded its first two searches were inadequate, and finds that NASA had not yet shown an adequate search. The AP reports that the suit, backed by the SyFy Channel, settled in October 2007 with NASA paying $50,000 in fees and searching some records, and WIRED covered the reopening. The new search ended in August 2009 with no record of the object.
The Black Vault, run by John Greenewald, adds a trail of paper. It reports that NASA's transmittal slip listed fragment-study records sent to the National Archives in late 1967 or early 1968. In 1996 the Archives told NASA the records were lost, and marked them so back to 1987. A 2021 letter appears to say they were never transferred at all. In July 2021 NASA released more than 220 pages on the lawsuit to the site.
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the cordon, the truck and the missing records as signs that something was recovered and kept from the public.
The mainstream view
VICE quotes a 1965 NASA press release saying the fireball's path was "probably too steep to be consistent with a spacecraft re-entering from Earth orbit and was more likely a meteor ... and probably ended its flight over western Lake Erie." The AP reports that military officials said at the time it was a meteor, and that in 2005 NASA spokesman David Steitz said the object appeared to be a Russian satellite that re-entered and broke up, with fragment records lost in the 1990s. Each statement is the named office's or official's own.
The adherents' answer
As Space.com reports her view, Kean said that data from U.S. Space Command and the Russian Space Agency show that whatever came down was not a Russian satellite. She also told the AP that NASA searched only three offices.