The case
History.com dates the event to 12 September 1952. West Virginia Public Broadcasting describes a Friday evening in September 1952 when children playing after supper at the elementary school in Flatwoods saw something streak overhead and crash into a nearby hill. A local mother went up the hill with the boys. Joe Nickell, in Skeptical Inquirer, describes boys playing football on the school playground, and both Nickell and a United Press story give a group of seven. The witnesses were children and teenagers in 1952, and this page does not name them.
West Virginia Public Broadcasting quotes the director of the Braxton County visitors bureau describing a green and red figure about 10 feet tall, with a red face and a spade-shaped form around the head. The United Press story of 15 September 1952, carried by the Washington Daily News, gives "11 or 12 feet," a "very sickening, hot, stuffy smelling odor" and "clawy hands." Nickell records drape-like folds, a metallic, "sickening, irritating" odour and "a pair of shining eyes." The group ran.
Nickell and the United Press story both record two tracks like skid marks the next morning and a trampled area. The United Press story calls the area "all trampled down" and the tracks "about a foot wide, a car length apart, and about ten yards long." Later accounts, including History.com and Skeptical Inquirer, record that the editor of the Braxton Democrat went up the hill with a shotgun. As the visitors bureau director tells it on West Virginia Public Broadcasting, the sheriff was convinced the witnesses had had a frightening experience; the broadcaster's text says the sheriff "supposedly" thought so. The United Press story quotes the editor: "I don't know what they saw, but they sure saw something on that hill," and "They could have been seen an owl sitting up there in a tree." The United Press wire is not the Braxton Democrat, and this page does not quote the 1952 Braxton Democrat.
Gray Barker, an early chronicler of the case, went to the scene and wrote an account for FATE based on taped interviews, as Skeptical Inquirer notes, citing Barker (1953). History.com says the case prompted an Air Force inquiry under Project Blue Book. The National Archives record card for the case (ATIC Form 329) lists the conclusion "Was Astronomical" and the comment: "The West Virginia monster so called. Actually the object was the well known Washington area meteor of 12 Sep landing near Flatwoods."
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the evening as the landing of a craft whose pilot stepped out. Skeptical Inquirer describes the investigator Sanderson's account of craft "maneuvering in formation," one of which landed at Flatwoods. In this reading the light, the odour, the marks and the figure are one visit.
The mainstream view
The Blue Book record card gives a meteor as the conclusion. Nickell argues in Skeptical Inquirer (November/December 2000) that the fireball was a meteor seen across at least three states. He says the pulsing red light matched "the light from a nearby plane beacon," as a local school teacher said at the time, and that the investigator Sanderson conceded there were three such beacons. He argues that the figure was a barn owl on a branch, with a heart-shaped face, a hissing cry and clawed feet that match the witnesses' own descriptions. History.com, quoting a 1952 news story, records that state police laughed off the reports as hysteria. Audubon (2018), a secondary source, discusses Nickell's owl identification.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that the skid marks and the odour were found at the site afterwards, and that a meteor does not explain either one. History.com says the Braxton Democrat's editor judged the witnesses badly frightened and doubted they could have invented the story so quickly. It also reports that a local mother and the group's National Guard member went to New York to talk to CBS.