The case
On 21 August 1955 a family on a farm near Kelly, Kentucky, said that small, silvery figures with large heads, yellow glowing eyes and clawed hands had approached the house after a bright object came down behind it. Two men fired a 20-gauge shotgun and a .22 rifle (History.com). This page refers to the family and does not name them or the three children.
About 11 p.m., eight adults and three children arrived at the police station in Hopkinsville (History.com). State police, military police from Fort Campbell and local officers went to the farm (History.com). The Kentucky New Era says more than a dozen state, county and city officers went. Its 22 August edition, the contemporary primary text, carried the headline "Story of Space-Ship, 12 Little Men Probed Today" and the line "Bullets Failed To Affect Visitors." The paper reports that officers "remained until after 2 a.m. without seeing anything either to prove or disprove the story."
The colour green came later. Joe Dorris, the New Era reporter, noted in a page on the case site that national media added the colour two or three days afterwards, and that the witnesses never mentioned it.
Blue Book recorded the case as number 10073 but did not officially investigate it. PBS Monstrum says J. Allen Hynek looked into the case and "claimed it to be preposterous."
The PBS transcript also says the family was "mocked, harassed, and overwhelmed" and that most of them "wanted little to do with the story."
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the night as a visit by small beings over several hours, one of the most detailed close encounters on record. History.com says the figures returned between 2:30 a.m. and daybreak, after the police left. A descendant of the family told Kentucky Educational Television, "Something happened that night."
The mainstream view
PBS notes that great horned owls can stand nearly two feet tall. As History.com reports it, Joe Nickell (2006) matched the light to similar reports suggesting a small meteor and proposed great horned owls for the figures.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that none of the witnesses changed their story or recanted (PBS). History.com records that the police chief said the family were not people who "normally run to the police for help. What they do is reach for their guns," and that an investigator measured one man's pulse at 140. Isabel Davis, author of an extensive report, judged the family's matriarch a no-nonsense woman who "had no reason to lie," in History.com's paraphrase. The family described a figure about three-and-a-half feet tall at close range (History.com), which adherents say an owl does not match. The Kentucky New Era's retrospective of 30 December 2002 reports children of a witness defending their father's 1955 account.