The case
Skeptoid says the Loveland story begins in 1955, often said to be May. It has three versions, all with an unnamed businessman or travelling salesman. In the first, he saw three figures three to four feet tall, standing erect, hairless with leathery skin, webbed hands and feet and frog-like faces. Cincinnati Magazine describes "several three-foot-tall creatures with leathery skin and amphibian faces."
At 1 a.m. on 3 March 1972, Skeptoid says, a Loveland police officer driving on Riverside Drive saw a creature three to four feet tall, about 50 to 75 pounds, with leathery skin, crouched like a frog. It stood erect and climbed over the guardrail toward the river. Two weeks later, on St. Patrick's Day, a second officer saw a similar creature crouched on the road and fired at it, and it climbed over the guardrail. His description matched the first, with the addition of a tail. This page says "the first officer" and "the second officer" and names neither. The second officer spoke to WCPO in 2016, and his statements stay attributed to him.
Skeptoid reports it could not find any articles from the time in the Loveland Herald or Cincinnati Enquirer online archives, or anything in the police department's report archives, and notes such records may not have been digitised. Every source cited here was published decades after the sightings, and the earliest is Skeptoid, 30 June 2015. The page does not claim a wider search than Skeptoid describes.
Loveland made the Loveland Frog its official mascot and holds a Frogman Festival (Cincinnati Magazine; Cincinnati CityBeat). A found-footage horror film about the legend was shown at a festival in 2023 (WCPO). A 2016 social media post about a frog-like creature at Lake Isabella prompted the second officer's call to WCPO (WCPO; Snopes).
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the reports as an amphibious, frog-like creature living along the Little Miami River, seen by two police officers within two weeks.
The mainstream view
WCPO (5 August 2016) reports that the second officer said the animal was a large iguana about 3 or 3.5 feet long, missing its tail, probably a released or escaped pet, and that the first officer agreed it was the creature he had seen. In WCPO's account the animal was not walking upright and did not climb over the guardrail, and crawled under it. The officer's own quoted words are "I know no one would believe me, so I shot it." He said he put the body in his trunk to show the first officer.
Cincinnati Magazine says a dead, tailless iguana "could have, but did not, end speculation." Skeptoid notes that Creature from the Black Lagoon came out in 1954, the year before the first sighting.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that the iguana account came more than 40 years after the event (WCPO) and contradicts the first officer's report, as Skeptoid summarises it, of a creature that stood erect and climbed over the guardrail. They add that the 1955 report came before 1972.