The case
On 15 November 1966 two young couples reported a large winged figure with red eyes near the TNT area, a former wartime munitions site outside Point Pleasant, West Virginia. The page does not name the four witnesses. The Point Pleasant Register of 16 November gave the two men's description: about six or seven feet tall, with a 10-foot wingspan and red eyes about two inches across. One of them said, "It was like a man with wings."
The local reporter Mary Hyre wrote 10 columns on the reports by the end of the year, according to West Virginia Public Broadcasting. Her stories ran in the Athens Messenger, where, History.com says, an editor coined the name "Mothman" after Batman's foe Killer Moth. UFO reports began on 22 January 1967 (West Virginia Public Broadcasting).
The sources disagree on how many sightings there were. Eleanor Hasken, writing in Contemporary Legend (Indiana University, 2026), says that John Keel's own timeline lists 21 sightings before 1967 and 5 after the new year. Hasken also records claims of more than a hundred witnesses, and notes that Keel's claim of "hundreds of sightings" has no corroborating record. This page therefore gives no single total.
On 15 December 1967 the Silver Bridge at Point Pleasant collapsed, killing 46 people. The National Transportation Safety Board determined that the collapse began with a cleavage fracture in the lower limb of the eye of eyebar 330 in the north eyebar suspension chain. The NTSB records that 31 of the 37 vehicles on the bridge fell with it. The American Society of Civil Engineers landmark page gives the same date and the same cause, a small crack in one suspension eyebar.
The adherents' reading
Audubon lists the claims of the partisans: an alien, a prophet of doom, or an extra-dimensional spirit. John Keel's The Mothman Prophecies (1975; made into a film in 2002) linked the sightings to the bridge collapse and to men in black. These are Keel's claims and are given here as his. Hasken also names the Curse of Chief Cornstalk as a related theory; it is a named theory, not an established fact.
The mainstream view
Audubon (2018) reports Joe Nickell's reading that a barred owl, with its red eyeshine and a head that blends into its body, matches the original description. It also reports a 2010 MonsterQuest test that showed people misjudging size at night. A 1966 column by Hyre carried the headline "Is Mysterious Creature Balloon Or Crane?" (West Virginia Public Broadcasting).
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that the first witnesses were two couples seeing the same thing together. One of them told History.com that "there were four of us who saw it." Hyre's columns record reports across more than a month. Hasken writes that the reports stopped after the collapse.