The case
By tradition, the creature was born on a stormy night in 1735 at Leeds Point to a woman known as Mother Leeds who, pregnant for the 13th time, cried out, "Let this one be a devil" (National Geographic History). The New Jersey Historical Society names her as Deborah Smith, who married a Mr. Leeds and had 12 children before the 13th. The Atlantic County Library gives a 1735 Quaker-woman version and others, so the birth story comes in several forms.
The Philadelphia Inquirer (2019) says the events of January 1909 seemingly started on 16 January with reports of strange hoofprints and filled newspaper pages for a week. Newspapers across South Jersey and Philadelphia carried reports of hoof-like tracks in snow and sightings of a winged, horse-headed creature. The Sun of New York reported on 21 January that all South Jersey had posses out hunting the "Leed's devil." The Inquirer's front page that day carried a photograph of "actual proof-prints," according to the Inquirer's 2009 article. The Atlantic County Library counts thirty sightings in a week.
The Atlantic County Library says Superintendent Robert D. Carson of the Philadelphia Zoo offered a $10,000 reward; the Inquirer (2019) says the zoo "reportedly" offered it. The library lists businessmen, postal officials and police among those who reported tracks and sightings, and says that published police and newspaper accounts that week turned local belief into a wider story.
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the week as a creature long known in the Pine Barrens appearing again, in line with the older tradition of the Leeds birth story.
The mainstream view
The Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia "could not locate any record of a living or dead species resembling the Jersey Devil," according to the Atlantic County Library. National Geographic History says the Kean University professors Brian Regal and Frank Esposito connect the Leeds name to the 17th-century colonist Daniel Leeds, an almanac publisher whom the Quakers came to call "evil." No 17th-century source calls any of his wives Mother Leeds.
The Inquirer (2019) calls the publicist Norman Jeffries, long dead, "the prime suspect in a case of fake news." It says he had represented the Dime Museum at Ninth and Arch Streets, which advertised the captured Leeds Devil on 24 January, that his obituary called the exhibit a "cleverly disguised kangaroo," and that he later confessed to staging a stunt. This role is from the Inquirer alone. The Atlantic County Library separately says that animal trainers at the Arch Street Museum made a Devil from a kangaroo painted with green stripes and false wings. The library also records a sandhill crane theory.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that businessmen, postal officials and policemen were among those reporting tracks and sightings (Atlantic County Library), on both sides of the Delaware from Trenton to the bay (Inquirer, 2019), and that the reports ran in many papers, not only near one exhibit.