The case
Norwegian sources describe a huge sea creature that fishers met over deep water. The Biodiversity Heritage Library says the thirteenth-century Norwegian text Konungs skuggsjá, the King's Mirror, describes a beast that appears "more like an island than a fish," which a 1917 translation identifies as the Kraken.
The account most often quoted is Erik Pontoppidan's Natural History of Norway, published in Danish in 1752 to 1753 and in English in 1755. He calls the creature "incontestibly the largest Sea-monster in the world," and gives its names as "Kraken, Kraxen, or, as some name it, Krabben." He says he writes from what his correspondents related. He reports that fishers "unanimously affirm" that where they expect 80 or 100 fathoms of water they sometimes find only 20 or 30, with plenty of fish, and that they row away if the water keeps shoaling. Its back, he says, "looks at first like a number of small islands." He gives "about an English mile and an half in circumference," the smallest estimate he knew.
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the shifting seabed and the agreement of many crews as the sign of one great animal. In this reading the fishers were describing something they met again and again, and Pontoppidan was recording their word for it. The older Norwegian text and the 1755 account are taken together as one long tradition of reports from the same waters.
The mainstream view
The Biodiversity Heritage Library says the giant squid, Architeuthis dux, was for centuries known as the Kraken. Kubodera and Mori (2005) report the first images of a live giant squid in the wild, at 900 metres off the Ogasawara Islands, and a severed tentacle confirmed an animal greater than 8 metres. Nature News and Scientific American, both in September 2005, covered the same images and the DNA comparison with stranded specimens. Nature News adds that more than 580 individuals had washed ashore over the years. Winkelmann and colleagues (2013) sampled 43 giant squid and found results consistent with one global species.
On this view the squid is the mainstream candidate for the animal behind the name. The sources describe the squid itself. They do not say what Pontoppidan's correspondents saw.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that an animal of about 8 metres is not a mile of back. If Pontoppidan's figures are taken as written, the older reports may describe something far larger, or something different. The 2005 images show a real giant squid, and adherents ask whether that settles what the fishers met in the shoaling water.