The case
The Ningen, Japanese for "human" and also called "hitogata," or human shape, is described as a pale, human-shaped being, tens of metres long, seen in the Southern Ocean near Japan's research whaling fleet. The account began as an anonymous post on the Japanese message board 2channel, now 5channel, in May 2002.
Greenland and Hayward (Shima, 2020), the one peer-reviewed study, date it to 11 May 2002 at 13:21, the 68th item in a thread titled "Giant Fish, Monster Fish" on its occult board. The archived thread shows the post, by a poster using the name Baito-kun, "part-timer." It says the information came directly from a person involved in research whaling who wanted to stay anonymous. A later post by the same poster says the story was really heard and was not a joke, translated from Japanese. A dedicated thread opened the same day, and five continuation threads followed, the last running until December 2003. The paper reports that the threads cited an "Antarctic Godzilla" reputedly witnessed in 1958 by the crew of the Sōya-maru. It also reports that in 2007 the magazine Mu printed Google Earth imagery of a white limbed figure, purportedly 19 metres long, off Namibia.
The adherents' reading
Adherents who take the account seriously point to the research-whaling setting, to the 1958 crew claim, and to the later retellings and images. All That's Interesting says some believe sightings go back to the 1950s. The Mirror (18 March 2016) reported a video captioned as a Ningen, with a stated length of 60 to 90 feet. The story has kept travelling this way, and this page records how it travels without giving a verdict.
The mainstream view
Greenland and Hayward call the Ningen "a mythical creature created by Japanese Internet users in the mid-2000s," and read it as "media-lore." They quote the commentator Jong: "In still images, the sea cryptids mostly just look like ice." Gaia calls the circulating videos and photos "lackluster" and "questionable," and says none provides definitive proof. All That's Interesting says reported sightings may be icebergs, albino whales or a mirage effect, and attributes this to Science Insights.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that finding where a story began does not show that nothing was seen. The post and the later retellings are one question, they say, and what the crews saw is another. What, if anything, did the crews see?