Browse all theories tagged with this keyword
The Feejee Mermaid is a mummified figure with a monkey-like head and a fish tail. Live Science says that Samuel Barrett Eades bought it from the Dutch in January 1822, showed it in London from September 1822, and that two naturalists he invited called it fake. After his death his son sold it to Moses Kimball of the Boston Museum, in the early 1840s. In 1842 Kimball and P. T. Barnum arranged its New York showing: Adrienne Saint-Pierre told Live Science that "Barnum leased the mermaid from Kimball". Live Science says that during the 1842 tour one Charleston newspaper vouched for it while another called it a fraud. Harvard's Peabody Museum says that "Japanese craftsmen fabricated mermaids by joining the bodies of monkeys and fish, although the head and torso of this example are made from papier-mâché". The Boston Globe (2016) records curator Diana Loren calling its Peabody figure "an amalgam of papier-mâché, fish and possibly monkey parts, and wood", and says Kimball told the Globe in an interview that he knew it was a "fraud". In October 2023, radiology students at Northern Kentucky University scanned the Clark County Historical Society's figure from Springfield, Ohio. The Springfield News-Sun reports that the scans showed what appeared to be fish scales and a fish jaw, wooden rods, metal, cotton stuffing and likely papier-mâché; The Northerner adds that further tests are needed. Loren told the Crimson it is "unclear" whether the Peabody figure is the exact specimen Barnum showed, and Saint-Pierre told Live Science the Peabody has "no solid documentation" that it is, while the Globe reports Loren saying the museum has documentation suggesting it is. Provenance also differs: Live Science says Eades bought it from the Dutch; the Globe says a sailor visiting Japan bought it in 1822; the Peabody says Kimball bought it from the son of a Boston sea captain. Adherents answer that it is not established that the Peabody figure is the one Barnum showed.
Otodus (formerly Carcharocles) megalodon is the largest shark known from the fossil record, and its teeth are common finds. On 4 August 2013 the Discovery Channel opened Shark Week with "Megalodon: The Monster Shark Lives", a film that National Geographic says Discovery calls "dramatized", with actors playing scientists who hunt a live 67-foot (20 m) shark, nicknamed "Submarine", off South Africa. National Geographic reports that Discovery aired disclaimers but also said that "sightings of 'Submarine' continue to this day." The Atlantic (6 August 2013) reports around 5 million viewers, a Shark Week record, and quotes blogger Christie Wilcox that, by Discovery's own poll, "upwards of 70%" of viewers came away believing megalodon is not extinct. People who keep the idea open point to how little of the deep sea has been surveyed. Snopes grants that "it's not absolutely impossible that an undocumented species of huge shark lives in the oceans' depths". Pimiento and Clements (PLOS ONE, 2014) applied an optimal linear estimation model to the fossil record and concluded that the species "went extinct around 2.6 Ma". Boessenecker and colleagues (PeerJ, 2019) found that every record from the eastern North Pacific later than the early Pliocene shows reworking or lacks reliable provenance, put the extinction at about 3.6 Ma, and gave a median of 3.51 Ma when they re-ran the earlier dataset. National Geographic says megalodon's skeleton was mostly cartilage, so "nothing remains of the creature except its teeth". Snopes rates the film's capsized-boat claim False and quotes marine scientist Daniel Holstein: "There's about as much scientific controversy about the possibility of Megalodons lurking in today's oceans as there is about mermaids. None." Adherents answer that those dates are model estimates from a limited record, and that a last-occurrence estimate says when the fossil record ends and nothing about what lives unseen.
The Ningen ("human" in Japanese; also "hitogata", human shape) is described as a pale, human-shaped being, tens of metres long, seen in the Southern Ocean near Japan's research whaling fleet. The account began as an anonymous post on the Japanese message board 2channel (now 5channel) in May 2002. Greenland and Hayward (Shima, 2020), the one peer-reviewed study, date it to 11 May 2002 at 13:21, the 68th item in a thread titled "Giant Fish, Monster Fish" on its occult board. The archived thread shows the post, by a poster using the name Baito-kun ("part-timer"). It says the information came directly from a person involved in research whaling who wanted to stay anonymous, and a later post by the same poster says the story was really heard and was not a joke (translated from Japanese). A dedicated thread opened the same day, and five continuation threads followed, the last running until December 2003 (the paper). The paper reports that the threads cited an "Antarctic Godzilla" reputedly witnessed in 1958 by the crew of the Sōya-maru, and that in 2007 the magazine Mu printed Google Earth imagery of a white limbed figure, purportedly 19 m long, off Namibia. Adherents who take the account seriously point to the research-whaling setting, to the 1958 crew claim and to the later retellings and images. The Mirror (18 March 2016) reported a video captioned as a Ningen with a stated length of 60 to 90 feet. Greenland and Hayward call the Ningen "a mythical creature created by Japanese Internet users in the mid-2000s" and read it as "media-lore". They quote the commentator Jong: "In still images, the sea cryptids mostly just look like ice". Gaia calls the circulating videos and photos "lackluster" and "questionable", and All That's Interesting says reported sightings may be icebergs, albino whales or a mirage effect (it attributes this to Science Insights). Adherents answer that finding where a story began does not show that nothing was seen.
Norwegian sources describe a huge sea creature that fishers met over deep water. The Biodiversity Heritage Library says the thirteenth-century Norwegian Konungs skuggsjá (the King's Mirror) describes a beast that appears "more like an island than a fish", which a 1917 translation identifies as the Kraken. Erik Pontoppidan's Natural History of Norway (Danish 1752 to 1753; English 1755) gave the account most often quoted. He calls it "incontestibly the largest Sea-monster in the world", names it "Kraken, Kraxen, or, as some name it, Krabben", and says he writes from what his correspondents related. He reports that fishers "unanimously affirm" that where they expect 80 or 100 fathoms they sometimes find only 20 or 30, with plenty of fish, and that they row away if the water keeps shoaling. Its back, he says, "looks at first like a number of small islands", and he gives "about an English mile and an half in circumference", the smallest estimate he knew. Adherents read the shifting seabed and the agreement of many crews as one great animal. The Biodiversity Heritage Library says the giant squid, Architeuthis dux, was for centuries known as the Kraken. Kubodera and Mori (2005) report the first images of a live giant squid in the wild, at 900 m off the Ogasawara Islands, and a severed tentacle confirmed an animal greater than 8 m. Winkelmann et al. (2013) sampled 43 giant squid and found results consistent with one global species, Architeuthis dux. Adherents answer that an animal of about 8 m is not a mile of back, so the older reports may describe something far larger or different.
Animal Planet's Mermaids specials presented fictional scientists, underwater images and government suppression in documentary form. Some viewers treated that presentation as evidence, prompting real questions to NOAA. The creator described his work as science fiction built around environmental concerns, while contemporary criticism examined the disclaimers and marketing. The documented case is a manufactured cover-up narrative entering public discussion, not evidence that NOAA discovered and concealed aquatic humans.