The case
The Feejee Mermaid is a mummified figure with a monkey-like head and a fish tail. Live Science says that Samuel Barrett Eades bought it from the Dutch in January 1822, showed it in London from September 1822, and that two naturalists he invited called it fake. After his death his son sold it to Moses Kimball of the Boston Museum, in the early 1840s. In 1842 Kimball and P. T. Barnum arranged its New York showing: Adrienne Saint-Pierre told Live Science that "Barnum leased the mermaid from Kimball."
Live Science says that during the 1842 tour one Charleston newspaper vouched for it while another called it a fraud.
The adherents' reading
Adherents take the figure's long run of exhibitions, and the disagreement about it in the press of the day, as part of the case. Provenance also differs between sources. Live Science says Eades bought it from the Dutch; the Boston Globe says a sailor visiting Japan bought it in 1822; the Peabody says Kimball bought it from the son of a Boston sea captain. These accounts are given as each source states them and are not resolved here.
The mainstream view
Harvard's Peabody Museum says that "Japanese craftsmen fabricated mermaids by joining the bodies of monkeys and fish, although the head and torso of this example are made from papier-mâché." The Boston Globe (2016) records the curator Diana Loren calling the Peabody figure "an amalgam of papier-mâché, fish and possibly monkey parts, and wood," and says Kimball told the Globe in an interview that he knew it was a "fraud."
In October 2023, radiology students at Northern Kentucky University scanned the Clark County Historical Society's figure from Springfield, Ohio. The Springfield News-Sun reports that the scans showed what appeared to be fish scales and a fish jaw, wooden rods, metal, cotton stuffing and likely papier-mâché. The Northerner adds that further tests are needed.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that it is not established that the Peabody figure is the one Barnum showed. Loren told the Crimson it is "unclear" whether the Peabody figure is the exact specimen Barnum showed, and Saint-Pierre told Live Science the Peabody has "no solid documentation" that it is. The Globe reports Loren saying the museum has documentation suggesting it is. Was it the same object?