Browse all theories tagged with this keyword
The Holy Lance in Vienna's imperial treasury is, per the Kunsthistorisches Museum (KHM), a Carolingian winged lance of the 8th century. The KHM says "pious wishful thinking" turned an iron pin set in the blade into one of the nails of the cross, and that in the 13th century the lance came to be seen as that of Longinus. Trevor Ravenscroft's *The Spear of Destiny* says that Hitler was obsessed with the lance. Time quotes the line "Whomsoever claims this spear and solves its secrets holds the destiny of the world in his hands". The book's date differs by source: 1972 (Bad Archaeology, naming Neville Spearman) or 1973 (All About History). Sky HISTORY says American forces located the lance "just two hours" before Hitler's death on 30 April 1945. Robert Feather, a British metallurgist, examined the lance in 2003 (Time Europe, 8 June 2003) and "found the main body of the spear to be medieval, dating to the 7th century at the earliest", which is compatible with the KHM's 8th century. Bad Archaeology, a blog by museum curator Keith Fitzpatrick-Matthews, says Ravenscroft "admitted in 1982" that his contact with his source, Walter Johannes Stein, was "conducted entirely through a medium", and that the book's style is "decidedly novelistic". All About History says Stein said nothing of such a claim in his lifetime. The sources also differ on the recovery: Bad Archaeology says Walter Horn of the US Army found the regalia's hiding place in 1946, while a US Army account says that on 7 August 1945 Horn located several missing pieces of the Imperial Regalia, including the crown, orb, scepter and two swords, and that the regalia returned to Austria on 4 January 1946. Feather also told Time that the iron pin is "consistent" in length and shape with a first-century Roman nail, that science cannot date the iron fragments around it, and that "We're in the realm of speculation, but you cannot rule it out." Adherents answer that the pin cannot be ruled out as a first-century nail.
The National Science and Media Museum (2012) says that in 1917 Frances Griffiths and her cousin Elsie Wright began a series of five photographs, showing the girls with fairies, at Cottingley Beck. In 1920 the photographs reached Edward Gardner of the Theosophical Society and then Arthur Conan Doyle, who published the first two in the Christmas 1920 Strand Magazine under the names "Alice" and "Iris" (Leeds Library; Bradford Museums). Cooper gives the first Strand publication as the end of 1919. Gardner supplied a camera and marked plates, and three more photographs followed in August 1920. Doyle's *The Coming of the Fairies* (1922) set out the case. Doyle's book opens by saying the incidents were "either the most elaborate and ingenious hoax ever played upon the public" or "an event in human history which may in the future appear to have been epoch-making in its character". In a letter to the photographic journalist Geoffrey Crawley dated 17 February 1983, Elsie (by then Elsie Hill) said all five photographs were staged (Science and Media Museum; the Leeds Library says she "finally wrote a letter of confession in 1983"). Joe Cooper's interview in The Unexplained (cited as issue 117, 1982; the Guardian says 1983) reports that "in late 1981 and mid 1982 respectively" Frances (Way) and Elsie (Hill) admitted the first four were fakes, made from gift-book illustrations fixed in place with hatpins. Frances said until her death that the fifth photograph, "Fairy Sunbath, Elves, etc.", was genuine and that she had seen fairies at the beck (Science and Media Museum; Bradford Museums; Cooper). She told Cooper: "I saw these fairies building up in the grasses and just aimed the camera and took a photograph." Both photographers are deceased (Frances Griffiths 1907 to 1986, Elsie Wright 1901 to 1988, per the Museum). Adherents point to Frances's statement that the fifth photograph is genuine, and to Cooper's remark that whether fairies exist "remains an open question".
The Feejee Mermaid is a mummified figure with a monkey-like head and a fish tail. Live Science says that Samuel Barrett Eades bought it from the Dutch in January 1822, showed it in London from September 1822, and that two naturalists he invited called it fake. After his death his son sold it to Moses Kimball of the Boston Museum, in the early 1840s. In 1842 Kimball and P. T. Barnum arranged its New York showing: Adrienne Saint-Pierre told Live Science that "Barnum leased the mermaid from Kimball". Live Science says that during the 1842 tour one Charleston newspaper vouched for it while another called it a fraud. Harvard's Peabody Museum says that "Japanese craftsmen fabricated mermaids by joining the bodies of monkeys and fish, although the head and torso of this example are made from papier-mâché". The Boston Globe (2016) records curator Diana Loren calling its Peabody figure "an amalgam of papier-mâché, fish and possibly monkey parts, and wood", and says Kimball told the Globe in an interview that he knew it was a "fraud". In October 2023, radiology students at Northern Kentucky University scanned the Clark County Historical Society's figure from Springfield, Ohio. The Springfield News-Sun reports that the scans showed what appeared to be fish scales and a fish jaw, wooden rods, metal, cotton stuffing and likely papier-mâché; The Northerner adds that further tests are needed. Loren told the Crimson it is "unclear" whether the Peabody figure is the exact specimen Barnum showed, and Saint-Pierre told Live Science the Peabody has "no solid documentation" that it is, while the Globe reports Loren saying the museum has documentation suggesting it is. Provenance also differs: Live Science says Eades bought it from the Dutch; the Globe says a sailor visiting Japan bought it in 1822; the Peabody says Kimball bought it from the son of a Boston sea captain. Adherents answer that it is not established that the Peabody figure is the one Barnum showed.
Small three-fingered bodies said to come from southern Peru have been shown to the public since about 2017. "Mummies" is in quotation marks because Peru's forensic institute says the seized figures it examined are not mummies. On 12 September 2023, Mexico's Chamber of Deputies held a hearing, at which two bodies were presented as beings found in Peru. Jaime Maussan, who presented them, said they were found in 2017 between Palpa and Nazca, that "they are beings that are not part of our earthly evolution", and that UNAM carbon-14 analysis gave "around 1,000 years". On 7 November 2023 the chamber held a second session at which, AP reports, a Peruvian physician showed X-rays and photographs of a find he said was recent. On 12 January 2024 in Lima, Peru's forensic institute and Ministry of Culture presented results on two figures seized in October 2023 at the airport as they were about to be sent to Mexico, and on a three-fingered hand handed in during April 2019. The press note says the figures are "constructions, with the same anatomical forms as a human being, made with animal bones joined with synthetic adhesives", and the hand is "composed of human bones, cotton and glue". DW and EFE both say the seized figures were very similar to, not the same as, the bodies shown in Mexico. EFE places the Mexican bodies' origin at Cuzco where DW says Palpa and Nazca. On 9 November 2024, Peru's Congress held a hearing led by congressman Germán Tacuri, which El Comercio says lasted almost three hours. Forensic archaeologist Flavio Estrada told El Comercio that the arguments for authenticity "lacked scientific support" and that the larger bodies are altered human remains of archaeological origin. UNAM's Instituto de Física says its work only dates samples and "in no case do we draw conclusions about the origin of those samples". Adherents answer that the laboratory did return an age of about 1,000 years, and that Peru examined different objects from those shown in Mexico.
The remains known as "Ata" are of a very small individual, about 15 cm (6 in) long according to the 2018 genome paper, reported to have been found in 2003 at La Noria, in the Tarapacá region of northern Chile. The skull is elongated, there are fewer ribs than expected, and the bone looks older than the size suggests. For years the remains were presented as a possible non-human being, and the genome paper says a documentary hypothesized "a preserved humanoid or possible evidence of alien life". Bhattacharya et al. (Genome Research, 2018; senior authors Garry Nolan and Atul Butte) report that "Ata is a female of human origin, likely of Chilean descent", with mutations in seven genes linked to short stature, rib anomalies, cranial malformation, premature joint fusion and skeletal dysplasia, and that "it seems likely the specimen was a preterm birth". Reported ages differ: Stanford's release says the skeleton is approximately 40 years old; Nolan and Butte's later statement says the DNA proved it "500 years old or less", possibly "considerably younger", and that the film team had claimed thousands of years. Nolan and Butte say the remains "should be repatriated and accorded proper respect as human remains", that they are "now privately held by an individual in Spain", and that none of the senior authors has seen or handled them. BBC Mundo (29 March 2018) reports that Chile's National Monuments Council lodged a complaint asking whether the remains were illegally exhumed in 2003 and taken out of the country. La Tercera (28 November 2018) quotes prosecutor Hardy Torres on the inquiry. In coverage reprinted by the Sociedad de Bioquímica y Biología Molecular de Chile, Chilean researchers asked whether the ethics of the skeleton's origin were considered before the analysis, and whether Chilean law was broken when the body left the country. No return or burial is documented. Those who held the earlier readings answer that the question was open when the research began.
Otodus (formerly Carcharocles) megalodon is the largest shark known from the fossil record, and its teeth are common finds. On 4 August 2013 the Discovery Channel opened Shark Week with "Megalodon: The Monster Shark Lives", a film that National Geographic says Discovery calls "dramatized", with actors playing scientists who hunt a live 67-foot (20 m) shark, nicknamed "Submarine", off South Africa. National Geographic reports that Discovery aired disclaimers but also said that "sightings of 'Submarine' continue to this day." The Atlantic (6 August 2013) reports around 5 million viewers, a Shark Week record, and quotes blogger Christie Wilcox that, by Discovery's own poll, "upwards of 70%" of viewers came away believing megalodon is not extinct. People who keep the idea open point to how little of the deep sea has been surveyed. Snopes grants that "it's not absolutely impossible that an undocumented species of huge shark lives in the oceans' depths". Pimiento and Clements (PLOS ONE, 2014) applied an optimal linear estimation model to the fossil record and concluded that the species "went extinct around 2.6 Ma". Boessenecker and colleagues (PeerJ, 2019) found that every record from the eastern North Pacific later than the early Pliocene shows reworking or lacks reliable provenance, put the extinction at about 3.6 Ma, and gave a median of 3.51 Ma when they re-ran the earlier dataset. National Geographic says megalodon's skeleton was mostly cartilage, so "nothing remains of the creature except its teeth". Snopes rates the film's capsized-boat claim False and quotes marine scientist Daniel Holstein: "There's about as much scientific controversy about the possibility of Megalodons lurking in today's oceans as there is about mermaids. None." Adherents answer that those dates are model estimates from a limited record, and that a last-occurrence estimate says when the fossil record ends and nothing about what lives unseen.
Norwegian sources describe a huge sea creature that fishers met over deep water. The Biodiversity Heritage Library says the thirteenth-century Norwegian Konungs skuggsjá (the King's Mirror) describes a beast that appears "more like an island than a fish", which a 1917 translation identifies as the Kraken. Erik Pontoppidan's Natural History of Norway (Danish 1752 to 1753; English 1755) gave the account most often quoted. He calls it "incontestibly the largest Sea-monster in the world", names it "Kraken, Kraxen, or, as some name it, Krabben", and says he writes from what his correspondents related. He reports that fishers "unanimously affirm" that where they expect 80 or 100 fathoms they sometimes find only 20 or 30, with plenty of fish, and that they row away if the water keeps shoaling. Its back, he says, "looks at first like a number of small islands", and he gives "about an English mile and an half in circumference", the smallest estimate he knew. Adherents read the shifting seabed and the agreement of many crews as one great animal. The Biodiversity Heritage Library says the giant squid, Architeuthis dux, was for centuries known as the Kraken. Kubodera and Mori (2005) report the first images of a live giant squid in the wild, at 900 m off the Ogasawara Islands, and a severed tentacle confirmed an animal greater than 8 m. Winkelmann et al. (2013) sampled 43 giant squid and found results consistent with one global species, Architeuthis dux. Adherents answer that an animal of about 8 m is not a mile of back, so the older reports may describe something far larger or different.
On the morning of 31 January 1921 the Coast Guard at Cape Hatteras spotted a five-masted schooner aground on Diamond Shoals with all sails set. When boarders finally reached her days later, the Carroll A. Deering was empty: no crew, no log, no navigation instruments, no boats, food laid out as if for a meal, and three half-starved cats. Five federal departments looked into the case. Washington openly suspected foul play, from pirates to Bolshevik agents, and the case was never closed.
Since December 1981, residents of Hessdalen, a 12 km valley in central Norway, have reported lights that hover for over an hour, drift, stop or race away. Unlike most light legends, Hessdalen has been watched with radar, magnetometers, spectrographs and cameras for four decades. Researchers have tracked the lights on radar and written about them in scientific journals, yet no accepted explanation exists. Some measurements reported by researchers, including lights that seemed to respond to a laser and radiant power up to 19 kW, do not fit easy answers.
On clear nights east of Marfa in Presidio County, Texas, observers facing the Chinati Mountains report lights that appear on the horizon, twinkle, split, merge, drift and vanish. Local history dates them to an 1883 sighting by a young cowhand who took them for Apache campfires but found no ashes. Adherents hold that at least some of the lights are a genuine unexplained phenomenon: they predate cars, retreat when approached, and have outlasted searches on horseback, from the air and with cameras.
On 2 July 1937 Amelia Earhart and navigator Fred Noonan left Lae, New Guinea, for Howland Island, a speck in the central Pacific where the Coast Guard cutter Itasca waited. Their last logged message said they were "on the line 157 337." Then nothing. The Navy and Coast Guard searched for two weeks and found no trace. Adherents reject the "ran out of fuel and sank" answer and back one of two alternatives: capture by the Japanese in the Marshall Islands, or a castaway death on Nikumaroro.
In February 1959 nine experienced ski hikers led by Igor Dyatlov died on the slope the Mansi call Kholat Syakhl in Russia's northern Urals. Searchers found their tent cut open from the inside and their tracks leading downhill into the cold, many without boots. Some had severe injuries, and a Soviet lab found radioactivity on clothing. The investigator closed the case citing an "overwhelming force." Prosecutors concluded in 2020 that an avalanche was to blame. A lawyer for the families' foundation rejected that finding.
On 5 December 1872 the British brig Dei Gratia found the American brigantine Mary Celeste between the Azores and Portugal, sound, provisioned and under sail, with no one aboard. Captain Benjamin Briggs, his wife Sarah, their two-year-old daughter Sophia and seven crewmen were gone, along with the ship's boat and papers. The 1873 press reported a bloodstained sword and cuts on the bows, and the U.S. Treasury wrote of "grave suspicions" of murder. No body, boat or survivor was ever found.
Adherents hold that the wilderness around Glastenbury Mountain in southwestern Vermont, near Bennington and the ghost towns of Glastenbury and Somerset, is a place where people walk into the woods and never come back. Adherents count at least five people who vanished there between 1945 and 1950, most famously 18-year-old Bennington College student Paula Jean Welden in 1946. Her case is still open with the Vermont State Police, the agency her disappearance helped create. Author Joseph Citro named the area the Bennington Triangle in 1992 and ties it to much older lore.
Adherents trace a triangle on Lake Michigan from Manitowoc, Wisconsin, east to Ludington and south to Benton Harbor, Michigan, where ships, aircraft and people have vanished and strange lights have been seen. In June 1950 Northwest Airlines Flight 2501 went down there with 58 aboard, and its wreck has never been found. In 1921 the schooner Rosa Belle was found floating upside down with her whole crew gone. Later accounts add a freighter captain who vanished in 1937 from a cabin locked from the inside.
Adherents call the waters south of Tokyo, around Miyake-jima and the Izu chain toward the Bonin Islands, the Devil's Sea or the Dragon's Triangle: the Pacific twin of the Bermuda Triangle. According to CNN, author Charles Berlitz wrote that Japan lost five military vessels and about 100 scientists there between 1952 and 1954. The emblem case is the government survey ship Kaiyo Maru No. 5, sent in September 1952 to study a new volcano. She went silent, and neither her crew nor her hull was ever found.
Adherents say a stretch of the western North Atlantic between Florida, Bermuda and Puerto Rico swallows ships and aircraft and leaves no wreckage, no bodies and often no distress call. In December 1945 five Navy Avengers radioed that their compasses were out and vanished with 14 men, and a flying boat sent to find them was lost with 13 more. In 1918 the collier USS Cyclops disappeared without sending a word. The Navy's own ship history still calls her loss one of the sea's unsolved mysteries.
In 2020 the World Economic Forum and Sberbank's BI.ZONE ran Cyber Polygon, an exercise built around a "digital pandemic," and Klaus Schwab opened it by saying COVID-19 would look like "a small disturbance" next to a cyberattack that halts power, transport and hospitals. Event 201 had rehearsed a coronavirus pandemic months before COVID. In North America, NERC's GridEx drills simulate a nation-state attack on the grid, and GridEx VIII in 2025 planned to keep running "while public trust is damaged." Some believe these drills are rehearsals.
On August 14, 2003, a blackout spread from Ohio across eight states and Ontario and left about 50 million people without power. The investigation blamed a silent bug in FirstEnergy's alarm software and transmission lines sagging into overgrown trees. But the blackout hit three days after the Blaster worm began tearing through the internet. Computers failed one after another at the utility at the worst possible moment, and a leading security expert said it looked like a malicious worm. Officials say the worm played no part.
Just before 1 a.m. on April 16, 2013, someone cut the fiber cables around PG&E's Metcalf substation near San Jose, then opened fire on its transformers, knocking out 17 of them and vanishing before police arrived. No one has ever been charged. The former head of FERC called it the worst act of domestic terrorism against the US grid and feared it was a dry run. The FBI said it was not terrorism, and Homeland Security talk of an insider was quickly walked back. The case is still open.
The Ica stones are promoted as an engraved library left by an advanced extraterrestrial civilization. The museum’s own explanation makes that claim explicit, while original investigations and expert reporting identify weak provenance and signs of recent manufacture. Accounts of confessions and retractions cite different dates and events; the 1975 interview and 1977 BBCmaterial have not been independently recovered. Those gaps must remain visible, not converted into a precise invented chronology or proof of an ancient alien archive.
Gail Brewer-Giorgio argued that Elvis Presley entered witness protection after an undercover FBI operation. Her claim has identifiable interview provenance, but the public records cited around it document different things: admiration for the Bureau, an offer to help, a headquarters tour and a narcotics badge. Original reporting, a proponent interview and archival histories distinguish these contacts from an actual operational assignment. No recovered record establishes the alleged 1976 recruitment or a staged death.
The Minnesota Iceman became a proposed new hominid after an examination through glass and ice. Later accounts protected the biological claim by distinguishing a missing original from a manufactured replacement, but even the principal investigators did not agree about that distinction. A complete 1969 report, opposing book reviews, 2013 reporting and the present exhibitor's custody correction reveal a contested chain of observation and ownership—not a recovered specimen available for biological testing.
Project Alpha placed two magicians inside a university psychic-research laboratory without disclosing their coordination with James Randi. His account describes ordinary methods behind apparent powers. The laboratory's own research briefs and Peter Phillips's reply complicate the familiar victory story: controls changed, later statistics were mixed, and researchers disputed the publicity. The documents establish deception, not a verdict on every paranormal claim or researcher.