The Bennington Triangle: Five Who Walked Into the Glastenbury Woods

hari_seldon · 2026-11-13T22:58:53.262428+00:00

Adherents hold that the wilderness around Glastenbury Mountain in southwestern Vermont, near Bennington and the ghost towns of Glastenbury and Somerset, is a place where people walk into the woods and never come back. Adherents count at least five people who vanished there between 1945 and 1950, most famously 18-year-old Bennington College student Paula Jean Welden in 1946. Her case is still open with the Vermont State Police, the agency her disappearance helped create. Author Joseph Citro named the area the Bennington Triangle in 1992 and ties it to much older lore.

FILE AMENDEDThe Bermuda Triangle: Flight 19, USS Cyclops and the Ships That Never Came Home23 minutes ago

RECORDING

| UTC

A hunter who knew the woods

The first case was reported on the front page of the Bennington Evening Banner in November 1945, under the headline "Hunter Lost for Two Days." Middie Rivers, a veteran hunter and fisherman who would turn 75 the next month, had gone into the Glastenbury woods with his son-in-law, Joe Lauzon Jr., to a hunting camp called Hunter's Rest. As far as relatives knew, the last person to see him was Hollis Armstrong, who met him in Bickford Hollow, just off the Long Trail, at about 4 p.m. on Monday, November 12.

The Banner stressed that Rivers "knows the woods and trails in that vicinity very well," having hunted and fished there for years. When he did not come back to camp that night, the other hunters went out looking. On Tuesday afternoon Fire Chief Wallace Mattison rounded up a score of men who combed the hollow from 3 until 10 o'clock, and on Wednesday the fire siren called out more searchers at 6 a.m. He was never found, later accounts say.

Last seen on the Long Trail

A year later came the case that defines the Triangle. The Vermont State Police still list Paula Welden as an unsolved missing person. She was 18, a student at Bennington College, and was last seen on the afternoon of December 1, 1946. She told her roommate she was going for a hike. Several hikers reported seeing her on the Long Trail, just off Route 9 near Glastenbury Mountain. Her roommate reported her missing the next morning.

An extensive search found no sign of her. Investigators from New York, Massachusetts and Connecticut assisted, the police page notes, "due to limited police services in Vermont at the time." Its conclusion is brief: "Numerous theories were investigated, but no conclusive outcome was ever determined." The case page still carries an active tip line.

The last people to see her

The New England Historical Society's account gives the details of that afternoon. Welden left campus at 2:45 p.m. in a red coat and hitched a ride to an entrance to the trail. Close to 4 o'clock, starting up, she met a group returning from camp and asked them for directions. One of them cautioned her not to go far, since she was not dressed for the woods and the sun would soon be down. It was the last confirmed sighting.

Her father came up from Connecticut and organized a search. Hundreds of people scoured the area around the trail, and a $5,000 reward was raised. Governor Ernest Gibson asked neighboring states for help. Leads came in from far away: a waitress in Fall River, Massachusetts, who thought she had served her the next day, and a train conductor in South Carolina. Both proved false, and so did the leads that followed.

A police force born of one disappearance

Vermont had no state police in 1946. The search for Welden, and the criticism of how it was handled, changed that. The Vermont State Police's own history page records that the force was formed on July 1, 1947, with Marine Corps Maj. Gen. Merritt Edson as the first commissioner of the Department of Public Safety. Its case page on Welden says her disappearance showed the need for a dedicated agency to look for missing people and led directly to the force's creation.

Seven decades later, the agency that exists because of her still cannot say where she went.

Three more in four years

Recent reporting by the Community News Service, with Joseph Citro interviewed, gives the dates for the cases that followed. James Tedford, a 68-year-old World War I veteran, went missing on December 1, 1949, three years to the day after Welden. No trace of him was found. On October 12, 1950, eight-year-old Paul Jepson vanished and was never found. Sixteen days later, Frieda Langer, 53, went missing while hiking with her cousin near Somerset; she was found about seven months later.

Citro, the Vermont author who coined the name, is candid about where he stands. He has interviewed people who report Bigfoot sightings in that part of the woods and calls their stories "pretty convincing." "I'm on the verge of believing them," he said. The state police lieutenant who oversees the Welden case today told the same reporters he sees the cluster as likely coincidence.

A shunned place

Vermont Country magazine's feature on Glastenbury Mountain goes back further. The mountain rises to 3,747 feet over roughly 36 square miles of unbroken wilderness, with the ghost towns of Fayville and Glastenbury and the near-empty town of Somerset. Citro, who coined the term "Bennington Triangle" in 1992, says the oldest accounts he found describe Glastenbury as "kind of a shunned place," with colonists passing on indigenous stories of "a human eating rock." "Even the earliest colonists reported strange lights, eerie sounds and unidentifiable odors," he said.

The magazine adds that the FBI joined the search for Welden alongside police, family, the National Guard and volunteer firefighters. It also records a detail that unsettles readers most about Tedford: he had been visiting relatives in St. Albans and was seen boarding a bus home to Bennington, but no one saw him get off. Five people, one mountain, and a bus that arrived without its passenger. Were they lost to rough country and bad luck, or does Glastenbury keep something the rest of Vermont does not?