The case
The remains known as "Ata" are of a very small individual, about 15 cm (6 in) long according to the 2018 genome paper. They were reported to have been found in 2003 at La Noria, in the Tarapacá region of northern Chile. The skull is elongated, there are fewer ribs than expected, and the bone looks older than the size suggests. For years the remains were presented as a possible non-human being, and the genome paper says a documentary hypothesized "a preserved humanoid or possible evidence of alien life."
This page treats Ata as a human individual and uses respectful terms throughout. It carries no image of the remains.
The adherents' reading
Those who held the earlier readings took the unusual skull, the rib count and the apparent age of the bone as signs of something other than an ordinary human infant. Nolan and Butte describe the coverage that followed, and the 2018 paper lists the hypotheses it tested.
The mainstream view
Bhattacharya and colleagues (Genome Research, 2018; senior authors Garry Nolan and Atul Butte) report that "Ata is a female of human origin, likely of Chilean descent." They found mutations in seven genes linked to short stature, rib anomalies, cranial malformation, premature joint fusion and skeletal dysplasia, and write that "it seems likely the specimen was a preterm birth."
Reported ages differ. Stanford's release says the skeleton is approximately 40 years old. Nolan and Butte's later statement says the DNA proved it "500 years old or less," possibly "considerably younger," and that the film team had claimed thousands of years.
The dispute over how Ata was studied
Nolan and Butte say the remains "should be repatriated and accorded proper respect as human remains," that they are "now privately held by an individual in Spain," and that none of the senior authors has seen or handled them. BBC Mundo (29 March 2018) reports that Chile's National Monuments Council lodged a complaint asking whether the remains were illegally exhumed in 2003 and taken out of the country. La Tercera (28 November 2018) quotes the prosecutor Hardy Torres on the inquiry. In coverage reprinted by the Sociedad de Bioquímica y Biología Molecular de Chile, Chilean researchers asked whether the ethics of the skeleton's origin were considered before the analysis, and whether Chilean law was broken when the body left the country. No return or burial is documented.
The adherents' answer
Those who held the earlier readings answer that the question was open when the research began. What should happen to the remains?