The case
The "Starchild Skull" is a small, thin-boned skull of a child. In Lloyd Pye's account it was found around 1930 in an abandoned mine tunnel in the Copper Canyon region of northern Mexico, about 100 miles southwest of Chihuahua. Its owners met him in El Paso in February 1999. He wrote that separate radiocarbon tests dated the skull to about 900 years ago.
This page carries no image of the skull.
The adherents' reading
Pye listed "two dozen major physiological differences" and wrote that "DNA testing performed in 2003 showed conclusively that its mother was human but its father was something other than 100% human." In 2011 he reported four mitochondrial DNA fragments totalling 1,583 base pairs with 93 differences from the human reference, which he extrapolated to 976 across the whole genome, against a human maximum he gave as 120. These figures are his own.
Dr Ted Robinson wrote in 2004 that the skull's provenance "is not verified at present" and that its morphology is "so highly unusual as to be unique in my forty years of experience."
The mainstream view
Steven Novella (2006) wrote that "Conservative scientists are convinced that the skull represents a severe congenital abnormality, but require more thorough examination before they can be more specific." Skeptoid reports Novella's view that the probable medical consensus is hydrocephaly.
Trace Genetics, the laboratory that tested the skull, reported on 12 August 2003 that its mitochondrial DNA is "consistent with Native American haplogroup C," and that "the inability to analyze nuclear DNA indicates that such DNA is either not present or present in sufficiently low copy number to prevent PCR analysis." The report does not address paternity.
The adherents' answer
Pye argued that hydrocephalic individuals "remain purely human, with normal human eye sockets, normal bone thickness in the non-expanded areas, a neck in the normal position," and that the skull "has none of those morphological features." Robinson's report adds that a radiologist noted no erosion of the inner table of the skull, which Robinson says rules out hydrocephaly. What does the skull show?