The case
Small three-fingered bodies said to come from southern Peru have been shown to the public since about 2017. "Mummies" is in quotation marks on this page because Peru's forensic institute says the seized figures it examined are not mummies.
On 12 September 2023, Mexico's Chamber of Deputies held a hearing at which two bodies were presented as beings found in Peru. Jaime Maussan, who presented them, said they were found in 2017 between Palpa and Nazca, that "they are beings that are not part of our earthly evolution," and that carbon-14 analysis at UNAM gave "around 1,000 years." On 7 November 2023 the chamber held a second session at which, AP reports, a Peruvian physician showed X-rays and photographs of a find he said was recent.
On 12 January 2024 in Lima, Peru's forensic institute and Ministry of Culture presented results on two figures seized in October 2023 at the airport as they were about to be sent to Mexico, and on a three-fingered hand handed in during April 2019. The press note says the figures are "constructions, with the same anatomical forms as a human being, made with animal bones joined with synthetic adhesives," and the hand is "composed of human bones, cotton and glue." DW and EFE both say the seized figures were very similar to, not the same as, the bodies shown in Mexico. EFE places the Mexican bodies' origin at Cuzco where DW says Palpa and Nazca.
The adherents' reading
Adherents take the Mexican presentations as showing non-human beings, and take the laboratory dating as support. Maussan's statements to the chamber, and the second session's X-rays and photographs, are the basis of this reading.
The mainstream view
On 9 November 2024, Peru's Congress held a hearing led by the congressman Germán Tacuri, which El Comercio says lasted almost three hours. The forensic archaeologist Flavio Estrada told El Comercio that the arguments for authenticity "lacked scientific support" and that the larger bodies are altered human remains of archaeological origin.
UNAM's Instituto de Física says its work only dates samples and "in no case do we draw conclusions about the origin of those samples."
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that the laboratory did return an age of about 1,000 years, and that Peru examined different objects from those shown in Mexico. The sources agree on the second point: the seized figures were very similar to the Mexican bodies, and not the same. What do the hearings actually settle?