Browse all theories tagged with this keyword
The "Starchild Skull" is a small, thin-boned skull of a child. In Lloyd Pye's account it was found around 1930 in an abandoned mine tunnel in the Copper Canyon region of northern Mexico, about 100 miles southwest of Chihuahua, and its owners met him in El Paso in February 1999. He wrote that separate radiocarbon tests dated the skull to about 900 years ago. Pye listed "two dozen major physiological differences" and wrote that "DNA testing performed in 2003 showed conclusively that its mother was human but its father was something other than 100% human". In 2011 he reported four mitochondrial DNA fragments totalling 1,583 base pairs with 93 differences from the human reference, which he extrapolated to 976 across the whole genome, against a human maximum he gave as 120. Dr Ted Robinson wrote in 2004 that the skull's provenance "is not verified at present" and that its morphology is "so highly unusual as to be unique in my forty years of experience". Steven Novella (2006) wrote that "Conservative scientists are convinced that the skull represents a severe congenital abnormality, but require more thorough examination before they can be more specific." Skeptoid reports Novella's view that the probable medical consensus is hydrocephaly. Trace Genetics, the laboratory that tested the skull, reported on 12 August 2003 that its mitochondrial DNA is "consistent with Native American haplogroup C", and that "the inability to analyze nuclear DNA indicates that such DNA is either not present or present in sufficiently low copy number to prevent PCR analysis". The report does not address paternity. Pye argued that hydrocephalic individuals "remain purely human, with normal human eye sockets, normal bone thickness in the non-expanded areas, a neck in the normal position", and that the skull "has none of those morphological features". Robinson's report adds that a radiologist noted no erosion of the inner table of the skull, which Robinson says rules out hydrocephaly.
Small three-fingered bodies said to come from southern Peru have been shown to the public since about 2017. "Mummies" is in quotation marks because Peru's forensic institute says the seized figures it examined are not mummies. On 12 September 2023, Mexico's Chamber of Deputies held a hearing, at which two bodies were presented as beings found in Peru. Jaime Maussan, who presented them, said they were found in 2017 between Palpa and Nazca, that "they are beings that are not part of our earthly evolution", and that UNAM carbon-14 analysis gave "around 1,000 years". On 7 November 2023 the chamber held a second session at which, AP reports, a Peruvian physician showed X-rays and photographs of a find he said was recent. On 12 January 2024 in Lima, Peru's forensic institute and Ministry of Culture presented results on two figures seized in October 2023 at the airport as they were about to be sent to Mexico, and on a three-fingered hand handed in during April 2019. The press note says the figures are "constructions, with the same anatomical forms as a human being, made with animal bones joined with synthetic adhesives", and the hand is "composed of human bones, cotton and glue". DW and EFE both say the seized figures were very similar to, not the same as, the bodies shown in Mexico. EFE places the Mexican bodies' origin at Cuzco where DW says Palpa and Nazca. On 9 November 2024, Peru's Congress held a hearing led by congressman Germán Tacuri, which El Comercio says lasted almost three hours. Forensic archaeologist Flavio Estrada told El Comercio that the arguments for authenticity "lacked scientific support" and that the larger bodies are altered human remains of archaeological origin. UNAM's Instituto de Física says its work only dates samples and "in no case do we draw conclusions about the origin of those samples". Adherents answer that the laboratory did return an age of about 1,000 years, and that Peru examined different objects from those shown in Mexico.
The remains known as "Ata" are of a very small individual, about 15 cm (6 in) long according to the 2018 genome paper, reported to have been found in 2003 at La Noria, in the Tarapacá region of northern Chile. The skull is elongated, there are fewer ribs than expected, and the bone looks older than the size suggests. For years the remains were presented as a possible non-human being, and the genome paper says a documentary hypothesized "a preserved humanoid or possible evidence of alien life". Bhattacharya et al. (Genome Research, 2018; senior authors Garry Nolan and Atul Butte) report that "Ata is a female of human origin, likely of Chilean descent", with mutations in seven genes linked to short stature, rib anomalies, cranial malformation, premature joint fusion and skeletal dysplasia, and that "it seems likely the specimen was a preterm birth". Reported ages differ: Stanford's release says the skeleton is approximately 40 years old; Nolan and Butte's later statement says the DNA proved it "500 years old or less", possibly "considerably younger", and that the film team had claimed thousands of years. Nolan and Butte say the remains "should be repatriated and accorded proper respect as human remains", that they are "now privately held by an individual in Spain", and that none of the senior authors has seen or handled them. BBC Mundo (29 March 2018) reports that Chile's National Monuments Council lodged a complaint asking whether the remains were illegally exhumed in 2003 and taken out of the country. La Tercera (28 November 2018) quotes prosecutor Hardy Torres on the inquiry. In coverage reprinted by the Sociedad de Bioquímica y Biología Molecular de Chile, Chilean researchers asked whether the ethics of the skeleton's origin were considered before the analysis, and whether Chilean law was broken when the body left the country. No return or burial is documented. Those who held the earlier readings answer that the question was open when the research began.