The case
Otodus megalodon, formerly Carcharocles, is the largest shark known from the fossil record, and its teeth are common finds. On 4 August 2013 the Discovery Channel opened Shark Week with "Megalodon: The Monster Shark Lives." National Geographic says Discovery calls the film "dramatized." It used actors playing scientists who hunt a live 67-foot (20 metre) shark, nicknamed "Submarine," off South Africa. National Geographic reports that Discovery aired disclaimers but also said that "sightings of 'Submarine' continue to this day."
The Atlantic (6 August 2013) reports around 5 million viewers, a Shark Week record. It quotes the blogger Christie Wilcox that, by Discovery's own poll, "upwards of 70%" of viewers came away believing megalodon is not extinct.
The adherents' reading
People who keep the idea open point to how little of the deep sea has been surveyed. Snopes grants that "it's not absolutely impossible that an undocumented species of huge shark lives in the oceans' depths."
The mainstream view
Two fossil studies give two extinction dates, and they are not blended here. Pimiento and Clements (PLOS ONE, 2014) applied an optimal linear estimation model to the fossil record and concluded that the species "went extinct around 2.6 Ma." Boessenecker and colleagues (PeerJ, 2019) found that every record from the eastern North Pacific later than the early Pliocene shows reworking or lacks reliable provenance. They put the extinction at about 3.6 Ma, and gave a median of 3.51 Ma when they re-ran the earlier dataset.
National Geographic says megalodon's skeleton was mostly cartilage, so "nothing remains of the creature except its teeth." Snopes rates the film's capsized-boat claim False and quotes the marine scientist Daniel Holstein: "There's about as much scientific controversy about the possibility of Megalodons lurking in today's oceans as there is about mermaids. None."
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that those dates are model estimates from a limited record, and that a last-occurrence estimate says when the fossil record ends and nothing about what lives unseen. Is the shark gone?