The case
The National Science and Media Museum (2012) says that in 1917 Frances Griffiths and her cousin Elsie Wright began a series of five photographs, showing the girls with fairies, at Cottingley Beck. In 1920 the photographs reached Edward Gardner of the Theosophical Society and then Arthur Conan Doyle, who published the first two in the Christmas 1920 Strand Magazine under the names "Alice" and "Iris," according to the Leeds Library and Bradford Museums. Joe Cooper gives the first Strand publication as the end of 1919. Gardner supplied a camera and marked plates, and three more photographs followed in August 1920. Doyle's The Coming of the Fairies (1922) set out the case.
The adherents' reading
Doyle's book opens by saying the incidents were "either the most elaborate and ingenious hoax ever played upon the public" or "an event in human history which may in the future appear to have been epoch-making in its character." Adherents take the second possibility seriously, and point to Frances's statement that the fifth photograph is genuine, and to Cooper's remark that whether fairies exist "remains an open question."
The mainstream view
In a letter to the photographic journalist Geoffrey Crawley dated 17 February 1983, Elsie, by then Elsie Hill, said all five photographs were staged. The Science and Media Museum reports it, and the Leeds Library says she "finally wrote a letter of confession in 1983."
Joe Cooper's interview in The Unexplained, cited as issue 117 of 1982 though the Guardian says 1983, reports that "in late 1981 and mid 1982 respectively" Frances, later Way, and Elsie, later Hill, admitted the first four were fakes, made from gift-book illustrations fixed in place with hatpins. The sources give differing dates for the book and for Cooper's publication, and this page does not choose between them.
The adherents' answer
Frances said until her death that the fifth photograph, "Fairy Sunbath, Elves, etc.," was genuine and that she had seen fairies at the beck, according to the Science and Media Museum, Bradford Museums and Cooper. She told Cooper: "I saw these fairies building up in the grasses and just aimed the camera and took a photograph." Both photographers are deceased: Frances Griffiths 1907 to 1986 and Elsie Wright 1901 to 1988, according to the Museum. What, if anything, did they see?