The case
The Holy Lance in Vienna's imperial treasury is, according to the Kunsthistorisches Museum (KHM), a Carolingian winged lance of the 8th century. The KHM says "pious wishful thinking" turned an iron pin set in the blade into one of the nails of the cross, and that in the 13th century the lance came to be seen as that of Longinus.
Trevor Ravenscroft's The Spear of Destiny says that Hitler was obsessed with the lance. Time quotes the line "Whomsoever claims this spear and solves its secrets holds the destiny of the world in his hands." The book's date differs by source: 1972 (Bad Archaeology, naming Neville Spearman) or 1973 (All About History). Sky HISTORY says American forces located the lance "just two hours" before Hitler's death on 30 April 1945.
The adherents' reading
Adherents take Ravenscroft's account of the lance and of Hitler's interest in it as the starting point. The lance's later attribution to Longinus, and the legend of its power, are the frame in which they read the Vienna object.
The mainstream view
Robert Feather, a British metallurgist, examined the lance in 2003 (Time Europe, 8 June 2003) and "found the main body of the spear to be medieval, dating to the 7th century at the earliest," which is compatible with the KHM's 8th century.
Bad Archaeology, a blog by the museum curator Keith Fitzpatrick-Matthews, says Ravenscroft "admitted in 1982" that his contact with his source, Walter Johannes Stein, was "conducted entirely through a medium," and that the book's style is "decidedly novelistic." These are the blog's claims. All About History says Stein said nothing of such a claim in his lifetime.
The sources also differ on the recovery. Bad Archaeology says Walter Horn of the US Army found the regalia's hiding place in 1946. A US Army account says that on 7 August 1945 Horn located several missing pieces of the Imperial Regalia, including the crown, orb, scepter and two swords, and that the regalia returned to Austria on 4 January 1946.
The adherents' answer
Feather also told Time that the iron pin is "consistent" in length and shape with a first-century Roman nail, that science cannot date the iron fragments around it, and that "We're in the realm of speculation, but you cannot rule it out." Adherents answer that the pin cannot be ruled out as a first-century nail. What does the metal actually show?