Paperclip was to bar active Nazis, yet the JIOA asked for revised security reports so some scientists could still come.
The program brought German and Austrian scientists, engineers and technicians to the United States after 1945. What was hidden was the Nazi Party and SS records of many of them; the means, as the records print it, were classified files and security reports revised at the request of the Pentagon agency running the program; the reasons given were the value of German weapons expertise and the wish to deny it to the Soviet Union. The facts came out in the 1980s, when files were declassified and the Justice Department moved against one engineer.
The plan Truman approved, 1946
A top secret memorandum of 30 August 1946 from Acting Secretary of State Dean Acheson to President Truman, printed in Foreign Relations of the United States, says the War Department had run a project known as "Paperclip" since shortly after V-E Day, bringing selected German scientists under military custody for short-term exploitation. It proposed expanding Paperclip to between 800 and 1,000 specialists, certified by the Joint Chiefs' designated agency, "now JIOA," with families brought over and selected persons later granted regular immigration status. The enclosed policy said no one found to have been a Nazi Party member "and more than a nominal participant in its activities, or an active supporter of Nazism or militarism" would be brought over, but that position or honours awarded "solely on account of his scientific or technical ability" would not in themselves disqualify. A handwritten notation reads "Approved 9/3/46 Harry S Truman."
FRUS 1946, Acheson to Truman: https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1946v05/d448
The JIOA and its dossiers
The National Archives' description of the Joint Intelligence Objectives Agency records says the JIOA was set up in 1945 under the Joint Chiefs of Staff and given direct responsibility for the foreign scientist program, first code-named Overcast. Its duties included administering the program and "compiling dossiers"; it was disbanded in 1962. Its Foreign Scientist Case Files, 1945-1958, hold dossiers on more than 1,500 scientists, technicians and engineers. The description names Georg Rickhey, a Nordhausen V-2 factory official tried and acquitted of war crimes in 1947; Walter Schreiber, who had been "instrumental in medical experiments on concentration camp inmates" and fled to Argentina in 1952; and Arthur Rudolph. It notes that the dossier on Wernher von Braun "was never transferred to NARA."
National Archives, RG 330 JIOA records: https://www.archives.gov/iwg/declassified-records/rg-330-defense-secretary
The GAO report, 1985
The General Accounting Office report of 28 June 1985, GAO/GGD-85-66, answered a House Judiciary request on whether federal programs helped Nazi war criminals immigrate and concealed their backgrounds; it found no such program but identified five people with questionable backgrounds who got individual help, two later protected from investigation. On Paperclip it says the military's security investigations "revealed that the majority of Paperclip recruits were Nazi party members or members of its affiliates," and that in April 1948 the JIOA's director said too much emphasis was being placed on Nazi affiliations and that Nazism as a security threat "had been destroyed by the war." It counts 528 scientists and engineers recruited by April 1951, 459 of whom immigrated, and says the recruitment would also deny other nations, "particularly the Soviet Union," their services.
GAO/GGD-85-66, June 1985: https://archive.org/details/cia-readingroom-document-cia-rdp87m01152r000300410001-8
Revised security reports, 1999
The interim report of the Nazi War Criminal Records Interagency Working Group, October 1999, says the JIOA needed presidential authority because so many of the scientists had been members of Nazi organizations, and that Wernher von Braun had been an SS officer. It says a Justice and State panel began in early 1947 to review dossiers prepared in Germany; where a scientist had been classified as an actual or potential security threat on the basis of a Nazi past, the panel rejected the Pentagon's request. "Consequently, the JIOA director wired the director of intelligence at the U.S. European Command (EUCOM) and requested that 'revised' security reports be prepared, in some cases, so scientists could participate in Paperclip." It says 765 specialists came between 1945 and 1955, and that perhaps as many as 80 percent had been Nazi Party members.
IWG interim report, October 1999: https://www.archives.gov/iwg/reports/nazi-war-crimes-interim-report-october-1999
The Justice Department history, 2008
"The Office of Special Investigations: Striving for Accountability in the Aftermath of the Holocaust," by Judy Feigin, dated December 2008, says Paperclip was designed to exclude anyone more than a "nominal participant" in Nazi activities. It says Arthur Rudolph, operations director at the Mittelwerk V-2 factory in the Dora-Nordhausen camp complex, arrived in December 1945, and that the immigration service knew of his party membership and his work at Mittelwerk but that there is no indication it had any information about his use of slave labor. It says thousands of prisoners died there. Rudolph became a citizen in 1954 and retired from NASA in 1969. Facing prosecution, he agreed in writing to leave and renounce his citizenship, the United States agreeing to withhold any announcement until he had gone; he left for Germany in October 1984. It calls him the only Paperclip scientist OSI prosecuted.
DOJ, OSI history, December 2008: https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/criminal/legacy/2011/03/14/12-2008osu-accountability.pdf
The museum's account
Michael J. Neufeld, senior curator at the National Air and Space Museum, writes that roughly half of the early Paperclip specialists had been Nazi Party members, that von Braun had been a party member and SS officer, and that "the U.S. Army kept that information classified" when it brought him and about 125 colleagues to Fort Bliss. He writes that the Cold War made it easier to "sweep their past under the rug," on the argument that the weapons programs needed them or that their knowledge must be denied to the Soviets. He calls "the coverup of the Nazi records of many of the specialists" the program's moral cost, and says the facts came out only in the 1980s, when the files were declassified.
National Air and Space Museum: https://airandspace.si.edu/stories/editorial/project-paperclip-and-american-rocketry-after-world-war-ii
What was hidden
The 1946 rule barred active Nazis. The records show that most recruits had Nazi affiliations, that the agency running the program asked for revised security reports where a Nazi past blocked entry, and that the Army kept von Braun's SS record classified. The stated reasons were weapons expertise and denial to the Soviet Union. The records stayed closed until the 1980s.
