The case
Snopes reports that the "Montauk Monster" was a carcass photographed on 13 July 2008 on a beach in Montauk, Long Island. Discover reports that the East Hampton newspaper The Independent first ran pictures and that Gawker posted them online. The animal looked hairless and bloated, with what many viewers read as a beak. Skeptical Inquirer lists the suggestions made: a shell-less sea turtle, a dog or other canid, a sheep, a rodent, a latex fake, or a mutation experiment at the nearby Plum Island Animal Disease Center.
The remains were never made available for examination, and every identification is therefore from photographs.
The adherents' reading
Adherents take the open question at face value. The first readings were mixed, and no one examined the carcass. Newsday, as quoted by Snopes, records William Wise, director of Stony Brook University's Living Marine Resources Institute, saying it was not a raccoon ("The legs appear to be too long in proportion to the body"), not a sea turtle ("Sea turtles do not have teeth") and not a rodent. His "best, educated guess" was "A talented someone who got very creative with latex," with "A dog or coyote that was diseased and has been in the sea for a while" next.
The mainstream view
Other specialists, working from the same photographs, identified a raccoon. The wildlife biologist Jeff Corwin, on Fox News, said "It appears to be an incredibly rare raccoon" (hamptons.com, 31 July 2008). Larry Penny, East Hampton's director of natural resources, said "We thought it could be a raccoon that was skinned and has its upper jaw missing" (Discover). The paleontologist Darren Naish (Tetrapod Zoology) pointed to the "very strange, elongate, almost human-like fingers with short claws" and wrote that the "beak" is "just a defleshed snout region." Joe Nickell (Skeptical Inquirer) concluded that the best evidence indicated an identifiable raccoon.
Snopes rates the claim "Mixture" and says "no definitive determination" was made, because the remains were never examined.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that every identification, the raccoon one included, rests on photographs, so none was tested against the carcass. What was on that beach?