The case
In 1964 the Soviet astronomer Nikolai Kardashev ranked civilizations by the energy they command. In the scanned paper, a Type I civilization uses about 4 x 10^19 erg per second, or 4 x 10^12 watts, "close to the level presently attained on the earth." Type II uses about 4 x 10^33 erg per second (4 x 10^26 watts), a civilization harnessing the energy of its own star, and the paper mentions a "Dyson sphere." Type III uses about 4 x 10^44 erg per second (4 x 10^37 watts), the scale of a galaxy.
Four years earlier, Freeman Dyson had proposed in Science that astronomers search for infrared radiation from artificial stellar sources, structures that convert starlight.
Carl Sagan extended the scale. Gray (2020) explains that in The Cosmic Connection (1973) Sagan suggested decimal types, Type 1.0 at 10^16 watts and Type 1.1 at 10^17 watts, and "presented no equation." Sagan classed Earth in 1973, at 10^13 watts, as Type 0.7. The formula often credited to Sagan does not appear in his book, Gray notes. Gray's own update puts Earth around 2015 at Type 0.72.
Why look for such civilizations? Wright and colleagues argue that "detectably large energy supplies can plausibly be expected to exist," because life can grow exponentially until checked by resource limits.
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the scale as a map of where advanced civilizations should be found, and of how far humanity still has to climb.
The mainstream view
Two surveys have used the scale as a search plan. Griffith and colleagues searched about 100,000 galaxies with the WISE satellite, identified 563 extended sources, and found none with more than 85 percent of its starlight reprocessed into mid-infrared. About 50 are consistent with more than 50 percent.
Zackrisson and colleagues analysed 1,359 disk galaxies and set a conservative upper limit of 3 percent on galaxy-wide Dysonian astroengineering. They found that none of the possibly underluminous galaxies "stand out as strong Kardashev type III candidates," and set a tentative limit of 0.3 percent.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that these surveys set upper limits, not zero, and that Earth itself still sits below Type I.