Browse all theories tagged with this keyword
Shortly after radio SETI began, Ronald Bracewell (Nature, 1960) raised the question of whether extraterrestrials might try observing us, as Haqq-Misra and Kopparapu recount. Their Bayesian study (Acta Astronautica, 2012) says extraterrestrial technology may exist in the Solar System without our knowledge, because unpiloted probes would likely remain unnoticed. Benford (AJ, 2019) proposes nearby co-orbital objects as places where a probe could watch Earth while not being easily seen. Villarroel and colleagues (Acta Astronautica, 2022) show that four or five aligned transients among nine on a pre-1957 photographic plate would be a strong indicator of non-terrestrial artefacts. Adherents read this work as a sign that watchers could already be close by, unnoticed. Freitas and Valdes (Icarus, 1980) searched the Earth-Moon L4 and L5 points and found no objects. Davies and Wagner (Acta Astronautica, 2013) propose scanning Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter images at 0.5 m resolution, while noting only a tiny probability of finding alien traces. Adherents answer that most of the Solar System has not been explored at a resolution sharp enough to find such probes.
Kardashev, in Soviet Astronomy (1964), ranked civilizations by energy: Type I at about 4 x 10^12 W, close to the level then reached on Earth; Type II at about 4 x 10^26 W, harnessing its own star; Type III at about 4 x 10^37 W, on the scale of a galaxy. Dyson, in Science (1960), had already proposed searching for infrared from artificial stellar sources. Gray (AJ, 2020) shows that Sagan, in The Cosmic Connection (1973), suggested decimal steps and classed Earth as Type 0.7, though Sagan presented no equation. Wright and colleagues argue that detectably large alien energy supplies can plausibly be expected to exist. Adherents read the scale as a map of where advanced civilizations should be, and of how far humanity has to go. Griffith and colleagues, using WISE on about 100,000 galaxies, found none reprocessing more than 85 percent of their starlight into mid-infrared. Zackrisson and colleagues, studying 1,359 disk galaxies, found none standing out as strong Type III candidates. Adherents answer that these surveys set upper limits, not zero.
Technosignatures are observable signs of technology. Cocconi and Morrison (Nature, 1959) proposed searching for interstellar radio communications. NASA's Technosignatures Workshop (Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston, 26 to 28 September 2018) produced a report edited by Jason Wright and Dawn Gelino, and Wright and coauthors (ApJL 927, L30, 2022) argue technosignatures may be abundant, long-lived, highly detectable and unambiguous. Adherents read this work as a sign that alien technology is now a serious scientific question, and that it may already be in the data. Price and colleagues (AJ 159, 86, 2020) searched 1,138 stars at Green Bank and 189 at Parkes and, after excluding interference, were "left with zero candidates," finding no transmitters above about 2.1 x 10^12 W (Green Bank) and 9.1 x 10^12 W (Parkes). A ten-year Breakthrough Listen review (MacMahon and Czech, arXiv, October 2026) notes that its best-known candidate, BLC1, was ultimately attributed to terrestrial interference, the conclusion Sheikh and colleagues reached with a technosignature verification framework. Adherents answer that these searches covered a small sample of stars and a narrow band of radio frequencies.
A narrowband signal at about 982 MHz was recorded toward Proxima Centauri with the Parkes "Murriyang" telescope in observations that began on 29 April 2019. The Breakthrough Listen team says it persisted over five hours and had some of the expected characteristics of an extraterrestrial transmission. The Guardian reported on 18 December 2020 that scientists were investigating it, and Andrew Siemion told Scientific American: "It has some particular properties that caused it to pass many of our checks, and we cannot yet explain it." Adherents read it as a possible beacon from the nearest star. Smith and colleagues (Nature Astronomy, 2021) attribute it to "an unusual but locally generated form of interference," and Sheikh and colleagues conclude it was an intermodulation product of local interferers, and report dozens of lookalike interference signals at frequencies harmonically related to common clock oscillators. A Research Notes paper reports no re-detection in 39 hours of reobservation. Adherents answer that, in the original observation, the signal appeared only in pointings toward the star.
Siraj and Loeb (arXiv 2019; ApJ 2022) reported that the fireball of 8 January 2014, catalogued as CNEOS 2014-01-08 and later called IM1, came from an unbound hyperbolic orbit "with 99.999% confidence." A U.S. Space Command memorandum dated 1 March 2022 and signed by Lt Gen John E. Shaw, Deputy Commander, repeats that figure as the paper's claim and says Dr Joel Mozer, Chief Scientist of Space Operations Command, "confirmed that the velocity estimate reported to NASA is sufficiently accurate to indicate an interstellar trajectory." From 14 to 28 June 2023, a Galileo Project expedition towed a magnetic sled about 85 km north of Manus Island, Papua New Guinea, and found about 850 spherules; Loeb and colleagues classed 22 percent as differentiated (D-type) and reported a subset with Be, La and U excess "distinctly different from coal fly ash." Adherents say the object was technological, and that pieces of it were recovered. Brown and Borovicka (ApJ 2023) suggest the simplest explanation is that the catalogued speed is substantially overestimated. Vaubaillon (2022) finds no scientific ground to conclude an interstellar orbit and calls finding pieces on the ocean floor extremely unlikely. Rudraswami, Singh and Pandey (Chemical Geology 2025) argue that most of the spherules, including the D-type group, are volcanic. Adherents answer that a U.S. military scientist backed the velocity estimate, and that the chemistry of the unusual spherules is still in dispute.
Dyson proposed in 1960 that advanced civilizations might be found by the infrared glow of the starlight they capture. Project Hephaistos (Suazo and colleagues, MNRAS 2024) screened about five million Gaia, 2MASS and WISE sources and named 7 candidates, all M dwarfs within 300 pc, whose infrared excess known processes cannot easily explain; the paper notes that a Dyson sphere cannot be proven from photometry alone. VASCO (Solano, Villarroel and Rodrigo, MNRAS 2022) lists 298,165 sources seen only on 1950s POSS-I plates, 5,399 still unidentified. Villarroel and colleagues (2021) describe nine point sources that appeared within half an hour on a red plate from 12 April 1950, and Bruehl and Villarroel (2025) report transients 45 percent more likely within one day of a nuclear test. Adherents read the infrared excesses and the vanishing lights as the first outlines of megastructures, or of objects in orbit before Sputnik. Zackrisson and colleagues (2026) used James Webb to trace the excess of candidates D and E to background galaxies. In Scientific American, Nigel Hambly urged checks of the original plates, and Sean Kirkpatrick pointed to nuclear test effects and high-altitude balloons. Adherents answer that the other five candidates were not part of the James Webb study, and that the plate transients are still of unknown origin.