The case
In Intelligent Life in the Universe (1966), Shklovskii and Sagan (Shklovsky in most English writing) worked from Sharpless's 1945 measurements of the orbit of Phobos, a moon of Mars. Explaining the decay of that orbit by atmospheric drag required a very low density. They wrote: "A natural satellite cannot be a hollow object. Therefore, we are led to the possibility that Phobos ... may be artificial satellites of Mars." They added that Sharpless's data "may contain substantial errors."
The second strand is a rock. NASA/JPL's release of a Mars Global Surveyor image from the spacecraft's fourth Phobos pass, on 12 September 1998, shows "several large boulders ... including a very large one near the center that is about 85 meters (~280 feet) in diameter." NASA says most of the boulders "may have been ejected from" Stickney, the largest crater on Phobos. NASA does not use the word monolith. IFLScience (4 February 2025) reports that the boulder became known as the Phobos monolith, and quotes Buzz Aldrin on C-SPAN in 2009: "There's a monolith there."
The adherents' reading
Adherents read the hollow moon calculation and the monolith together as signs that Phobos is a made object.
The mainstream view
Parts and Wright (Research Notes of the AAS, May 2026) write that later observations revealed a slower orbital decay, which updated models account for through tidal friction. They find that Phobos would need to be reduced to 2.1 x 10^-5 of its actual mass to inspiral at the 1966 rate, a change that modern observations could detect within a year.
On density, Science News (14 May 2010), reporting on Mars Express data, gives about 1.87 grams per cubic centimeter and says Phobos may contain as much as 30 percent empty space, possibly a mass of rocky rubble.
The mission
JAXA's Martian Moons eXploration spacecraft launched on 20 October 2026 (Japan time) on H3 Flight No. 10. JAXA states that "the goal is to return more than 10g of material to Earth," with Earth return targeted for 2031.
The adherents' answer
Adherents answer that no piece of Phobos has yet been examined in a laboratory.