The case
This is a living tradition of specific Aboriginal nations, and the page leads with the Ngarrindjeri account as the sources give it. The Ngarrindjeri tell of the Mulyawonk, a water being of the river. In the story given by the Rural City of Murray Bridge and the Murray-Darling Basin Authority, a greedy man took far more fish than he needed. The Elders, angry that he did not respect the Ngarrindjeri laws of fishing, turned him into a half-fish, half-man creature and banished him to the river. Children are told never to swim alone or take more fish than they can eat, and one home of the Mulyawonk is a river cave near Tailem Bend. The council page says the story varies between Lakalinyeri (clans) and that it "teaches children water safety and respect for the fish of the river and lakes." Mark Koolmatrie, of the Ramindjeri and Warki clans, told ABC Science: "We were taught to preserve the environment so the Mulyawonk stays healthy," and "The Mulyawonk story has been told to us forever." The authority reports that a riverside attraction turned fifty in January 2022, marked by an event where people learned the story through Ngarrindjeri dance and music.
The word "bunyip" is a colonial name. The council page says it comes from the Wemba-Wemba or Wergaia language. The Canberra Times reports that banib was a creature known to the Wemba Wemba people, with a similar creature in Wadawurrung stories. Historian David Waldron told the paper: "The white people think they're using Indigenous terminology, but the Indigenous people think they're hearing a white word," and different water creatures from different language groups "get shoehorned into the word bunyip."
Separately, a colonial museum episode took place. Penny Edmonds writes in the Australian Humanities Review that two heads interested colonial scientists. The Macleay Museum head, found at the Hawkesbury River in 1841, is "a confected creature made from a deformed foal's skull and skin." Five years later a squatter found a second skull by the Murrumbidgee River, and it was displayed at the Colonial Museum of Sydney the following year as a possible bunyip. It "has since become lost." This page treats it as a story about settlers' expectations, not as evidence about what the Aboriginal tradition means.
The adherents' reading
Edmonds writes that scientists at the time declared the Murrumbidgee specimen to be from a strange and unknown species. Patrick Nunn and Luiza Ponciano suggest, in The Conversation, that some stories may preserve memories of extinct megafauna. They point to an 1846 account of bunyips "as tall as gum trees" that "tore trees out by their roots," which they say recalls Palorchestes azael. This is their hypothesis.
The mainstream view
Edmonds records that the naturalist William Sharp Macleay judged the Murrumbidgee skull, like the Hawkesbury one, "likewise the misshapen foetus of a mare." Nunn and Ponciano write that "we shall never be able to prove conclusively" the megafauna link. They also suggest the name may recently have been given to the rakali, or water-rat.
The adherents' answer
Those who keep the Mulyawonk teaching are not adherents of an animal reading, and they do not argue the question of a specimen. Koolmatrie, the council and the Murray-Darling Basin Authority describe a living story told forever, about caring for the river and taking only what is needed.