1Malaysia Development Berhad was described, in the pleading that opened the United States civil case, as a strategic investment and development company wholly owned by the government of Malaysia, ostensibly created to pursue investment and development projects for the economic benefit of Malaysia and its people, funded by debt securities. The same pleading alleges that between about 2009 and at least 2013, officials and associates diverted billions, laundered proceeds through U.S. banks, and spent them on real estate, gambling, art, and films, while 1MDB kept no interest in those assets. That is the denial the complaints name: a development fund on the letterhead, and money that left the development story. The doors fetched for this page say “Malaysian Official 1” and “1MDB Official.” This page does not fill in a name the pleadings withheld, and it does not treat a civil allegation as a criminal finding.
Three Phases in the July 2016 Complaint
On 20 July 2016 the United States filed a civil forfeiture complaint in the Central District of California, CV 16-5362, against profits, royalties, and distribution proceeds of The Wolf of Wall Street, held by Red Granite Pictures. It is in rem, and it alleges the asset is traceable to money taken from 1MDB. It divides the conduct into three phases. Good Star, about September 2009 through 2011: under the pretense of a PetroSaudi joint venture, more than $1 billion moved from 1MDB to a Swiss account in the name of Good Star Limited. Banks were told a false story about who owned it. The complaint alleges the beneficial owner was Low Taek Jho, called Jho Low, who had no formal position at 1MDB, and that he laundered more than $400 million of those funds into the United States. Aabar-BVI, 2012: about $1.367 billion, more than forty percent of net proceeds, left two bond offerings arranged by Goldman Sachs International, bonds guaranteed by 1MDB and by Abu Dhabi’s International Petroleum Investment Company. The money went to Aabar Investments PJS Limited in the British Virgin Islands, named to resemble the real Aabar subsidiary of IPIC. The complaint alleges there was no genuine affiliation. Funds then moved, among other places, to a Singapore account of Tan Kim Loong, called Eric Tan. Tanore, 2013: more than $1.26 billion left a third Goldman-arranged offering of about $3 billion that was supposed to fund a joint venture called ADMIC. Days later, proceeds sat in an account on which the then-executive director of 1MDB was, the complaint alleges, an authorized signatory. Malaysian Official 1 is defined there as a high-ranking Malaysian official who also held authority at 1MDB. Riza Aziz is described as a relative of that official and a co-founder of Red Granite. Allegations, not a verdict.
DOJ — verified complaint, United States v. The Wolf of Wall Street, 20 July 2016: https://www.justice.gov/opa/file/877166/dl
The Parent Information and the Deferred Prosecution
On 22 October 2020 the United States filed a criminal information in the Eastern District of New York, Cr. No. 20-437 (MKB), charging The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. with one count of conspiracy, under 18 U.S.C. § 371, to violate the anti-bribery provisions of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. The information covers 2009 through at least 2014. The same day the parent company entered a deferred prosecution agreement with the Fraud Section, the Money Laundering and Asset Recovery Section, and the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of New York. The agreement sets a criminal penalty of $2,315,088,000 and disgorgement of $606 million, and records a guilty plea by Goldman Sachs Malaysia. The statement of facts incorporated in the Malaysia plea, and the parallel facts in the parent agreement, say Goldman conspired to provide approximately $1.6077 billion to or for the benefit of foreign officials and their relatives, of which about $18.1 million was paid from accounts controlled by Tim Leissner, and that the bribes resulted in Goldman being engaged on three bond offerings that raised approximately $6.5 billion for 1MDB in 2012 and 2013. Those bond and bribe figures are the criminal resolutions’ figures. They are not a retotal of the civil complaint’s phase-by-phase sums.
DOJ — information, United States v. The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc., Cr. No. 20-437: https://www.justice.gov/criminal/criminal-fraud/file/1329911/dl?inline=
DOJ — deferred prosecution agreement, The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc.: https://www.justice.gov/criminal/criminal-fraud/file/1329926/dl?inline=
DOJ — plea agreement, Goldman Sachs (Malaysia) Sdn. Bhd.: https://www.justice.gov/d9/press-releases/attachments/2020/10/22/goldman_malaysia_plea_agreement_0.pdf
What the Department Said in Public That Day
At the press conference that day the Department called 1MDB a fund created by the Malaysian government to promote economic development, and said Goldman helped it raise $6.5 billion in bonds. Officials said co-conspirators siphoned off approximately $2.7 billion and paid approximately $1.6 billion in bribes, and they described a subsidiary guilty plea, a parent deferred prosecution, disgorgement on the order of $600 million, a penalty of about $2.3 billion, and a total over $2.9 billion. The $2.7 billion figure is the press conference’s. It is not the civil complaint’s phase totals added together.
DOJ — press conference transcript, Goldman Sachs and 1MDB, 22 October 2020: https://www.justice.gov/opa/media/1101471/dl?inline=
The SEC’s Parallel Order, as the Commission Announced It
The same day the Securities and Exchange Commission announced charges against The Goldman Sachs Group Inc. for Foreign Corrupt Practices Act violations in connection with the 1MDB bribe scheme. The Commission’s press release says the firm agreed, as part of coordinated resolutions, to pay more than $2.9 billion, including more than $1 billion to settle the SEC’s charges. The order, as the release describes it, finds that beginning in 2012 former senior employees used a third-party intermediary to bribe high-ranking officials in Malaysia and Abu Dhabi, and that the bribes enabled Goldman to obtain business from 1MDB, including underwriting approximately $6.5 billion in bond offerings. The release says the firm consented to a cease-and-desist order and to pay $606.3 million in disgorgement and a $400 million civil penalty, with the disgorgement satisfied by amounts paid to the Government of Malaysia and 1MDB in a related settlement. The criminal agreement’s disgorgement line is $606 million. The SEC release’s line is $606.3 million. This page leaves both numbers on the doors that printed them.
SEC — press release 2020-265, Goldman Sachs charged with FCPA violations: https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2020-265
What Stays Outside L1
The documented core is the U.S. civil complaint’s account of how money left the development-fund story — Good Star, Aabar-BVI, Tanore, and the bond proceeds those names sat on — and the U.S. criminal and SEC resolutions with Goldman: an information, a deferred prosecution of the parent, a guilty plea by the Malaysian subsidiary, and the penalty and disgorgement figures those instruments state. Malaysian political narrative about who Malaysian Official 1 was, and any domestic case beyond these doors, is outside this file. Contested / L2. The verdict is not flipped.
