The case
These are two threads, and this page does not claim that one caused the other.
The first is a radio song. The Cadillac News reports that on 1 April 1987 WTCM-FM in Traverse City, Michigan, played a spoken-word song, "The Legend," twice, at 7 a.m. and 9 a.m., with no set-up from the morning host. Steve Cook, then the station's production director, had written the lyrics in a rush and recorded them on a keyboard at the station, as an April Fools' Day prank about a half-man, half-dog creature. MyNorth puts it this way: "It was just a joke, he says, until the sighting reports started coming in." Cook told WCMU Public Media that he recalls no reaction until about an hour after the host went off the air, and that when the station started looking into the history of the creature, "it turns out, it actually had one." MyNorth reports that Cook sells copies of the song and gives all proceeds to local animal shelters, an estimated 50,000 dollars. This page uses only Cook's published statements.
The second thread is in Wisconsin. On 29 December 1991 Linda Godfrey reported in The Week, of Elkhorn, on talk of a wolfish creature that ran on two legs near Bray Road. This page does not describe the witnesses in that article. The Chicago Tribune writes that the creature was allegedly first seen there in 1936, and that reports share a handful of recurring features, pointy ears, a long muzzle, sharp claws and walking on two feet, though heights and colours vary. It adds that local farmers offer themed hayrides and that Elkhorn has hosted a Halloween festival for several years. This page states no attack or injury claims as fact.
The adherents' reading
Adherents take the reports, in Michigan and in Wisconsin, as the trace of a real, unknown animal. In Godfrey's account the creature was a wolf-like animal that moved on two legs.
The mainstream view
Cook describes himself as a skeptic. He told WCMU: "There's really nothing that I've seen that cements it for me," and said footage is "always just a little bit grainy." In Godfrey's 1991 article the county humane officer's best guess was "a coyote or even a wolf." Dan Plutchak's 2006 column lists local theories "from buffalo kept by local farmers" to an escaped bighorn sheep. The Tribune calls the photographs blurry and quotes the researcher Chad Lewis: "it's probably not a solvable thing. It's a belief; you can't solve it."
The adherents' answer
The Tribune reports that Godfrey, who died at 71 in 2022, gathered hundreds of eyewitness sightings. She liked to say most witnesses seemed credible and sane, and she came to believe that if the creature existed it was an undiscovered species. Her answer rests on the number and the character of the witnesses rather than on any single photograph.