The case
People in southern Florida have reported a large, hairy, upright animal with a strong smell, most often in the Everglades. Smithsonian Magazine dates one of the earliest well-publicised sightings to a pair of hunters in 1957, says the name "skunk ape" surfaced sometime in the 1960s, and says reports increased in the 1960s and 1970s and came from as far north as the panhandle. Mental Floss likewise says sightings peaked in those two decades.
The legislature took up the animal twice. Mental Floss says that in 1977 Representative Paul Nuckolls of Fort Myers sought to pass House Bill 1664, making it a misdemeanor to "take, possess, harm or molest anthropoid or humanoid animals." Mental Floss says it passed committee and was withdrawn before a vote, and quotes Nuckolls: "I'd hate to see someone catch one and put it in a circus or in a zoo." The Florida Department of State's Florida Memory Blog tells it differently. It says House Bill 1664 failed to pass, and that House Bill 58 passed the House Criminal Justice Committee on 13 October 1977 and then died without passing. The State Archives of Florida holds a record of House Bill 58, "The Florida Skunk Ape Protection Act," dated 1978, and notes that it did not pass. The sources differ, and this page follows each as it is written.
In 2001 the Tampa Tribune's Steve Otto reported that a Sarasota County Sheriff's Office desk report of 18 January logged a mailing under "Suspicious Incident." It was an anonymous letter with two photographs of an animal that had taken apples off a porch, "about six and a half to seven feet tall." The letter asked, "Is someone missing an orangutan?" Mental Floss says the letter was sent in December 2000. The writer was never identified, and this page names no one connected with it.
The adherents' reading
Dave Shealy, in his own published statements, says he first saw one at the age of ten, in 1974, has seen them on three other occasions, and filmed one in July 2000 (Smithsonian). He tells Atlas Obscura that seven to nine live in the Everglades. Loren Coleman told the Sarasota Herald-Tribune, "Maybe it's a breeding population of unknown apes." Adherents read the reports, the bills and the photographs as the trace of a real primate.
The mainstream view
Smithsonian quotes Bob DeGross, public affairs officer at Big Cypress: "there has never been a substantiated sighting of the skunk ape that was verified by National Park Service wildlife staff." Smithsonian says trail cameras in many research projects have captured no proof, and quotes Sharon Hill: "The empirical evidence is extremely weak," "almost entirely eyewitness testimony." It also notes that primates have escaped in Florida, and that there is no fossil evidence that the extinct mega-apes some believers cite ever lived in the Americas. Smithsonian reports that Coleman and a Canadian Wildlife Service biologist agreed with the orangutan reading of the 2000 photographs.
The adherents' answer
Shealy tells Smithsonian that remains decompose quickly in the swamp, which covers 2.2 million acres, most of it rarely visited. "I know what I've seen," he says. Adherents add that the unidentified letter writer's two photographs remain the only record of that porch visit, and that an absence of verified remains in so large a wetland is what an animal hard to find would leave.