Accounts and products customers did not request were opened so Wells Fargo’s cross-sell numbers held. In September 2016 the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s consent order found that Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. had opened unauthorized deposit accounts and transferred funds into them without customers’ knowledge or consent, submitted credit-card applications in consumers’ names without consent, enrolled consumers in online banking they did not request, and ordered and activated debit cards without consent. The Bureau’s newsroom summary of that action, citing the bank’s own analysis, put the deposit figure at roughly 1.5 million accounts that may not have been authorized and credit-card applications at roughly 565,000 that may not have been authorized, and recorded a $100 million civil money penalty to the Bureau, a $35 million penalty to the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, and $50 million to the City and County of Los Angeles. The sales story sold to investors was needs-based cross-sell. The enforcement record is unauthorized volume under pressure.
What the CFPB Consent Order Settles
The consent order states the bank’s business had emphasized “cross-selling” products to existing customers and that compensation incentives rewarded opening new accounts. Employees opened deposit accounts without consent and used simulated funding — moving money from authorized accounts — so the new accounts would look funded. They applied for credit cards without consent, issued debit cards and created PINs without telling consumers, and enrolled people in online banking with phony contact details. The order requires redress and a $100 million civil money penalty. Those are Bureau findings and directions in a consented order, not a jury verdict against a named chief executive.
CFPB — Consent Order, Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. (September 2016): https://files.consumerfinance.gov/f/documents/092016_cfpb_WFBconsentorder.pdf
CFPB — newsroom release on the $100 million fine and unauthorized accounts: https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/consumer-financial-protection-bureau-fines-wells-fargo-100-million-widespread-illegal-practice-secretly-opening-unauthorized-accounts/
What the OCC Added
The same month the OCC issued Cease and Desist Order EA 2016-077 against Wells Fargo Bank, N.A., identifying deficiencies and unsafe or unsound practices in risk management and oversight of sales practices, and unsafe or unsound sales practices themselves — including selling unwanted deposit or credit-card accounts, unauthorized openings, and simulated funding. The OCC’s news release of 8 September 2016 states that the agency assessed a $35 million civil money penalty and ordered restitution and corrective action. Prudential-regulator language sits beside the Bureau’s consumer-protection order. Neither document is a personal criminal conviction of a chief executive officer.
OCC — Cease and Desist / CMP Order EA 2016-077: https://www.occ.gov/static/enforcement-actions/ea2016-077.pdf
OCC — NR 2016-106, $35 million civil money penalty: https://occ.gov/news-issuances/news-releases/2016/nr-occ-2016-106.html
Cross-Sell as the Investor Story
The Department of Justice Statement of Facts that Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. and Wells Fargo & Company admitted in February 2020 describes the Community Bank’s “cross-sell strategy” and the published Community Bank “cross-sell metric” — products per retail bank household — as central to what the company told investors. From at least 2000 until the third quarter of 2016 that metric appeared in Annual Reports and SEC forms. Internally, “gaming” meant manipulating or misrepresenting sales to meet goals: forged signatures, unauthorized accounts, simulated funding, unauthorized credit cards and bill-pay products, altered contact information. From 2002 to 2016 the company opened millions of accounts or financial products that were unauthorized or fraudulent, collected millions of dollars in fees and interest to which it was not entitled, and misused customers’ identifying information. Between 2011 and 2016 it referred more than 23,000 employees for sales-practices investigation and terminated over 5,300 for customer-facing sales ethics violations. The Statement of Facts names “Executive A” as the senior executive vice president in charge of the Community Bank from 2007 to 2016. The Statement of Facts does not itself convict a chief executive.
DOJ — Exhibit A, Statement of Facts (21 February 2020): https://www.justice.gov/d9/press-releases/attachments/2020/02/21/wells_fargo_-_exhibit_a_-_statement_of_facts_0.pdf
The SEC Cease-and-Desist
On the same day the Securities and Exchange Commission entered a cease-and-desist order under Exchange Act Section 21C (Release No. 88257; File No. 3-19704). The Commission found that from 2012 through 2016 the company misled investors about a “needs-based” sales strategy while the Community Bank ran a volume-based model, that unauthorized and low-value accounts inflated the cross-sell metric, and that Wells Fargo violated Exchange Act Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5. The order imposes a $500,000,000 civil money penalty and notes that the company entered a deferred prosecution agreement acknowledging responsibility for criminal conduct relating to the findings — specifically, responsibility for violations of 18 U.S.C. §§ 1005 and 1028A in the DPA with the United States Attorney’s Offices. The February 2020 resolution is a company deferred-prosecution agreement. It does not itself convict a chief executive.
SEC — Order, Wells Fargo & Company (21 February 2020): https://www.sec.gov/files/litigation/admin/2020/34-88257.pdf
Roles, Not Color
The bank and the holding company appear as respondents and admitting parties. Community Bank leadership appears through the Statement of Facts’ officer titles and “Executive A.” Branch employees appear as the workforce the orders say was pressured and, in thousands of cases, investigated or terminated. The cross-sell metric is the published number the doors say was inflated by accounts customers did not request.
What the Paper Trail Settles
Documented: unauthorized deposit accounts, credit cards, debit cards, and online-banking enrollments under sales pressure; CFPB and OCC 2016 consent and cease-and-desist orders with $100 million and $35 million federal penalties in the Bureau and OCC announcements; a 2020 Statement of Facts in which the company admits millions of unauthorized or fraudulent accounts tied to the cross-sell model; an SEC cease-and-desist with a $500 million civil penalty and a company deferred prosecution agreement on false-bank-records and identity-theft statutes. No personal criminal conviction of a chief executive is stated in the consent order, the cease-and-desist orders, or the Statement of Facts.